plan an original suspense narrative for our anthology or audio drama, choosing a suspense engine and an ending, and learn the checklist our readers will use.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. In Part 1 you felt your pulse speed up as Poe, Bierce and Saki kept secrets from their characters or from you. List three things that make you hold your breath in a story or a movie (a sound in the dark, a clock running out, a character who does not know what you know…). Star the one you would most like to use.
Which plan usually creates more suspense?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Writers, welcome to Build. In Part 1 you studied how Poe, Bierce and Saki make readers hold their breath. Now it is your turn. Each of you will write one original suspense narrative for our class collection, The Uncanny. It will be printed and posted as a digital book for the school library, and you will perform part of it at our October family reading event, either as a read-aloud or in a short audio drama with a team.
What “uncanny” means. Something is uncanny when it is familiar and strange at the same time: your own hallway at 3 a.m., a voice that sounds almost like a friend’s, a house that seems to answer back. Uncanny stories do not need monsters. They need a gap between what the reader senses and what anyone understands.
Your task. Write a real or imagined narrative of 600 to 1,000 words. Build it on a suspense engine: a secret (someone knows something others do not), a danger (something is coming), a question (what is that sound?) or a clock (it must happen by midnight). Plan your ending before you draft, so every clue points somewhere. Poe himself wrote stories for magazine readers and a prize contest; you are writing for a real audience too.
Read our mentor narrative. A mentor text is a model we study to learn craft. “The Knocking at Nine” was written for this unit. We will return to it in every lesson.
Mentor narrative: “The Knocking at Nine” (written for our class)
The storm had knocked out the streetlights on Grandma Ruth’s block by the time she called. “I’m stuck at the hospital until midnight, Jada,” she said. “Lock the doors. And don’t worry about the noises. This old house talks.”
I was thirteen. I told her I wasn’t worried. Then I hung up and checked the lock twice.
At 8:55 the rain was drumming on the porch roof, and the kitchen clock ticked louder than any clock should. I sat on the couch with my math homework open and did not read a single problem.
At nine o’clock exactly, something knocked.
Not at the front door. Under the floor.
Knock. Knock. Then a pause, long enough for one breath, and a third knock, harder, as if a fist were testing the boards beneath my feet.
I pulled my feet onto the couch. If Grandma had been home, she would have laughed. She was not home.
I grabbed my phone. One bar. I texted her: Someone is in the basement.
Her answer took forever. Meanwhile, the knocking came again, then a long hiss, like breath pushed through teeth. The basement door, which had been closed all evening, now stood open an inch. Had it always been open? I could not remember.
Finally my phone buzzed. Did you read my note on the fridge?
I had not. I crept into the kitchen with my back to the wall and found a yellow sticky note beside the takeout menus: Furnace kicks on at 9. Pipes bang 3 times. Don’t panic! Love, G.
Under my feet, the old pipes knocked once more and then settled into a warm, steady hum. The air from the vent smelled like dust and toast.
I laughed so hard that I had to sit down on the kitchen floor. Then I closed the basement door anyway.
When Grandma got home, she found me asleep on the couch with every light on. “The house talked,” I told her. She kissed my forehead. “It always does,” she said. “The trick is learning its language.”
Now, when I hear a strange sound in the dark, I still jump. But then I ask myself which note I have not read yet.
Worked example 1: Darnell picks his engine. Darnell lists three ideas: a power outage at a sleepover, a locker that is open every morning though he locks it, and a lost hiker. He asks of each, What does the reader want to know, and how long can I make them wait? The locker wins: the question (who opens it?) can stretch over a whole week of mornings. That is his suspense engine.
Worked example 2: Lucia plans backward. Lucia knows her ending first: the “ghost” on the security camera is her own little brother sleepwalking. She works backward to plant three fair clues: muddy socks, a missing cookie, and the brother yawning at breakfast. Then she chooses a first-person narrator who does not notice the clues, so the reader might. That difference in what the narrator and the reader know is dramatic irony, the skill you studied in Part 1.
