analyze how captions and a descriptive paragraph are built to inform quickly and precisely, and use a mentor label to plan the structure of our exhibit panels.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Think of a sign or label you read quickly and understood at once (a museum card, a trail marker, a food label). What did it tell you first? Write the three things it told you, in order.
What do you predict a 1914 photograph caption in a government report tells first?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Labels are tiny informative texts. A museum label must work in seconds. Most follow a pattern: a title that names the object or idea, an identification line (what, where, when, who), and a short body of two to four sentences that explains why it matters. Every word is chosen for precision.
Worked example 1: decoding a caption. Elena breaks down Plate 2: “LANGLEY AEROPLANE” (what) “JUST RISING FROM WATER” (action) “JUNE 2, 1914” (when) “PILOTED BY CURTISS” (who). Four facts in eleven words. Our identification lines should be just as efficient.
Worked example 2: how a paragraph refines. Kwame maps Zahm’s paragraph. Sentence 1 tells what the plates show (floats added). Sentence 2 claims what stayed the same. Sentences 3-5 explain the controls, ending with what the pilot did not have (ailerons) and how he balanced instead. Each sentence narrows the reader’s picture. Kwame also notes that sentence 2 is a claim worth checking (see 2.11).
A mentor label (my own writing). Title: A Vaccine for Everyone. ID line: Polio vaccine developed by Dr. Jonas Salk’s team, University of Pittsburgh, released April 12, 1955. Body: In 1954 polio killed more than 1,300 Americans, many of them children. Within a year of the vaccine’s release, polio deaths fell by half. Scientists, donors, doctors and families all helped get it to children across the country. Every fact in it comes from a source we read.
Craft choices. Notice the mentor label’s strong verb (killed), its exact numbers rounded honestly (“more than 1,300” for “over thirteen hundred”), and its last sentence, which answers our driving question. A label also pairs with an image, so it should not repeat what visitors can already see.
Checking for accuracy. A label is a public promise. Before any fact goes on your panel, mark the source and the exact words it came from.
Mark each caption: W (what), A (action), D (date), P (place), N (name of a person).
Plan your own label.
Draft a practice label for one object or moment from our readings (for example, the bolometer, the 1903 aerodrome, the 1955 Rose Garden citation). Include a title, an identification line (what, where, when, who) and a body of 2-3 sentences. Checklist: (1) every fact from a source we read, (2) source noted in the margin, (3) one precise technical word defined for visitors, (4) under 60 words.
Medium choice: what image or other medium would sit beside your label, and what should the label not repeat because visitors can see it?
We have studied how a label works. Next we pull the unit’s ideas together and check our reading.
Exit ticket: trade labels with a partner. Circle one word that could be more precise and suggest a replacement.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 7, mini lesson 10, guided practice 8, label draft 11.
Text note: copied from Project Gutenberg #44466, including the file’s bracketed illustration notes; the cut skips the captions of the flight photo and Plates 3-4. The mentor label is our own writing; its facts come from the Eisenhower Library page (2.01) and Fogarty’s speech (2.03, 2.06); the University of Pittsburgh link is in Fogarty’s page 2 (2.06).
Likely misconceptions: that a label should tell everything; that a caption and a label are the same (a caption explains one picture; a label explains an object or idea and why it matters); that a report’s descriptive sentence is automatically neutral.
Supports: a label template with three boxes; a word bank of strong verbs. Stretch: rewrite Zahm’s sentence 2 as a label sentence that is accurate given what 2.11 showed.
Answer guide: Zahm puts the “substantially the same” claim second so readers accept that the 1914 machine is still Langley’s before reading about how it flew; it supports his argument in 2.11. Practice label example: The Bolometer. Invented by Samuel P. Langley at the Allegheny Observatory, Pittsburgh, 1878. It detects tiny differences in radiant heat, one hundred-thousandth of a degree Celsius. Instruments of this type later flew on NASA missions that measure Earth’s energy balance.