independently read a new passage from Bierce’s “A Jug of Sirup” and show how dialogue, word choice and differences in knowledge create suspense and humor, with an objective summary and a theme connection.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. List the tools we have studied: slowed time, repeated words, dramatic irony, verbal irony and puns, planted clues, dialogue that raises the stakes, a haunted mind. Star the two you understand best.
The standard for this unit says differences in what characters and readers know can create suspense or humor. Can an uncanny story also be funny?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Cold-read strategy. Read the whole passage once for the story. On the second reading, annotate with three marks: K where you notice a difference in what characters know, D where dialogue pushes the action or reveals someone, and W for a word or comparison with strong connotation.
Worked example 1: a multiple-meaning word. Noor reads, “Deemer himself drew it.” She knows drew can mean sketched a picture, but that does not fit sirup. Context (a jug, a store) shows it means poured out from a barrel. Using context is how strong readers handle hard words in a cold read.
Worked example 2: humor from a narrator’s tone. Gabriel notes that the clock seemed slow “as if it were civilly granting them an extension of time.” He writes: “Bierce makes the clock sound polite, like a banker giving more time on a loan. It is a joke in a frightening moment, so the tone is dry and amused.”
Answer the question asked. In the reading check, each response needs a claim, the strongest evidence and reasoning. Keep your summary objective, and keep your theme a full sentence about life.
Looking ahead. In Part 2 you become the writer. Everything you noticed in Poe, Bierce and Saki is now a tool for your own story in The Uncanny.
Reading check, part A. Work alone. Use the passage.
Reading check, part B. Write your responses.
1. Objective summary: in 3-4 sentences, summarize the passage without opinions. 2. Knowledge gaps: how does the difference between what Mr. Creede believes and what the child's question reveals create suspense or humor? Give a claim, the strongest quotation and reasoning. 3. Word choice: explain the personification of the clock and the tone it creates.
4. Theme across texts: state one theme this passage seems to share with another text from the unit, and support it with one quotation from each. 5. Independent reading: name one suspense technique from your own book and the page where it appears.
You have read, investigated and made sense of the uncanny. In Part 2 we build our own collection for the school library and the October family reading event.
Exit ticket: answer the driving question in one sentence: How do writers make readers hold their breath?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 3, cold read and annotation 10, mini lesson 4, part A 9, part B 14.
Assessment: formative check of all Part 1 codes (CC.1.3.8.A, B, C, D, F and K); Part 2 assesses them again through the anthology and the unit check. Point scheme (20 points): part A quizzes and true/false, 1 point each (5); fill-in, 1; dialogue response, 2; summary, 3; knowledge-gap CER, 4; word-choice response, 3; theme across texts, 2. The independent-reading item is recorded for CC.1.3.8.K, not scored.
Context: Deemer’s death, burial and habits come from the opening of the story in the same file and are told in the summary. The passage cuts Mr. Creede’s account of seeing Deemer behind the counter, a mild curse, and his wife’s reply. Later the village crowds into the haunted store and a brawl breaks out in the dark; if students read on, preview it.
Likely misconceptions: that “drew” means sketched; that the child is lying; that a funny tone means the story is not uncanny (Bierce uses both at once).
Supports: read the passage aloud for students whose plans allow it, keeping the responses independent; provide the K/D/W annotation key. Stretch: explain why the narrator says the sentence “remains to this day unfinished.”
Sample answers: summary: Mr. Creede comes home one evening and finds that the jug of maple sirup he set down at his door is gone. He says he bought it from Silas Deemer, then remembers Deemer died three weeks earlier. He decides the experience was in his own mind, since a jug cannot appear from nothing. Then his daughter asks whether her brother may have the jug when it is empty. Knowledge gap: Creede believes the jug was imaginary, but the child, who “could not have heard a word of the conversation,” saw it, so the reader shivers with him. Word choice: the clock “civilly granting them an extension of time” is personification that adds dry humor. Dialogue: the unfinished sentence stops because he remembers Deemer is dead, which turns an ordinary errand into a ghost story. Theme: like “Owl Creek,” the passage asks whether what a person experiences is real or only in the mind.
Ambrose Bierce, Can Such Things Be? (Boni and Liveright, 1918), Project Gutenberg eBook #4366 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #4366
About the story. Ambrose Bierce, who wrote “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge,” also wrote short tales of the supernatural. This one is from his collection Can Such Things Be? It begins with the death of Silas Deemer, a shopkeeper in the village of Hillbrook. For more than twenty-five years Deemer never missed a day at his store, except Sundays. He died in July 1863, and the whole village saw him buried. Our passage follows Alvan Creede, the town banker, coming home one summer evening.
What to notice. This is a cold read: read on your own and annotate. Track what Mr. Creede knows, what his wife knows and what the child knows. Notice the narrator’s tone.
Words to know. A threshold is the strip under a doorway. A phenomenon is an event that can be observed. Subjective means existing only in a person’s own mind. An apparition is a ghost. Import here means meaning or importance.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the story and once with a pencil.
One pleasant summer evening at about the hour of ten Mr. Creede, entering at his garden gate, passed up the gravel walk, which looked very white in the moonlight, mounted the stone steps of his fine house and pausing a moment inserted his latchkey in the door. As he pushed this open he met his wife, who was crossing the passage from the parlor to the library. She greeted him pleasantly and pulling the door further back held it for him to enter. Instead he turned and, looking about his feet in front of the threshold, uttered an exclamation of surprise.
[…]
“A jug of maple sirup—I brought it along from the store and set it down here to open the door. What the—”
[…]
“My dear, do you suppose a man does not know when he is carrying a jug? I bought that sirup at Deemer’s as I was passing. Deemer himself drew it and lent me the jug, and I—”
The sentence remains to this day unfinished. Mr. Creede staggered into the house, entered the parlor and dropped into an armchair, trembling in every limb. He had suddenly remembered that Silas Deemer was three weeks dead.
[…]
There were long moments of silence broken by nothing but the measured ticking of the clock, which seemed somewhat slower than usual, as if it were civilly granting them an extension of time in which to recover their wits.
[…]
“Doubtless the phenomenon was subjective,” he said, with a somewhat ludicrous transition to the slang of science. “Granting the possibility of spiritual apparition and even materialization, yet the apparition and materialization of a half-gallon brown clay jug—a piece of coarse, heavy pottery evolved from nothing—that is hardly thinkable.”
As he finished speaking, a child ran into the room—his little daughter. She was clad in a bedgown. Hastening to her father she threw her arms about his neck, saying: “You naughty papa, you forgot to come in and kiss me. We heard you open the gate and got up and looked out. And, papa dear, Eddy says mayn’t he have the little jug when it is empty?”
As the full import of that revelation imparted itself to Alvan Creede’s understanding he visibly shuddered. For the child could not have heard a word of the conversation.
Source: Ambrose Bierce, Can Such Things Be? (Boni and Liveright, 1918), Project Gutenberg eBook #4366 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)