write a claim-evidence-reasoning response that combines information from several sources, choosing the strongest evidence and noting where sources differ.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A pizza is invented in one town, tested in another and sold everywhere. Whose pizza is it? Write one sentence and one reason.
The Salk vaccine was developed at the University of Pittsburgh. Where do you predict its success was announced on April 12, 1955?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Claim, evidence, reasoning (CER). A claim answers the question. Evidence is the strongest quoted support, named by source. Reasoning explains how the evidence proves the claim and deals with evidence that seems to point the other way.
Several sources, one answer. Today’s question, “Was the polio vaccine Pittsburgh’s breakthrough?”, cannot be answered from one text. Our sources show a vaccine developed in Pittsburgh, funded by a national foundation, evaluated in Michigan, licensed by a federal department and made by six companies.
Worked example 1: a qualified claim. Tomas first writes, “Yes, Pittsburgh did it all.” Then he rereads Text A: Dr. Thomas Francis Jr. “at the University of Michigan, declared Salk’s polio vaccine safe and effective.” He qualifies his claim: “The vaccine began in Pittsburgh, but it took a national effort to prove and deliver it.” A qualified claim is often the strongest.
Worked example 2: handling a difference. Ana notices Text B calls Salk “Jonas Salk of the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis,” while Text A says the Foundation “helped fund the development.” She writes: “Text B links Salk to the Foundation, but Text A explains the link: the Foundation paid for the work. Fogarty’s speech (2.06) calls him ‘Dr. Jonas Salk of the University of Pittsburg.’” She uses the difference instead of ignoring it.
Statistics need care. “Deaths… declined by 50 per cent” within one year and “cases had decreased by ninety percent” by 1957 are not in conflict: they count different things (deaths, cases) over different times. Always say what a number measures.
A model CER paragraph. The polio vaccine was a Pittsburgh breakthrough that became a national achievement. Fogarty credits “Dr. Jonas Salk of the University of Pittsburg” with the first usable vaccine, but the National Archives notes that the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis “helped fund the development” and that Dr. Francis “at the University of Michigan, declared Salk’s polio vaccine safe and effective.” The National Library of Medicine adds that the federal Department of HEW “licensed 6 companies to distribute” it. So Pittsburgh supplied the discovery, while the country supplied the money, the proof and the doses.
Use Texts A and B and your notes from 2.01-2.06.
CER response.
Prompt: Was the polio vaccine Pittsburgh's breakthrough? Write a CER paragraph of 7-9 sentences. Checklist: (1) a clear, possibly qualified claim, (2) evidence from at least three sources we have read, each named, (3) exact quotations, (4) reasoning that explains each piece, (5) one sentence that handles a difference between sources, (6) no claims the sources do not support.
Reading log: how does a person or group in your nonfiction book depend on others to make their idea work? One quotation from your book.
Strong claims fit all the evidence. Next we study how museum captions and labels are built, so our panels can do the same in fewer words.
Exit ticket: write your claim in 15 words or fewer, as it might appear at the top of an exhibit panel.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 3, reading 8, mini lesson 9, guided practice 8, CER response 12.
Text note: Text A copied from the DocsTeach description (rights line on the page: Public Domain, Free of Known Copyright Restrictions). Text B copied from the Historical Note on the NLM finding aid page, https://findingaids.nlm.nih.gov/repositories/4/resources/684 (opened 2026-11-21); the last sentence of that note is cut.
Accuracy notes: “Salk of the National Foundation” in Text B is loose wording; our other sources place his work at the University of Pittsburgh with Foundation funding. Fogarty’s speech (read in 2.06) says the vaccine was licensed “by the NIH Division of Biologics Standards” while Text B says HEW licensed it: another factual difference that strong students can investigate (the licensing office was part of NIH, inside HEW). The Cutter incident is handled briefly and factually, as the source does; avoid alarm, and add details about what followed only from a source you can show students.
Likely misconceptions: that “developed” and “announced” mean the same thing; that two different statistics must conflict; that a strong claim cannot be qualified.
Supports: a CER organizer with three evidence boxes, each with a source label. Stretch: Text A calls Salk “the creator” of the vaccine. How would Fogarty respond?
Sample response: see the model in the mini lesson. Guided open question: yes; an honest panel can mention it, because the text says the problem was found and the Public Health Service “directed CDC epidemiologist Alexander Langmuir to investigate.”
National Archives, DocsTeach: White House Press Release about Dr. Jonas E. Salk (description); Text B: National Library of Medicine, finding aid for the U.S. Public Health Service Polio Vaccine collection (MS C 251), Historical Note, findingaids.nlm.nih.gov/repositories/4/resources/684 · Public Domain, Free of Known Copyright Restrictions (National Archives); Text B: U.S. government work, public domain
About the texts. Text A is the National Archives’ description of a 1955 White House press release, on DocsTeach, the Archives’ teaching site. Text B is from the National Library of Medicine’s guide to the U.S. Public Health Service’s papers about the vaccine. Archivists write these descriptions to tell researchers what a collection holds.
What to notice. Mark every person, place and organization. Note what each text says about Salk’s connection to the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis; the two describe it differently. Compare Text A’s 1957 statistic with the Eisenhower Library sentence from 2.01: “Within one year, the deaths attributed to polio declined by 50 per cent.”
Words to know. Publicizes means announces to the public. HEW was the federal Department of Health, Education, and Welfare. To license is to give official permission. Endorsed means publicly approved. An allotment is a share. Tainted means spoiled or contaminated. An epidemiologist is a scientist who studies how diseases spread.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
Text A: National Archives, DocsTeach description of the White House press release
This White House Press Release publicizes the presidential citations that President Dwight D. Eisenhower presented to Jonas Salk, the creator of the first successful polio vaccine, and the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis, an organization created by President Franklin D. Roosevelt that helped fund the development of the Salk polio vaccine. The ceremony itself took place at the White House on April 22, 1955.
Just a few days earlier, on April 12, Dr. Thomas Francis Jr., Director of the Poliomyelitis Vaccine Evaluation Center at the University of Michigan, declared Salk’s polio vaccine safe and effective, prompting celebrations across the nation.
By 1957, polio cases had decreased by ninety percent.
Text B: National Library of Medicine, guide to the Public Health Service polio vaccine papers
In April 1955 the Department of HEW licensed 6 companies to distribute a newly-developed polio vaccine developed by Jonas Salk of the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis. The vaccine’s effectiveness had been endorsed by NIH and the Surgeon General. Shortly after the vaccine was distributed, however, Cutter laboratory’s allotment was found to be tainted and a cause of 72 new cases of polio. Responding to the crisis, the U.S. Public Health Service directed CDC epidemiologist Alexander Langmuir to investigate.
Source: National Archives, DocsTeach: White House Press Release about Dr. Jonas E. Salk (description); Text B: National Library of Medicine, finding aid for the U.S. Public Health Service Polio Vaccine collection (MS C 251), Historical Note, findingaids.nlm.nih.gov/repositories/4/resources/684 (docsteach.org)