give and use specific feedback on a complete panel draft, test it aloud and revise it with a revision log, the way National Park Service writers do.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Bring your complete panel draft: title, subtitle, introduction, sections, caption, words to know and conclusion. Count your words and write the total at the top.
Park Service planners name one tool for testing a finished exhibit with real visitors. What is it?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Fresh eyes. After days with your draft, you know what you meant, so you read what you meant instead of what you wrote. A reviewer reads only the page. The park planners ask “civilians” with little or no connection to their profession for that reason: they are like your STEM night visitors.
Today’s protocol (two rounds). (1) The writer reads the panel aloud while the reviewer times it; the gallery-talk version should fit in about 60 seconds. (2) The reviewer retells the big idea in one sentence. (3) The reviewer gives one glow and one grow, each tied to a checklist number and a specific sentence. (4) The reviewer answers “So what?” in the visitor’s words. (5) The writer asks one question of their own.
Helpful feedback is specific. “It’s good” helps no one. “Item 9: your second section starts with ‘Also,’ but it is a contrast, so try ‘However’” helps a lot. Talk about the writing, not the writer, and the writer decides what to change.
Cut to sharpen. Our checklist sets 250 to 350 words. If your panel is over 350 words, find a detail that does not serve your big idea and remove it. If a word made your reader stumble, replace it or define it.
Worked example 1: Isabella gives a grow. Isabella reviews Ethan’s polio panel. She writes: “Item 6: you have a strong quotation from Eisenhower, but I can’t tell where it is from. Add the source and year in the same sentence.” She names the item, the spot and a possible fix.
Worked example 2: Ethan keeps a revision log. Ethan lists each change: “Added ‘President Eisenhower said in 1955’ (item 6, Isabella). Cut a sentence about my visit to a doctor (off topic, word count 362 to 331). Replaced ‘huge’ with ‘nationwide’ (item 11).” A revision log shows your thinking and is part of your panel grade.
Use the park writers’ advice under “The text,” then practice before you trade drafts.
Workshop in pairs, then revise.
Reviewer: after timing your partner’s read-aloud, write (1) the time, (2) the big idea in one sentence, (3) one glow with a checklist number, (4) one grow with a checklist number and a quoted phrase and (5) your answer to “So what?”
Writer: start your revision log. List at least three changes from your partners’ feedback and the checklist, with the reason for each. Make the changes and record your new word count.
Harpers Ferry Center, in Harpers Ferry, West Virginia, is the part of the National Park Service that helps parks plan and produce exhibits, waysides, publications and other interpretive media. Its writer-editors keep an online HFC Editorial Style Guide for park staff, contractors and anyone else preparing park media. According to the guide, it aims to reduce distractions caused by differences in spelling, capitalization and hyphenation, and to eliminate derogatory, insensitive, racist and outdated language. The writer-editors work with subject experts across the Park Service to update entries as language changes.
Their wayside planning advice turns that care into a process: plan each exhibit as a team with a subject expert, an interpreter and a designer; sketch ideas small so the team can discuss them; then field-test the finished exhibit by timing visitors and asking ordinary readers for candid responses. Like our class, they write for a public that is on the move, so every word has to earn its place.
Every exhibit you have enjoyed was revised by people you never met.
Exit ticket: what is the most useful feedback you received today, and what will you change because of it?
Pacing: warm-up 2 minutes, reading 5, mini lecture with the case study 8, guided practice 8, two peer rounds of 7 minutes each, revision log 3. Continue revision in 2.24 if needed.
Source notes: the passage is copied from the Harpers Ferry Center page “Wayside Planning” (last updated March 18, 2024), with its straight quotation marks around “civilians” and its spelling “realworld” as printed. That page also contains the section “Wayside Exhibit Writing,” which ELA 5 and ELA 7 read, so this lesson uses other sections. The case study paraphrases the “HFC Editorial Style Guide” introduction (last updated August 19, 2026) and this page. Ethan’s panel quotes Eisenhower’s 1955 citation from Part 1.
Discussion: this lesson practices CC.1.5.8.A (collaborative discussion), owned in Unit 1. Model a respectful glow and grow before pairs begin.
Likely misconceptions: that the reviewer fixes the draft (the writer decides); that a field test grades the writer (it shows how real readers respond); that cutting means the draft was bad.
Supports: give reviewers sentence starters: “Item __: when you wrote ‘___,’ I learned ___.” “Item __: I was confused at ___; you might ___.” Pair students thoughtfully, and offer a teacher conference instead of a peer round for writers who need it.
Answer guide: mentor panel practice: glow, item 6, the exact Holman quotation with his name; grow, item 7, the caption could tell visitors what to notice in the chart (for example, that the groups were counted differently). Collect revision logs; they are part of the panel grade in 2.25.
National Park Service, Harpers Ferry Center: Wayside Planning · U.S. government work (National Park Service), public domain
You read other sections of this National Park Service page in 2.15. These sections explain how exhibit planners check their work. Each exhibit plan should reflect a whole team, not one writer. After an exhibit is made, the planners watch and time real visitors and ask ordinary people, whom they call “civilians,” for honest reactions, because real readers may respond very differently from the experts. Early on, the team sketches ideas small and rough so everyone can talk about them.
As you read, turn each idea into something you can do for a partner today. For example: “Tell me honestly where you lost interest.”
Words to know: perspective, point of view; obsessively, again and again, with great attention; field-test, try out in a real setting; eavesdrop, listen quietly to what others say; cultivate, build up or develop; solicit, ask for; candid, honest and direct; perceptual, having to do with noticing and seeing; thumbnail sketch, a very small, quick drawing; facilitate, make easier.
[…] At this stage, each exhibit in the proposal should reflect a team perspective, including the views of a subject matter expert, park interpreter, designer, wayside exhibit planner, and park superintendent. […]
Concluding Strategies
As in theater, wayside exhibits depend on an audience response. Obsessively field-test your products; spend hours observing people interacting with outdoor exhibits. Eavesdrop on their comments. Use a stopwatch to time people who stop at (or pass by) the exhibit. To test wayside exhibit concepts and effectiveness, cultivate a group of informal evaluators —”civilians” with little or no connection to the profession of interpretation or outdoor recreation. Solicit candid responses; don’t let them pull punches. Real people in a realworld outdoor setting may provide you with responses far different from those of your client park interpreter.
At its best, a wayside exhibit inspires a more active park visit. Good waysides often provide perceptual tools for further exploration. […]
Sketch Thumbnails
While your team (subject matter expert, writer, designer, interpreter) is on site get your ideas on paper so you can share them with others. Make a thumbnail sketch yourself, or have a designer do the drawing to help facilitate the discussion. Sketch small to encourage simplicity and focus. Have actual graphics on hand but don’t be limited by them. Brainstorm ideas and draw them all. The quality of the drawing is not as important as the ability to show ideas, hierarchy of information, and graphic options.
Source: National Park Service, Harpers Ferry Center: Wayside Planning (nps.gov)