analyze three texts that give conflicting information about early piloted flight and identify where they disagree on matters of fact and of interpretation.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Two runners both claim a race record. One ran first; the other’s time was faster but on a different, shorter track. What questions would you ask before deciding who holds the record?
Langley's piloted aerodrome crashed on December 8, 1903. Nine days later the Wright brothers flew. In 1914 Langley's repaired machine flew. Who do you predict the 1914 Smithsonian report called the first?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Same event, different claims. When texts conflict, first line up the claims exactly. Then ask, for each difference: can it be checked (fact), or is it a judgment about meaning (interpretation)? Often a conflict mixes both.
Define the key word. Many conflicts hide inside one word. The Wrights define “first” carefully: a machine “carrying a man” that “raised itself by its own power,” flew “on a level course” and “landed without being wrecked.” Zahm’s title says “capable of sustained free flight,” which is about what the machine could do, not what it did in 1903.
Worked example 1: a matter of fact. Keisha asks whether the 1914 machine was the same as the 1903 machine. Text A itself says that after a few flights “its engine and twin propellers were replaced by a Curtiss 80-horse motor.” That is checkable, and it matters: later flights did not use Langley’s original engine.
Worked example 2: a matter of interpretation. Ravi compares Text A’s “an untoward accident to his launching gear badly crippled his carefully and adequately designed machine” with Text C’s “Some authorities believe that if his catapult had not failed, Langley would have been the first.” Both blame the launcher, not the design. But “would have been” is a judgment about what might have happened, and the NASA page marks it as the view of “some authorities,” not proven fact.
Weighing sources. Consider who wrote each text and why. The Smithsonian report praised the Smithsonian’s own former leader. The Wrights wrote about their own achievement. The NASA Earth Observatory page is about the man a NASA research center is named for, and it uses careful words. Every source has a stake; that does not make it false, but it tells you to read closely.
A model paragraph. The texts conflict over who first achieved piloted flight. The Wrights claim their December 17, 1903 flight was “the first in the history of the world” in which a machine carrying a man flew under its own power. Zahm argues instead that Langley’s machine was “carefully and adequately designed” and failed only because of its launching gear, pointing to its 1914 flights. Yet Zahm’s own report admits the engine was later replaced, which weakens the claim that the 1914 flights prove what the 1903 machine could do.
Make a claims chart: Text / What it says happened / What it says that proves / Fact or interpretation?
Conflict analysis and an exhibit decision.
Write 6-8 sentences: Where do Texts A, B and C disagree about early piloted flight? Checklist: (1) a claim naming the conflict, (2) at least one quotation from each text, (3) one matter of fact and one matter of interpretation, labeled, (4) one sentence on each writer's stake.
Exhibit decision: write a fair two-sentence label about Langley's 1903 aerodrome that does not overclaim. Use only facts all three texts support.
Defining the key word and checking what changed can settle much of a conflict. Next we combine sources to write a claim-evidence-reasoning response about the polio vaccine.
Exit ticket: what is one question you would still want answered before deciding the Langley-Wright conflict?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 9, mini lesson 9, guided practice 8, analysis 10.
Text note: Text A copied from Project Gutenberg #44466 (Smithsonian Report for 1914, Government Printing Office, 1915); cuts skip Langley’s models and contract, the press’s ridicule, and the details of the 1914 test. Text B copied from Gutenberg #25420, “The Wright Brothers’ Aeroplane” (Century Magazine, 1908). Text C copied from the NASA Science page used in 2.07.
Background beyond our texts: Zahm’s report does say, in parts not shown, that Curtiss added floats and made the rear rudder turnable. Historians later argued that the 1914 changes were greater than the report admitted, and in 1942 the Smithsonian published a statement acknowledging the modifications; the Wright Flyer came to the Smithsonian in 1948. Share this as background only; it is not in the texts students read, so it should not appear in their evidence.
Likely misconceptions: that “first” has one obvious meaning; that a government publication must be neutral; that the NASA page’s sentence states a fact.