Our checklist. Our readers will judge every story by these ten points. We will build each skill in the lessons ahead.
| # | Writer’s checklist: The Uncanny | Standard |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | My opening establishes the context (where, when, what is going on) and a clear point of view, and it introduces the narrator or characters. | N |
| 2 | My story has a suspense engine: a secret, a danger, a question or a clock that makes readers hold their breath. | M |
| 3 | Dialogue reveals what characters want or fear and pushes the action forward. | O |
| 4 | I use precise words, descriptive details and sensory language (at least three senses). | O |
| 5 | I control pacing: I slow down the big moment and let my narrator reflect at least once. | O |
| 6 | Events unfold logically, and varied transitions signal shifts in time or setting. | P |
| 7 | My conclusion follows from the events (any surprise is fair, with planted clues) and reflects on what the experience meant. | P |
| 8 | I vary sentences and use verb voice and mood on purpose: at least one passive or active choice for effect and one conditional or subjunctive verb. | Q |
| 9 | Grammar, dialogue punctuation, commas, dashes and ellipses, spelling and verb tense are correct. | R |
| 10 | I revised after feedback and kept a revision log with reasons. | T |
Constraints: 600 to 1,000 words. Suspense, not gore: our audience includes families and younger siblings, so frighten readers with what they almost see, not with graphic violence. If your story is based on real events or people, change names or ask permission. Audio-drama teams adapt one member’s story into a 2-3 minute script with a narrator, voices and sound cues.
Use the mentor narrative and the Poe profile. Talk with a partner before you answer the open questions.
Plan your anthology narrative.
Fill in your suspense plan: (1) narrator and point of view, (2) setting, (3) suspense engine, (4) three fair clues, (5) the big moment, (6) your ending and what the narrator understands afterward. Say whether the story is real or imagined and whether you plan a read-aloud or an audio drama.
Dramatic irony check: will your reader know something your narrator does not, or will both learn the truth together? Explain your choice and how it will create suspense, using Lucia’s plan or the mentor narrative as an example.
Every family at our October event knows the feeling of a strange sound in the dark. Your story will give them that feeling, safely.
Exit ticket: in one sentence, what question will keep your readers turning pages? Who in our audience will enjoy it most, and why?
Pacing: warm-up 5 minutes, reading 6, mini lecture with the mentor read-aloud 12, guided practice 10, suspense plan 5, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that suspense requires gore or a monster (the mentor has neither); that a surprise ending should come from nowhere (fair surprises are planted); that planning the ending first spoils the story for the writer.
Supports: provide an idea bank (a power outage, a sound in the attic, an elevator that stops between floors, a message from an unknown number, a pet that stares at an empty corner). Let students talk their plan aloud first. Stretch: plan two narrators for the same events and pick the one that creates more dramatic irony. Set expectations for school-appropriate content now: suspense, not graphic violence. Form audio-drama teams of three or four by the end of 1.17.
Answer guide: sample plan: narrator – first person, Darnell, age 13; setting – school hallway before the first bell; engine – who opens my locker?; clues – a janitor’s cart nearby, a new lock sticker, a note about a broken latch; big moment – he hides and watches; ending – the latch is broken and pops open when the heater runs, and he realizes he made a mystery out of a mechanical problem. Sample dramatic-irony answer: “My reader will notice the latch note before Darnell does, so they will feel suspense wondering when he will figure it out.” Reading facts come from the NPS Poe profile (last updated January 30, 2023).
National Park Service, Edgar Allan Poe (people profile) · U.S. government work (National Park Service), public domain
The National Park Service runs the Edgar Allan Poe National Historic Site in Philadelphia. Its profile of Poe calls him an author, poet, editor and critic, and a pioneer of modern detective fiction.
Poe was born in Boston in 1809. Both of his parents were actors. After his mother died in 1811, he was raised in Richmond, Virginia, by John and Frances Allan. As a young man he published a book of poems, served in the U.S. Army and spent time at West Point.
In 1833 Poe won a $50 prize for a short story, “Ms. Found in a Bottle.” That success led to a job as an editor in Richmond. In 1838 he moved to Philadelphia. The profile calls his six years there his most productive and perhaps happiest. He worked as an editor and critic for Graham’s Magazine, one of the largest magazines in the country, and wrote famous stories such as “The Fall of the House of Usher” and “The Mask of the Red Death.” His wife, Virginia, became ill in 1842, and money troubles followed him. He died in Baltimore in 1849, at 40.
Words to know: critic means a person who judges and reviews writing; productive means getting a lot of work done.
Source: National Park Service, Edgar Allan Poe (people profile) (nps.gov)