write a claim-evidence-reasoning response analyzing how lines of dialogue in “The Interlopers” propel the action and reveal the two characters.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Two neighbors have argued over a strip of land for three generations. Tonight a storm traps both of them under the same fallen tree. Write the first thing you think each one says.
Each man has his own foresters, workers who guard the forest, somewhere nearby. What do you predict the two enemies will argue about?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Dialogue does three jobs. In grade 8 we analyze how lines of dialogue or incidents propel the action, reveal a character or provoke a decision. In this scene, the men cannot move, so every line has to do one of those jobs.
Claim, evidence, reasoning (CER). A claim answers the question. Evidence is the exact line that supports it. Reasoning explains how the evidence proves the claim. Reasoning is where your thinking shows.
Worked example 1: dialogue that propels the action. Zoe chooses Georg’s threat: “I have men, too, in the forest to-night, close behind me, and they will be here first.” Her reasoning: “This line sets up a race. From now on, the question that drives the story is whose men will come first.”
Worked example 2: dialogue that reveals character. Luis compares “snared in his stolen forest” with “I’m caught in my own forest-land.” His reasoning: “Each man is sure the land is his. The same forest is ‘stolen’ to Georg and ‘my own’ to Ulrich, which shows how deep their pride runs.”
A model CER paragraph. Claim: Georg’s threat turns a stalemate into a race. Evidence: he warns that his men will “roll this mass of trunk right over on the top of you.” Reasoning: before this line, the men can only wait; after it, each one’s life depends on which group of foresters arrives first, so every sound in the forest becomes a source of suspense.
Watch the title. Georg says there will be “no cursed interlopers to come between us.” Saki named the story after that word. A wise reader asks: who might the real interlopers be?
Use the passage. Quote exact words.
Write a full CER response.
Prompt: How do the lines of dialogue in this passage raise the stakes of the feud? Write one CER paragraph of 6-8 sentences. Checklist: (1) a clear claim, (2) two exact quotations with lead-ins, (3) reasoning that explains how each line propels the action or reveals a character, (4) a closing sentence that connects to suspense.
Peer check: trade with a partner. Underline their claim, box their evidence and star their best sentence of reasoning. Write one suggestion.
Two enemies, one tree, and a race against time. Next we read what changes between them, and who finally arrives.
Exit ticket: predict who the “interlopers” of the title will turn out to be. Give a reason.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 8, mini lesson 9, guided practice 9, CER and peer check 10.
Language note: the passage includes “damned” and “Death and damnation,” mild curses in the original 1919 text. Read them as written or say “[curse]”; do not ask students to repeat them.
Likely misconceptions: that reasoning means repeating the quotation in other words; that dialogue only reveals character and never moves the plot; that one man is clearly the villain (Saki makes both proud).
Supports: a CER organizer with sentence starters (“This line shows… because…”). Pair readers to perform the dialogue. Stretch: analyze how the narrator’s words “mockingly and savagely” shape our view of Georg.
Sample CER: The dialogue raises the stakes by turning a standoff into a deadly race. Georg warns that his men will “roll this mass of trunk right over on the top of you,” so the men’s lives now depend on who arrives first. Ulrich answers that his men will come in “ten minutes time, seven of which must have gone by,” which puts a clock on the scene. Their insults, like “forest-thief, game-snatcher,” show that neither will back down, so every sound in the forest becomes suspenseful.
Saki (H. H. Munro), The Toys of Peace (1919), Project Gutenberg eBook #1477 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #1477
About the story. Saki was the pen name of H. H. Munro, a British writer famous for short stories with sharp, surprising endings. “The Interlopers” appeared in his 1919 collection The Toys of Peace. It is set in a forest in the Carpathian Mountains of eastern Europe. Ulrich von Gradwitz and Georg Znaeym come from two families that have fought over a strip of forest for three generations. On a stormy winter night, Ulrich hunts for Georg with a rifle. They meet face to face, and before either can act, a falling beech tree pins them both to the ground.
What to notice. Neither man can move, so only words can act. Mark each threat. What does each man believe about the land?
Words to know. Exasperation is great annoyance. A plight is a bad situation. Poaching is hunting on land where you have no right to hunt. Condolences are words of sympathy after a death. Interlopers are people who push in where they do not belong.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the story and once with a pencil.
Relief at being alive and exasperation at his captive plight brought a strange medley of pious thank-offerings and sharp curses to Ulrich’s lips. Georg, who was nearly blinded with the blood which trickled across his eyes, stopped his struggling for a moment to listen, and then gave a short, snarling laugh.
“So you’re not killed, as you ought to be, but you’re caught, anyway,” he cried; “caught fast. Ho, what a jest, Ulrich von Gradwitz snared in his stolen forest. There’s real justice for you!”
And he laughed again, mockingly and savagely.
“I’m caught in my own forest-land,” retorted Ulrich. “When my men come to release us you will wish, perhaps, that you were in a better plight than caught poaching on a neighbour’s land, shame on you.”
Georg was silent for a moment; then he answered quietly:
“Are you sure that your men will find much to release? I have men, too, in the forest to-night, close behind me, and they will be here first and do the releasing. When they drag me out from under these damned branches it won’t need much clumsiness on their part to roll this mass of trunk right over on the top of you. Your men will find you dead under a fallen beech tree. For form’s sake I shall send my condolences to your family.”
“It is a useful hint,” said Ulrich fiercely. “My men had orders to follow in ten minutes time, seven of which must have gone by already, and when they get me out—I will remember the hint. Only as you will have met your death poaching on my lands I don’t think I can decently send any message of condolence to your family.”
“Good,” snarled Georg, “good. We fight this quarrel out to the death, you and I and our foresters, with no cursed interlopers to come between us. Death and damnation to you, Ulrich von Gradwitz.”
“The same to you, Georg Znaeym, forest-thief, game-snatcher.”
Source: Saki (H. H. Munro), The Toys of Peace (1919), Project Gutenberg eBook #1477 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)