Supports: a pre-labeled claims chart; highlight every “first” in the texts. Stretch: how does Zahm’s word “capable” change his claim?
Answer guide: fact: whether the 1914 machine was the original (Text A admits a new motor); interpretation: whether the 1903 design deserved to fly first (Text A, Text C) versus who actually flew first (Text B). Stakes: Smithsonian honoring its late Secretary; Wrights defending their record; the NASA page honoring the agency’s namesake but hedging. Fair label example: Langley’s piloted aerodrome crashed on launch on December 8, 1903, nine days before the Wright brothers’ first flight. Repaired and changed, it flew over Lake Keuka in 1914. (The December 8 date and “nine days” come from the NASA page read in 2.07.)
A. F. Zahm, The First Man-Carrying Aeroplane Capable of Sustained Free Flight (Smithsonian Report for 1914; Government Printing Office, 1915), Project Gutenberg eBook #44466; Text B: Orville and Wilbur Wright, The Early History of the Airplane, Project Gutenberg eBook #25420 (gutenberg.pglaf.org/2/5/4/2/25420/25420.txt); Text C: NASA Science, Earth Observatory: Samuel Pierpont Langley · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #44466 and #25420; Text C: U.S. government work, public domain
About the texts. Text A is from a 1914 report by A. F. Zahm for the Smithsonian Institution, which Langley had led until his death. In 1914 Glenn Curtiss repaired and flew Langley’s 1903 machine at Lake Keuka, New York. Text B is the Wright brothers’ own 1908 description of their first flight on December 17, 1903. Text C is one sentence from the Langley profile on NASA’s Earth Observatory website.
What to notice. Each text uses the word first or implies it. Compare what each says happened, what each says it proves, and what each leaves out. Watch Text A’s last paragraph closely: what was changed on the machine?
Words to know. Unremittingly means without stopping. Untoward means unlucky. Launching gear is the equipment that starts a craft into the air; the NASA page calls Langley’s a catapult. Sustained means kept going. A tractor propeller pulls from the front. Heavier-than-air means a machine, unlike a balloon, that is heavier than the air it moves through.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
Text A: A. F. Zahm, Smithsonian Report for 1914
Something of this latter fortune was fated to the late Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution. For a decade and a half Dr. Langley had toiled unremittingly to build up the basic science of mechanical flight, and finally to apply it to practical use. […] But on that luckless day in December, 1903, when he expected to inaugurate the era of substantial aviation, an untoward accident to his launching gear badly crippled his carefully and adequately designed machine. The aeroplane was repaired, but not again tested until the spring of 1914–seven years after Langley’s death.
[…]
The four-winged craft, pointed somewhat across the wind, went skimming over the wavelets, then automatically headed into the wind, rose in level poise, soared gracefully for 150 feet, and landed softly on the water near the shore. […]
After a few more flights with the Langley aeroplane, kept as nearly as possible in its original condition, its engine and twin propellers were replaced by a Curtiss 80-horse motor and direct-connected tractor propeller mounted on the steel frame, well forward, as shown in the photographs.
Text B: Orville and Wilbur Wright, 1908
The first flight lasted only 12 seconds, a flight very modest compared with that of birds, but it was, nevertheless, the first in the history of the world in which a machine carrying a man had raised itself by its own power into the air in free flight, had sailed forward on a level course without reduction of speed, and had finally landed without being wrecked.
Text C: NASA Earth Observatory page, “Samuel Pierpont Langley”
Some authorities believe that if his catapult had not failed, Langley would have been the first to achieve sustained flight in a manned heavier-than-air machine.
Source: A. F. Zahm, The First Man-Carrying Aeroplane Capable of Sustained Free Flight (Smithsonian Report for 1914; Government Printing Office, 1915), Project Gutenberg eBook #44466; Text B: Orville and Wilbur Wright, The Early History of the Airplane, Project Gutenberg eBook #25420 (gutenberg.pglaf.org/2/5/4/2/25420/25420.txt); Text C: NASA Science, Earth Observatory: Samuel Pierpont Langley (gutenberg.pglaf.org)