write a conclusion that follows from the events I narrated, pays off my clues and reflects on what the experience meant, using the ending of “The Signal-Man” as a model.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Which surprise ending feels fair? (A) The knocking in the basement was an alien, and nothing earlier hinted at aliens. (B) The knocking was the furnace, as Grandma’s note and her warning that “this old house talks” suggested. Explain in one sentence.
Why does ending B feel fair to the reader?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
An ending is a promise kept. Your opening planted a question; your conclusion must answer it, or deliberately leave a chill that follows from everything before. A conclusion follows from the events when it grows out of clues the reader has seen. It reflects when the narrator, or the story, pauses to show what the experience meant.
How Dickens pays off his clues. Look how many earlier details return. The first shout, “Halloa! Below there!”, comes back as the driver’s “Below there! Look out!” The ghost’s gesture (left arm across the face, right arm waving) turns out to be the driver’s real motion: “I put this arm before my eyes not to see, and I waved this arm.” The red light, the tunnel, the warnings: all of it was pointing here. The surprise is shocking, but it is fair.
Dramatic irony at the end. When the driver repeats his words, he has no idea what they mean to the narrator. The narrator, and the reader, know the signal-man heard those exact words for weeks, and the narrator knows he silently attached “For God’s sake, clear the way!” to the gesture. That gap in knowledge is why “I started” hits so hard.
Reflection in the final paragraph. Dickens does not explain the ghost. Instead the narrator reflects on one “coincidence” and stops. The calm, careful voice leaves the reader to wonder: was it chance, or a warning from the future? A theme rises out of that question: some warnings cannot be understood until it is too late.
Worked example 1: Lucia’s fair surprise. Lucia’s camera “ghost” is her sleepwalking brother. She checks her clues: muddy socks (planted in paragraph 3), a missing cookie (paragraph 5), the brother yawning at breakfast (paragraph 7). Her final scene shows the footage, and her narrator reflects: “The scariest thing in our house, it turned out, was how little I noticed.”
Worked example 2: Jordan avoids the trapdoor ending. Jordan’s draft ends, “Then I woke up. It was all a dream.” His partner says it feels like a trick, because nothing follows from the events. Jordan revises so the ending follows from his clues (the narrator’s cousin had been setting up the “haunted” sounds with a phone speaker) and adds one line of reflection about trust.
Look at the mentor. “The Knocking at Nine” ends with a scene (Grandma’s line “The trick is learning its language”) and a reflection (“I ask myself which note I have not read yet”). The ending follows from the clues and tells us what Jada learned.
Use the passage under “The text.” Use exact evidence.
Draft or revise the ending of your anthology narrative.
Make a clue map for your story: list every clue you planted and the paragraph where it appears. Then draft your conclusion (100-200 words) so that it pays off at least two clues and includes one or two sentences of reflection.
Write one sentence naming a theme your ending suggests. Then explain which event in your story develops that theme most.
A fair surprise makes readers want to start the story over, just to find the clues they missed.
Exit ticket: which clue in your story will a reader notice only on a second reading?
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 9, mini lecture 9, guided practice 10, clue map and drafting 6, closure 2.
Content note: the signal-man dies in the ending (struck by a train, without gory description). Preview this with students and be ready for students who have lost someone in an accident; offer to discuss the craft through the mentor narrative instead. The exclamation “For God’s sake” is part of the 1866 text and is central to the ending.
Likely misconceptions: that a surprise must come from nowhere; that a conclusion must explain everything; that the narrator caused the death (the story leaves only a sense of self-reproach).
Supports: before reading, review the summary’s key facts (the gesture, the warning words, the narrator’s unspoken words). Provide a two-column chart: Earlier clue / How the ending pays it off. Stretch: write a different final paragraph that explains the ghost, then argue which ending is stronger and why.
Answer guide: the payoffs: (1) the shout “Halloa! Below there!” returns in the driver’s “Below there! Look out!”; (2) the ghost’s gesture, arm across the face and arm waving, matches the driver’s “I put this arm before my eyes not to see, and I waved this arm”; (3) the red danger-light and tunnel are where the accident happens. The calm final reflection leaves readers unsettled because it names a coincidence no one can explain. Sample theme: “Some warnings cannot be understood until too late; the signal-man saw the warning three times but could not tell what it meant.”
Project Gutenberg, Three Ghost Stories by Charles Dickens (1894 Chapman and Hall text), eBook #1289, "The Signal-Man" · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
On his second visit, the signal-man tells the narrator his secret. A figure has appeared near the red danger-light at the tunnel, with its left arm across its face and its right arm waving wildly, calling “Halloa! Below there! Look out!” Each time, a disaster followed on the line: first a terrible accident, later the death of a young woman on a passing train. Now the figure has come back a third time. When the narrator watched the man act out the waving gesture, he silently thought it looked like someone crying, “For God’s sake, clear the way!” He never said those words aloud.
The worried narrator plans to take the signal-man to a doctor. The next evening he walks to the top of the cutting.
Words to know: brink means edge; tarpaulin means a heavy waterproof cloth; self-reproachful means blaming yourself; started here means jumped in surprise; coincidence means things happening together by chance; gesticulation means a wild gesture.
This ending includes a death, told without gory detail. Notice how much the narrator understands that the railway men do not.
Before pursuing my stroll, I stepped to the brink, and mechanically looked down, from the point from which I had first seen him. I cannot describe the thrill that seized upon me, when, close at the mouth of the tunnel, I saw the appearance of a man, with his left sleeve across his eyes, passionately waving his right arm.
The nameless horror that oppressed me passed in a moment, for in a moment I saw that this appearance of a man was a man indeed, and that there was a little group of other men, standing at a short distance, to whom he seemed to be rehearsing the gesture he made. The Danger-light was not yet lighted. Against its shaft, a little low hut, entirely new to me, had been made of some wooden supports and tarpaulin. It looked no bigger than a bed.
With an irresistible sense that something was wrong,—with a flashing self-reproachful fear that fatal mischief had come of my leaving the man there, and causing no one to be sent to overlook or correct what he did,—I descended the notched path with all the speed I could make.
“What is the matter?” I asked the men.
“Signal-man killed this morning, sir.”
“Not the man belonging to that box?”
“Yes, sir.”
[…]
“He was cut down by an engine, sir. No man in England knew his work better. But somehow he was not clear of the outer rail. It was just at broad day. He had struck the light, and had the lamp in his hand. As the engine came out of the tunnel, his back was towards her, and she cut him down. That man drove her, and was showing how it happened. Show the gentleman, Tom.”
[…]
“What did you say?”
“I said, ‘Below there! Look out! Look out! For God’s sake, clear the way!’”
I started.
“Ah! it was a dreadful time, sir. I never left off calling to him. I put this arm before my eyes not to see, and I waved this arm to the last; but it was no use.”
[…]
Without prolonging the narrative to dwell on any one of its curious circumstances more than on any other, I may, in closing it, point out the coincidence that the warning of the Engine-Driver included, not only the words which the unfortunate Signal-man had repeated to me as haunting him, but also the words which I myself—not he—had attached, and that only in my own mind, to the gesticulation he had imitated.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Three Ghost Stories by Charles Dickens (1894 Chapman and Hall text), eBook #1289, "The Signal-Man" (gutenberg.pglaf.org)