write a title, subtitle and introduction that state my topic clearly and preview my sections, after studying how a 1919 Pittsburgh scientist introduced his report.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Here are two openings for the same panel. Which one would make you keep reading, and why? (A) “This panel is about polio.” (B) “In 1955, church bells rang across the country. A vaccine tested by millions of children had worked.”
A 1919 scientist is about to introduce a report on preventing influenza. What do you predict his first paragraph will do?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
The first lines do the most work. On a panel, the title and introduction are what most visitors read. The standard asks you to introduce the topic clearly, including a preview of what is to follow. A preview is a sentence that tells readers what parts are coming, like a map of your panel.
How Haythorn builds his introduction. Look at the job of each paragraph. Paragraph 1 states the problem: preventing influenza is one of the hardest problems in medicine, because old methods did not work. Paragraph 2 explains why it is hard to judge what worked, shows the experts’ disagreement with three paired examples and ends with his purpose: this paper will “state the facts and discuss their bearing on prevention as impartially as possible.” Paragraph 3 gives the background that leads to his focus, vaccines.
Key sentences. In paragraph 2, the sentence beginning “For instance” refines the idea of disagreement: it turns a general claim into three concrete conflicts. The last sentence of paragraph 3 narrows the whole introduction to one topic. Evaluating how particular sentences develop a concept is what CC.1.2.8.E asks you to do as a reader.
Three ways to open a panel. (1) A striking fact or scene: “In 1955, church bells rang.” (2) A problem: “For years, no one could stop polio.” (3) A question a visitor might ask: “How do you measure the heat of the sun?” Follow the hook with a sentence that names your topic and a preview that names your sections in order.
Worked example 1: Aisha revises a title. Aisha’s first title is “Polio.” It names a disease but not a breakthrough. She tries “The Shot Heard Round the World” and realizes it hides the topic. Her final version uses both jobs: a title that hooks and a subtitle that informs. Title: “When the Bells Rang.” Subtitle: “How a Pittsburgh Lab Helped Defeat Polio.”
Worked example 2: Connor writes a preview. Connor’s sections are “The Problem,” “The Instrument” and “What It Revealed.” His introduction reads: “How do you measure the heat of the sun? At the Allegheny Observatory, Samuel Langley found a way. This panel explains the problem he faced, the instrument he built and what it revealed about sunlight.” The last sentence previews all three sections in the same order they appear.
Watch out. Avoid announcing (“In this panel I will tell you about…”) without saying anything. A preview should still teach: “the problem he faced” tells the visitor there was a problem.
Use Haythorn’s introduction under “The text.” Number the paragraphs 1 to 3 in your notes.
Draft the opening of your panel.
Write a title (2 to 6 words) and a subtitle that names your breakthrough and Pittsburgh. Then explain in one sentence how each line does a different job.
Draft your introduction (40 to 70 words): a hook, a sentence that names your topic and a preview sentence that names your two or three sections in order. Underline the preview.
Your introduction is a promise. The rest of your panel keeps it.
Exit ticket: trade introductions with a partner. Can your partner name your sections from your preview alone? Write what they said.
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 9, mini lecture 9, guided practice 10, drafting 6, closure 2.
Source notes: the passage is copied from the Gutenberg file of the 1919 report. The first cut removes one sentence about a naval officer and one about a “chaos of opinions”; the second removes “These are by no means all, but are probably the most striking illustrations; and” before “with such examples.” “Present century” means the 1900s; the “Great World War” is World War I. Haythorn’s hope for a flu vaccine was not met in 1918; the CDC page in 2.23 says there was no vaccine to protect against influenza infection then.
Discussion note: the 1918 pandemic killed many people; some students may have family stories of recent illness or loss. Keep the focus on how scientists worked, and let students opt for another breakthrough if the topic is hard for them.
Likely misconceptions: that an introduction must be long; that a preview means “I will tell you about”; that a clever title can replace a clear subtitle.
Supports: read paragraph 2 aloud and chunk it at each semicolon. Offer a frame: “[Hook]. [Breakthrough] began in Pittsburgh when ___. This panel explains ___, ___ and ___.” Stretch: compare Haythorn’s purpose statement with the preview in our mentor panel.
Answer guide: sample summary: “Haythorn says preventing influenza is one of medicine’s hardest problems because methods that worked on other diseases failed in 1918, and experts disagree about what helped. Since vaccines controlled other diseases, he sees a vaccine as the greatest hope.” Sample preview: “This chapter reviews the vaccine experiments of 1918 and what their numbers can and cannot prove.”
Project Gutenberg, Studies on Epidemic Influenza by Members of the Faculty of the School of Medicine, University of Pittsburgh (1919), eBook #60822 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
In the fall of 1918 a deadly influenza epidemic reached Pittsburgh. Faculty of the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine studied it in emergency laboratories and published their findings in 1919 as Studies on Epidemic Influenza. One chapter, by Dr. Samuel R. Haythorn, director of the Singer Memorial Research Laboratories, asks how influenza epidemics could be prevented.
Below is the opening of his introduction. Watch what each paragraph does. The first names the problem. The second describes the disagreement among experts and then tells readers what his paper will try to do. The third explains where he thinks the greatest hope lies. His sentences are long and formal, as scientific writing was in 1919.
Words to know: preventive medicine, medicine that keeps disease from starting; quarantine, keeping sick or exposed people apart; ravaged, badly damaged; exponents, supporters; prophylactic, protecting against disease; impartially, fairly, without taking sides; sera, blood products that give quick protection (one is a serum).
THE PREVENTION OF EPIDEMIC INFLUENZA WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO VACCINE PROPHYLAXIS
By SAMUEL R. HAYTHORN, M. D.INTRODUCTION
In developing practical measures for the prevention or control of influenza epidemics, preventive medicine faces one of the most difficult problems of modern times. By means of quarantine, protective vaccination and instructions in personal hygiene many of the diseases which formerly ravaged the world have been brought under control. At first glance it would seem to be a simple matter to apply the principles which we have found successful against these diseases to influenza and let it go at that, but in the recent epidemic many of the formerly successful measures were tried and found to be either inefficient, inapplicable, or at least of doubtful value.
During the pandemic there was little time to think collectedly, and no time to analyze procedures, and even now it is far from easy to determine what things were done wisely and what things were of no practical value. There exists the greatest difference of opinion as to what measures should again be used when the need arises, and what ones should be discarded. For instance, there are confirmed exponents of prophylactic vaccines, and equally able men who are convinced of their uselessness; enthusiastic advocates of the face mask, and almost as many objectors; those who would close schools, churches, theatres, etc., and those who claim that such measures serve only to prolong the epidemic. […] While there remain so many points on which definite, concrete knowledge is lacking, and so much controversy over the relative value of various measures, this paper can do little more than state the facts and discuss their bearing on prevention as impartially as possible.
Great progress has been made in controlling contagious diseases in recent years—a fact which can be easily verified by anyone who will compare the sick reports of the Great World War with those of any war previous to the beginning of the present century. The diseases which have been most easily controlled have been those against which prophylactic vaccines or prophylactic sera have been developed. Smallpox, dysentery and typhoid fever have lent themselves readily to control by protective vaccination, while reliable temporary immunity can be afforded by the administration of sera for protection against diphtheria and tetanus. […] with such examples before us, the greatest hope for the prevention of influenza apparently lies in the development of a prophylactic vaccine against it.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Studies on Epidemic Influenza by Members of the Faculty of the School of Medicine, University of Pittsburgh (1919), eBook #60822 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)