evaluate how specific sentences and paragraphs in a 1965 speech develop and refine the concept of distributing a scarce vaccine fairly.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Your class gets 10 new laptops but has 30 students. Write a fair plan in two sentences. Who gets them first, and why?
In 1955 there was not yet enough vaccine for every child. What do you predict the country did?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A concept grows. A concept is a general idea. In a strong informational text, each paragraph develops the concept (adds to it) or refines it (makes it more exact). Today’s concept: getting a scarce vaccine to people fairly.
Jobs sentences do. A sentence can introduce or transition, state a problem, describe a solution, give evidence, evaluate (judge how well something worked) or extend the idea to a new case. Naming the job helps you see the structure.
Worked example 1: the transition sentence. Aiden studies the first sentence of paragraph 2: “The long sought for vaccine was a reality, but this was only to be a new beginning.” The first half looks back at the discovery; but turns forward. Its job: move the speech from inventing the vaccine to delivering it.
Worked example 2: refining the concept. Sofia sees that paragraph 2 says the vaccine went to groups “most susceptable to polio,” fair by risk. Paragraph 4 adds a second kind of fairness: no one “deprived of vaccine because they could not afford it,” fair by money. The concept is refined from “share it by risk” to “share it by risk, and don’t let cost stop anyone.”
The evaluating sentence. “The success of this system was particularly noteworthy since it was entirely voluntary” is the writer’s judgment, backed by a reason. Notice that Fogarty does not give numbers here; ask whether you would want more evidence before putting that claim on an exhibit panel.
A model paragraph. The sentence that opens Fogarty’s second paragraph works as a hinge. By calling the vaccine “only… a new beginning,” he signals that the hard part was still ahead. The next sentence names the problem, supplies that “were limited” while “demand… was overwhelming,” and the rest of the paragraph answers it with a committee and a system of priorities.
Label each sentence’s job in the margin: T (transition), P (problem), S (solution), J (judgment), X (extension).
Structure map and analysis.
Make a structure map: one box per paragraph, with its main job and the sentence that does it best (quoted). Draw arrows to show how each paragraph builds on the last.
Write 4-5 sentences analyzing the role of the paragraph that begins “To assure that no children or pregnant women.” Checklist: (1) what concept it refines, (2) a quotation, (3) how it connects to the paragraphs before it.
Discovery was the beginning; delivery took committees, companies, Congress and doctors. Next we meet our second Pittsburgh breakthrough: Samuel Langley at the Allegheny Observatory.
Exit ticket: name three groups of people in today's passage who helped turn the vaccine into help for millions.
Pacing (40 min): laptop Do Now 5, reading 8, mini lesson 9, guided practice 9, structure map 9.
Text note: transcribed from pages 2-3 of the NLM scan and checked word by word; the page break falls after “give the vaccine to.” Original spellings and grammar (“Pittsburg,” “susceptable,” “those whose risk were”) are kept.
Accuracy note: the speech does not say which groups had priority. Do not let students invent them; if they ask, have them note it as a research question for Part 2.
Likely misconceptions: that each paragraph is a separate topic; that a writer’s judgment is a fact; that “voluntary” means unpaid.
Supports: a sentence-job word bank; paragraph boxes printed in advance. Stretch: why might Fogarty, a member of Congress, mention the Act Congress passed?
Answer guide: structure: P1 background (Salk’s vaccine at Pittsburg, the 1954 field trials, licensing on April 12, 1955); P2 transition, problem, solution (committee, priorities); P3 judgment with reason, more cooperation, ending; P4 extension to cost (Act, $50 million, doctors’ time). Judgment sentence: “The success of this system was particularly noteworthy…”; evidence wanted: numbers vaccinated by priority group, or a report from the time. Analysis: the paragraph refines fairness from risk to cost and shows Congress and private doctors joining the effort.