evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of different mediums for presenting a scientific subject, using Langley’s comparison of photographs, drawings and eyewitness description, and apply them to print, digital, video and multimedia choices for our exhibit.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. You want to show a friend a sunset you saw. You could send a phone photo, draw it, or describe it in words. Which would you choose, and what would each one miss?
In 1869 photographers tried to capture the corona, the glowing halo seen around the sun during a total eclipse. How do you predict the photo turned out?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Every medium is a trade-off. A medium gains some things and loses others. Langley’s book shows this in 1888: a photograph is trustworthy but early cameras missed faint light; a drawing catches more but is rushed and personal; a written eyewitness account gives feeling but only one person’s view.
Today’s mediums. Print (a panel or booklet) is permanent, readable at any pace, and needs no power, but holds limited text and no motion or sound. Digital text can link to sources and be updated, but needs a device and can distract. Video shows motion and voices, but forces a fixed pace and needs screens and sound. Multimedia combines them, but costs more time and can overload visitors.
Worked example 1: evaluating with evidence. Priya evaluates the photograph: advantage, “quite authentic portraits, since the sun himself made them”; disadvantage, the 1869 plate “having taken no impression” of the outer corona. Her judgment: photographs are trustworthy for what they catch, but you must know what they miss.
Worked example 2: applying it. Marcus plans a polio panel. A chart of cases by year shows the drop at a glance (advantage) but cannot show what families felt (disadvantage). A short audio memory adds feeling but takes a minute at a busy STEM night. He chooses a printed panel with a chart, plus a QR code linking to the audio for visitors who want more.
Purpose and audience decide. Ask: What must visitors understand? How long will they stay? Where will the exhibit stand? A library hallway, a gym at STEM night and a website each favor different mediums.
A model evaluation. Langley shows that no single medium tells the whole truth. He trusts photographs because “the sun himself made them,” yet admits an 1869 photograph “is very disappointing” because it missed the outer corona, while a drawing showed more but was “incomplete, whatever the artist’s skill.” For our exhibit, this means pairing a trustworthy image with careful words that explain what it shows.
Make a T-chart for each medium Langley names: plus (+) and minus (-).
Medium decision for your exhibit panel.
Choose a topic you might put on your panel (polio, the vaccine rollout, Langley's sun studies or his flight experiments). Evaluate three mediums for it (for example, printed panel, short video, digital page with links, audio clip, chart). For each, give one advantage and one disadvantage for a STEM night audience.
Write 4-5 sentences: Which combination will you use, and why? Checklist: (1) a clear choice, (2) reasons tied to audience and purpose, (3) one idea borrowed from Langley, quoted.
Each medium shows some of the truth. Next we see that writers can also disagree about what the truth is.
Exit ticket: which medium do you trust most for facts, and which for feelings? One sentence each.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 8, mini lesson 10, guided practice 9, decision 9.
Text note: copied from Project Gutenberg #64577: the first segment is from Chapter I (the sun photographs by Rutherfurd, 1870); the rest from Chapter II on eclipses. The figures Langley mentions are not reproduced here. Shelbyville and Springfield were observing stations for the 1869 eclipse; the passage does not name their states, so do not add them without a source.
Standards note (CC.1.2.8.G): Langley’s 1880s mediums are the bridge; make sure students apply the reasoning to modern print, digital, video and multimedia choices in the independent task.
Likely misconceptions: that photographs are always complete and objective; that video is always best; that a medium choice is only about what looks exciting.
Supports: the modern-mediums list from the mini lesson as a handout. Stretch: does a photograph edited for a panel stay “authentic”? What should a caption tell visitors?
Answer guide: eyewitness advantage: personal detail and feeling (“each can tell best what he has personally seen”); disadvantage: “Each one notes something different,” so one view may be partial. Decision response: accept any combination justified by audience (one-minute visitors), place (noisy gym or quiet library) and purpose (accuracy plus interest).
Samuel Pierpont Langley, The New Astronomy (Ticknor and Company, Boston, 1888), Project Gutenberg eBook #64577 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #64577
About the passage. These excerpts come from Chapters I and II of Langley’s 1888 book. In each one he stops to tell readers how the pictures in his book were made and how far to trust them. The last two paragraphs are about the total eclipse of 1869, seen across the United States.
What to notice. List every medium Langley mentions: photographs, engravings, drawings, printed descriptions, his own eyewitness account. For each, mark what he praises and what he warns about.
Words to know. Authentic means real and trustworthy. An engraver carved pictures into metal or wood so they could be printed in books. The corona is the glowing halo around the sun that shows during a total eclipse. Feebly means weakly. A fac-simile is an exact copy. Phenomena are events or things that can be observed.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
Opposite are three successive views (Figs. 2, 3, 4) taken on three successive days,–quite authentic portraits, since the sun himself made them; they being, in fact, projected telescopic images which have been fixed for us by photography, and then exactly reproduced by the engraver. […]
Each one notes something different from another at such a time; and though the reader will find minute descriptions of the phenomena already in print, it will perhaps be more interesting if, instead of citations from books, I invite him to view them with me, since each can tell best what he has personally seen. […]
It is impossible to give an exact view of what our friends at Shelbyville saw, for no drawings made there appear to have been preserved, and photography at that time could only indicate feebly the portion of the corona near the sun where it is brightest. Fig. 31 is a fac-simile of one of the photographs taken on the occasion, which is interesting perhaps as one of the early attempts in this direction, for comparison with later ones; but as a picture it is very disappointing, for the whole structure of the outer corona we have alluded to is missed altogether, the plate having taken no impression of it.
A drawing (Fig. 32) made by another observer, Mr. M’Leod, at Springfield, represents more of the outer structure; but the reader must remember that all drawings must, in the nature of the case (since there are but two or three minutes to sketch in), be incomplete, whatever the artist’s skill.
Source: Samuel Pierpont Langley, The New Astronomy (Ticknor and Company, Boston, 1888), Project Gutenberg eBook #64577 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)