reflect on how our research and writing grew from question to published episode, answer the driving question with evidence, and plan questions for future episodes.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Put your first segment plan from 2.15 next to your published script. Write one thing that stayed the same and one thing that changed.
What do you think changed most from your plan to your published segment?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Look back to look ahead. Reflection means thinking about what you did, what you learned and what you will do next. Writers and producers reflect after every project so the next one is stronger.
Back to our driving question. We started this unit with our eyes closed, asking, How does hearing a story change it? Since then you have compared stories in print, film and audio, heard a 1922 living room listen in, heard two readers make one poem sound different, and turned your own research into something people hear. Now you can answer with evidence.
The farmer’s list. The old farmer has lived through the telegraph, the telephone, automobiles, airplanes and wireless, and he still says radio “beats the world.” Every new medium changed how people got stories and news. Podcasts are on that list now, and so is our show.
Worked example 1: Aaliyah’s reflection. “My biggest growth was writing for the ear. My first draft said, ‘Fessenden, who had worked for Edison and taught at the Western University, joined the bureau.’ My final script says, ‘He had worked for Edison. Then he taught right here in Pittsburgh.’ My table-read partner said the short version was the first one she understood.”
Worked example 2: Ben answers the driving question. “Hearing a story adds a person’s choices. In the Parkville scene, the line ‘It was fine!’ sounded like a cheer when my partner read it. But hearing takes something away too: listeners cannot reread, so our segment had to repeat its claim. Next time, I want to find out who the first radio listeners in our town were.”
Circle discussion. We finish in a circle. Bring one growth you are proud of and one question for a future episode.
Use the radio-tent passage, then your own project folder.
Write your reflection for your portfolio.
Reflection paragraph: state your biggest growth in this project. Quote a sentence from an early draft and the same sentence in your final script, and explain why the change helps listeners. Name one short task and one long task from this unit that built that skill.
Answer the driving question, “How does hearing a story change it?” Use one text from this unit and our own episode as evidence. Then write two focused questions you would research for a future episode.
The farmer said radio “beats the world.” Somewhere, a listener may say the same about our show.
Exit ticket: finish this sentence: “Next time I make something for listeners, I will…”
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 6, mini lecture 6, guided practice with circle discussion 14, written reflection 8, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that reflection means summarizing the segment; that growth counts only if the final piece is perfect; that the driving question has one right answer. The cut in the passage removes a short exchange in which a boy says a girl is “pretty good, you know, for a girl” and Jessie objects; if students read the full chapter, discuss how the book pushes back on that idea. The farmer’s description (“ancient, baldheaded, bewhiskered”) is the narrator’s gentle humor; invite students to notice how the description makes his excitement more vivid.
Supports: provide reflection stems: “At first I…; now I…; this helps listeners because…” Seat the circle so every student can see the speaker. Stretch: write a short letter to next year’s seventh graders with three tips for making a radio segment.
Answer guide: sample driving-question answer: “Hearing a story changes it because a voice adds tone, pace and feeling. When Jessie’s neighbors heard the radio, it was ‘almost like hearing the real people right in the room.’ In our episode, the pause before ‘one mile’ made listeners lean in. But listeners cannot reread, so we had to repeat our claim. Future questions: Who were the first families in our town to own a radio? How did local news reach people before radio?” The reflection and new questions assess CC.1.4.7.X:1a (writing over short and extended time frames) and CC.1.4.7.V:2a.
Project Gutenberg, The Radio Girls of Roselawn by Margaret Penrose (Cupples & Leon, 1922), eBook #71771 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
This passage comes from later in Chapter XIII of The Radio Girls of Roselawn (1922), the bazaar we met in 2.21. Jessie gave her talk and ran the radio tent all afternoon and evening.
Notice who comes to listen, how often they come back and what made so many people curious. Then listen to the old farmer, who has lived through many inventions.
Words to know: presided means was in charge; rife means very common; ablaze means brightly lit; afire means burning or very excited; prosperous means successful with money; agriculturist means farmer; in its infancy means just beginning; plumb is old slang for completely.
The children were not the most interested part of the audience in the tent. From two o’clock until closing time Jessie Norwood presided at eight shows. She sometimes faced almost the same audience twice. Not only did some of the children pay their way in more than once, but grown people did the same. Curiosity regarding radio science was rife.
Doctor Stanley came more than once himself to listen. And the minister’s boys wanted to take the radio set all apart between shows to “see how it went.” […]
In the evening when the electric lights were ablaze the Norwood lawns were a pretty sight indeed. People came in cars from miles away. It was surprising how many came, it seemed, for the purpose of listening to the radio. That feature had been well advertised, and it came at a time when the popular curiosity was afire through reading so much about radio in the newspapers.
Among the hundreds of cars parked near by were those of several of the more prosperous farmers of the county. One ancient, baldheaded, bewhiskered agriculturist sat through three of the radio shows, and commented freely upon this new wonder of the world.
“The telegraph was just in its infancy when I was born,” he told Jessie. “And then came the telephone, and these here automobiles, and flying machines, and wireless telegraph, and now this. Why, ma’am, this radio beats the world! It does, plumb, for sure!”
Source: Project Gutenberg, The Radio Girls of Roselawn by Margaret Penrose (Cupples & Leon, 1922), eBook #71771 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)