write an objective summary of “The Interlopers” and explain how its theme develops through the characters, setting and surprise ending.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Which sentence is objective? (a) “Two foolish men waste their lives fighting.” (b) “Two men whose families have feuded for generations are trapped under a fallen tree.” Explain how you can tell.
The two enemies are trapped and in pain. What do you predict will change between them?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
An objective summary retells the most important events in order, in your own words, without opinions or judgments. It names the main characters, the conflict and how it ends. It is short: often 4-6 sentences for a short story.
Worked example 1: removing opinion. Priya’s first draft says, “The stupid feud finally ends in a shocking way.” She revises: “The two men end their feud and wait for rescue, but the figures who arrive are wolves.” She cut “stupid” and “shocking” because they are her judgments.
A model summary. Ulrich von Gradwitz and Georg Znaeym, whose families have fought over a strip of forest for three generations, meet in the forest on a stormy night. A falling beech tree pins them both. At first they threaten each other, each sure his own men will arrive first. As they lie in pain, Ulrich offers friendship, and Georg accepts. They shout for help together, but the figures running toward them are wolves.
Worked example 2: tracing a theme. Malik writes a theme: “Human quarrels look small and foolish beside the power of nature.” He traces it: characters fight over a forest “where the trees can’t even stand upright in a breath of wind”; the setting, a storm, knocks them down; the plot ends with wolves, nature’s own interlopers.
Irony in the ending. Each man prays that his men arrive first so that he can be generous. The reader learns at the same moment as Georg that neither group is coming first. Ulrich’s laugh, “the idiotic chattering laugh of a man unstrung with hideous fear,” tells us before the last word does.
Summary versus analysis. Your summary reports. Your theme paragraph argues. Keep them separate, and your reader will trust both.
Use the passage and the model summary.
Summary first, then theme.
Objective summary: write 4-6 sentences summarizing the whole story. Checklist: main characters named; the conflict; key events in order; the ending; no opinions or judgment words; your own words.
Theme paragraph: state a theme of “The Interlopers” and explain how the characters, the setting and the ending develop it. Use two exact quotations.
Saki made us hope, then took the hope away in one word. Next we return to Montresor and write about the darkest ending in our unit.
Exit ticket: in one sentence, how does Saki make readers hold their breath in the last lines?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 8, mini lesson 8, guided practice 9, summary and theme 11.
Context: the wine-flask offer and Georg’s speech of acceptance come from the same file; the passage cuts Georg’s speech for length, so the summary tells it. Georg’s words of acceptance are in the cut; do not ask students to quote them.
Likely misconceptions: that an objective summary may include “I think”; that the ending means the men were punished for being bad (the story is ironic, not moralizing); that the theme is “nature” (a topic).
Supports: a Somebody-Wanted-But-So-Then frame for the summary; highlight judgment words in a sample and cross them out. Stretch: compare the surprise endings of Saki and Bierce. Which is fairer to the reader?
Sample theme paragraph: The story suggests that human quarrels look small beside the power of nature. The men fight over land “where the trees can’t even stand upright in a breath of wind,” and a storm knocks both down. Their peace comes too late: the figures are “Wolves,” interlopers no family can argue with. Title answer: the wolves are the real interlopers, coming between the men just as Georg said no one would.
Saki (H. H. Munro), The Toys of Peace (1919), Project Gutenberg eBook #1477 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #1477
Where we are. After their threats, both men stop struggling. Ulrich manages to drink from his wine-flask and offers it to Georg, who refuses. In the cut part of the passage, Georg answers Ulrich’s offer and imagines peace between their families. He agrees to be Ulrich’s friend.
What to notice. How does the setting, the cold forest and the wind, affect the men? What does each now pray for? When the figures appear, listen to the clues in the numbers. Then read the last word aloud.
Words to know. Languor is weakness and tiredness. A compact here is an agreement. A reconciliation is making peace after a quarrel. Succour is help in a time of need. Unstrung means badly shaken, losing self-control.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the story and once with a pencil.
Ulrich was silent for a few minutes, and lay listening to the weary screeching of the wind. An idea was slowly forming and growing in his brain, an idea that gained strength every time that he looked across at the man who was fighting so grimly against pain and exhaustion. In the pain and languor that Ulrich himself was feeling the old fierce hatred seemed to be dying down.
“Neighbour,” he said presently, “do as you please if your men come first. It was a fair compact. But as for me, I’ve changed my mind. If my men are the first to come you shall be the first to be helped, as though you were my guest. We have quarrelled like devils all our lives over this stupid strip of forest, where the trees can’t even stand upright in a breath of wind. Lying here to-night thinking I’ve come to think we’ve been rather fools; there are better things in life than getting the better of a boundary dispute. Neighbour, if you will help me to bury the old quarrel I—I will ask you to be my friend.”
[…]
For a space both men were silent, turning over in their minds the wonderful changes that this dramatic reconciliation would bring about. In the cold, gloomy forest, with the wind tearing in fitful gusts through the naked branches and whistling round the tree-trunks, they lay and waited for the help that would now bring release and succour to both parties. And each prayed a private prayer that his men might be the first to arrive, so that he might be the first to show honourable attention to the enemy that had become a friend.
[…]
“They hear us! They’ve stopped. Now they see us. They’re running down the hill towards us,” cried Ulrich.
“How many of them are there?” asked Georg.
“I can’t see distinctly,” said Ulrich; “nine or ten,”
“Then they are yours,” said Georg; “I had only seven out with me.”
“They are making all the speed they can, brave lads,” said Ulrich gladly.
“Are they your men?” asked Georg. “Are they your men?” he repeated impatiently as Ulrich did not answer.
“No,” said Ulrich with a laugh, the idiotic chattering laugh of a man unstrung with hideous fear.
“Who are they?” asked Georg quickly, straining his eyes to see what the other would gladly not have seen.
“Wolves.”
Source: Saki (H. H. Munro), The Toys of Peace (1919), Project Gutenberg eBook #1477 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)