use a source about early radio to generate related, focused research questions and turn them into a plan that draws on several sources.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now: the question ladder. Put these sample questions in order from broadest to most focused: (a) How did people get news in the 1920s? (b) What is the history of communication? (c) How did families near Pittsburgh hear the 1920 election results?
Which question could a team answer well in a five-minute radio segment?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Short research, real questions. A short research project answers one focused question using several sources. Along the way, good researchers write new, related questions. Some become part of the segment; others go in a “further research” list for the next team.
What makes a question focused? It names a topic, a place or group, and a time. It can be answered with evidence, not just opinion. It is interesting to our listeners: families and neighbors in our community.
Worked example 1: climbing down the ladder. Ana started with “What is the history of radio?” Too big. She narrowed it: “How did radio change daily life in the Mon Valley in the 1920s?” Then narrower: “How did families here hear their first radio broadcasts?” She can answer this with a newspaper archive, a library local-history file and an interview.
Worked example 2: a detail sparks a question. Devon read that Los Angeles officials “estimated” the traffic-light project saved 55,000 hours a day. He wrote two follow-ups: “How did they estimate that?” and “Does our area use radio time signals for anything today?” Notice the word estimated: it tells him to report it as an estimate, not a measured fact.
Planning across sources. For each sub-question, plan at least two kinds of sources: a government or library source, a primary source from the time (newspaper, photograph, recording), and if possible a person who remembers.
A model plan of my own. Main question: How did families near Pittsburgh hear the 1920 election results? Sub-questions: What equipment did listeners need? Who was on the air that night? How did newspapers report it the next day? Sources: the ITS and NIST pages; a 1920 newspaper in a digital archive; a local historical society.
Use the post under “The text” and your research log.
Write your research plan.
Research plan. Checklist: (1) your final focused question, (2) three sub-questions, (3) four search terms, (4) three planned sources, including at least one primary source and one government or library source, (5) two questions for further research.
Plans are ready. Last in this part: we pitch our segments and answer the driving question so far.
Exit ticket: what is the one thing you most want listeners to learn from your segment?
Pacing (40 min): question ladder 5, reading 7, mini lesson 8, guided practice 9, research plan 11.
Source notes: the post says the early concerts ran “from 8:30 to 11”; the history page in 2.07 adds “p.m.” The post’s call-letter date (Oct. 1, 1919) is more exact than the history page’s October 1919; both agree. The Los Angeles figures are the officials’ estimates and should be reported that way.
Interviews: any interview of a community member needs teacher approval, a parent or guardian’s knowledge, and the speaker’s permission before it is recorded or shared online.
Likely misconceptions: that a narrow question is boring; that one great source is enough; that new questions mean the research failed.
Supports: a ladder graphic (broad, narrower, focused); a bank of local topics. Stretch: write a question that compares two sources’ answers.
Answer guide: a strong plan has a place, time and topic in the main question and at least one primary source (a 1920s newspaper, photograph or recording).
National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), Taking Measure blog, NIST Radio Station WWV Celebrates a Century of Service, by Laura Ost, October 1, 2019 · U.S. government work, public domain (NIST staff writing)
About the source. NIST, a U.S. government science agency, posted this article on its blog in 2019 to mark 100 years of its radio station, WWV.
What it says. The agency, then the National Bureau of Standards, got the call letters WWV on Oct. 1, 1919, after a radio craze began following World War I. A 1919 newspaper story described the bureau sending “music through the air” from a record player to an auditorium nearby. WWV began broadcasting from Washington, D.C., in May 1920 with Friday evening concerts. The bureau later published instructions for building a home radio; the 1922 booklet cost 5 cents. Today WWV broadcasts the exact time all day, every day. In 1988, Los Angeles used WWV time codes to keep more than 1,000 traffic lights in step, and city officials estimated large savings in time and fuel.
Words to know. Call letters are a station’s official name. A craze is a sudden popular fad. A transmitter sends radio signals. To synchronize is to make things happen at the same time.
The radio broadcasting craze started after World War I. NIST, then known as the National Bureau of Standards (NBS), got the call letters WWV for its experimental radio transmitter on Oct. 1, 1919.
A 1919 newspaper story recounted that NBS experimented with broadcasting “music through the air,” transmitting tunes played on a Victrola record player several hundred yards to an NBS auditorium. That demonstration might have been sponsored by military laboratories then operating at NBS.
WWV began broadcasting in May 1920 from Washington, D.C., at a frequency of 600 kilohertz. The first broadcasts were Friday evening music concerts that lasted from 8:30 to 11. The 50-watt signal could be heard about 40 kilometers away.
Among many other relevant activities, NBS supported the public’s use of the novel technology by publishing instructions on how to build one’s own radio receiver. The agency’s 1922 how-to publication cost 5 cents.
[…]
In one interesting example of the NIST radio station’s impact, WWV time codes were used in a 1988 project by the city of Los Angeles to synchronize traffic lights at more than 1,000 intersections. City officials estimated that this project saved motorists 55,000 hours a day in driving time, conserved 22 million gallons per year in fuel, and prevented 6,000 to 7,000 tons of pollutants per year.
Source: National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), Taking Measure blog, NIST Radio Station WWV Celebrates a Century of Service, by Laura Ost, October 1, 2019 (nist.gov)