set up our exhibit, give a clear 60-second gallery talk about my breakthrough and answer visitors’ questions with facts from my sources.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Write the three things a visitor must hear in your 60-second talk: your big idea, one surprising fact and why it matters. Then practice once, quietly, with a partner timing you.
At a NASA exhibit outside a Pittsburgh stadium, what do you think drew the most visitors?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Tonight, you are the experts. Visitors will walk past our panels the way people walk past a booth outside a stadium: curious, but in a hurry. Your panel does the reading work. Your gallery talk does the people work.
The 60-second talk. (1) Greet and point: “This panel is about…” and point to your graphic. (2) Big idea in one sentence. (3) One surprising fact, with its source: “According to the 1919 University of Pittsburgh report…” (4) So what. (5) Invite a question. Speak to the visitor, not the panel, at a steady pace.
Answering questions. Answer with facts from your sources. If you do not know, say so honestly: “My sources don’t say, but the CDC page might be a place to check.” Never make up a fact to fill a silence.
Print, web and in person. The NASA article reached readers on a web page with photographs and captions; the exhibit booth reached fans in person, where they could meet an astronaut and take a photo. Our exhibit uses print panels plus live talks: visitors can read at their own pace and also ask a real person a question.
Worked example 1: Kayla opens her talk. Kayla borrows the NASA writer’s move, a question hook: “What do a summer swimming pool, a church bell and a Pittsburgh lab have in common? They are all part of the polio vaccine story.” Then she points to her timeline and gives her big idea.
Worked example 2: Luis handles a hard question. A visitor asks Luis whether the 1918 flu shots worked. He answers, “The 1919 report says the data were inconclusive, partly because the two groups were counted over different weeks. My caption explains that.” He points to his chart.
Gallery etiquette. When you visit classmates’ panels, read first, then ask a question, and leave one specific compliment on a sticky note.
Use the NASA article under “The text,” then rehearse.
Exhibit Night.
During the exhibit, record (1) two questions visitors asked you and how you answered, (2) one moment when your graphic helped a visitor understand and (3) one thing you would change about your panel after watching people read it.
Visit three classmates’ panels. For each, write the big idea in one sentence and one specific compliment tied to the checklist.
A discovery helps people only when people learn about it. Tonight you helped.
Exit ticket: what did a visitor learn from you tonight? Quote or describe their reaction.
Pacing (class session before the event): warm-up 5 minutes, reading 6, mini lecture 7, guided practice and rehearsal 15, setup 7. The exhibit itself runs at the STEM night or library event; the independent practice is completed there or the next day.
Source notes: the passage is copied from the NASA Glenn article (December 6, 2023); the cut removes one caption about Hoburg traveling to the Dec. 3 game. Captions are shown in italics. The article says Peregrine Mission One was scheduled to launch in January (2024); it does not report what happened to the mission. If students want to tell visitors the outcome, have them find it on a later NASA or Astrobotic mission page and cite that page; otherwise they should describe Iris only as the article does, as a rover that was scheduled to launch.
Event: confirm the partner (STEM night or public library), room setup, accessibility and family invitations. Students who cannot attend give their talk in class. Panels display students’ first names only.
Likely misconceptions: that the talk should read the panel aloud; that “I don’t know” is a failure; that a speaker should look at the panel instead of the visitor.
Supports: allow note cards with the five talk moves; pair anxious speakers with a partner who points to the graphic; offer a recorded talk played beside the panel as an alternative. This lesson also practices CC.1.5.8.A, owned in Unit 1.
Answer guide: look for a talk that states the big idea, gives a sourced fact, explains the graphic and ends with so what, in about 60 seconds. Visitor notes should name real questions and accurate, sourced answers.
NASA, Glenn Research Center: NASA Glenn Director, NASA Astronaut Visit Pittsburgh · U.S. government work (NASA), public domain
This short NASA article describes a weekend in December 2023 when NASA visited Pittsburgh. The director of NASA’s Glenn Research Center in Cleveland and astronaut Woody Hoburg, a Pittsburgh native, met Carnegie Mellon University students who built a small lunar rover named Iris. They also joined a Steelers game, where NASA’s public engagement team ran an exhibit booth outside the stadium.
The article is a web page with photographs, so some of its sentences are captions with credit lines. As you read, notice how the writer uses a question to hook readers, which facts tie the story to Pittsburgh and how the photos and captions add to the text. Think about what an in-person exhibit can do that a web page cannot.
Words to know: payloads, the equipment or cargo a rocket carries; lunar, having to do with the Moon; initiative, a new plan or program; public engagement, sharing work with the public; ceremonial, used for a special occasion.
What do a rover, an astronaut, and a rally towel have in common? They all came together for a NASA-filled weekend in Pittsburgh on Dec. 2 and 3.
Dr. Jimmy Kenyon, director of NASA’s Glenn Research Center in Cleveland, and NASA astronaut Woody Hoburg, who piloted NASA’s recent SpaceX Crew-6 mission to the International Space Station, met with students from Carnegie Mellon University. The students built the Iris lunar rover.
NASA astronaut Woody Hoburg holds a “Terrible Towel” that was flown in space aboard the International Space Station at the Dec. 3 Pittsburgh Steelers game. Credit: NASA
[…]
NASA Glenn Center Director Dr. Jimmy Kenyon looks on from the NASA Glenn exhibit booth as astronaut Woody Hoburg takes a photo with a fan and a Pittsburgh Steelers ceremonial towel. Credit: NASA
Iris is one of several payloads scheduled to launch aboard Astrobotic’s Peregrine Mission One on United Launch Alliance’s Vulcan rocket in January. The launch is part of NASA’s Commercial Lunar Payload Services initiative, which will help NASA study Earth’s nearest neighbor, the Moon.
While in town, Hoburg received a warm welcome back from his 186-day journey in space by the Pittsburgh Steelers. The football team invited Hoburg to participate in the Terrible Towel Twirl. As a Pittsburgh native and lifelong Steelers fan, Hoburg jumped at the opportunity to lead his hometown crowd in the cheer. He also joined NASA Glenn’s public engagement team as they shared updates about NASA’s Artemis missions and more at an exhibit outside the stadium.
Source: NASA, Glenn Research Center: NASA Glenn Director, NASA Astronaut Visit Pittsburgh (nasa.gov)