show what I have learned in Unit 1 by reading a new poem and its author’s note closely, writing a text-dependent analysis and turning in my final argument letter.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Take a slow breath. You have read like a historian and written like an advocate for weeks. Read the note and the poem twice: once for the story, once with your pencil. Mark every place where the poem and the note seem to disagree.
How confident are you that you can I am ready to read closely and use evidence from the texts.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
How this check works. Part A is a reading check on the note and the poem. Part B is a text-dependent analysis. Part C is your final argument letter with your checklist and revision log. Take your time and use evidence.
Reminders for Part A. When a question asks about history, use the note. When it asks about form, think about the pattern of the lines. When it asks about a word, reread the whole line and the lines around it.
Worked example 1: Mia compares two tellings. A practice question asks what the poem adds. Mia writes, “The note says she waved her flag when ‘General Burnside’s troops followed close upon Jackson’s.’ The poem instead has Jackson’s men shoot at her flag, so Whittier adds danger.” She quotes exactly and explains.
Worked example 2: Ben evaluates a source claim. Ben reads that Whittier wrote from “respectable and trustworthy sources.” He writes, “Whittier does not name these sources, so readers cannot judge whether they were credible.”
Reminders for Parts B and C. A TDA needs a clear claim, quotations copied exactly and an explanation after each. Your letter is scored with our ten-item checklist.
| # | Writer’s checklist | Standard |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | My introduction names the site and my reader and states my claim clearly. | H |
| 2 | My claim proposes one specific action: a marker, a preservation step or a display. | G |
| 3 | I give two or three clear reasons, each in its own paragraph. | J |
| 4 | My evidence comes from accurate, credible sources, and I name each source. | I |
| 5 | I explain how each piece of evidence supports my reason. | S |
| 6 | I acknowledge an opposing claim fairly and answer it with reasons. | I |
| 7 | Transition words, phrases and clauses connect my claim, reasons and evidence. | J |
| 8 | My conclusion follows from my argument and asks the reader to act. | J |
| 9 | I use a formal style, precise words and varied sentences. | K |
| 10 | Grammar, punctuation, spelling and letter format are correct. | L |
Constraints: 300 to 500 words, in business-letter form (greeting, body, closing, first name and grade). Every fact must come from a source you can name. Be respectful of the people and places you write about. Your teacher will confirm who receives the letters before anything is sent.
Part A: Reading check. Work alone. Answer each question from the note and the poem.
Parts B and C.
Part B (text-dependent analysis, about 25 minutes): Whittier changed what happened in Frederick. Using evidence from both the note and the poem, write an essay that answers: Is Whittier’s change to history a problem, a power, or both? Include an introduction with a clear claim, at least two body paragraphs with exact quotations and explanations, and a conclusion. Discuss how the poem’s form or word choice helps it persuade.
Part C: Submit your final argument letter with your checklist marked, your conference notes and your revision log. In two sentences, name the checklist item you improved most and how.
Whittier’s poem made a woman of Frederick famous, and his note asked readers to remember the facts too. You have done both kinds of work in this unit.
Exit ticket: which question on the check felt strongest for you, and which skill do you want to keep practicing?
Pacing: warm-up and two readings 8 minutes, reminders 3, Part A 12, Part B 25 (it may continue into the next lesson). Collect Part C at the end.
Coverage: Part A covers CC.1.3.7.E (couplet form, question 1), CC.1.3.7.H (questions 2-4 and 10), CC.1.3.7.I and J (questions 5, 6 and 9), CC.1.2.7.D (question 7, Whittier’s note as informational text), CC.1.2.7.H (question 8) and CC.1.2.7.J and K (questions 5, 6 and 9 use context, roots and connotation). Part B scores CC.1.4.7.S with K and L. Part C, the final letter, scores CC.1.4.7.G-L, with I and S for evidence.
Text and history notes: Whittier’s note is from the collected Works; the poem was first published in 1863. “Qnantrell” is copied exactly from the Project Gutenberg file and is glossed as a printing error for Quantrell. Whittier’s phrase “the Slavery Rebellion” names slavery as the cause of the war, which is historically accurate. The poem honors both Frietchie and Jackson’s “nobler nature”; students may discuss how that portrayal is itself a choice. The cut couplets describe the forty flags, the rest of the day and Whittier’s closing tribute.
Supports: read the texts aloud for students with reading accommodations. Allow typed responses and a TDA planning sheet. Rent and horde are deliberately left out of the words to know to test context clues.
Scoring Part A: questions 1-10 are 1 point each (10 points). Answer key: 1 = A (index 0), 2 = C (2), 3 = B (1), 4 = D (3), 5 = C (2), 6 = A (0), 7 = B (1), 8 = D (3), 9 = C (2), 10 = B (1).
Rubric for Part B (TDA) and Part C (letter). Score each row 4 (exceeds), 3 (meets), 2 (approaching) or 1 (beginning). Use rows 6-8 for Part B and rows 1-5 and 7-8 for Part C.
| Row (standard) | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Claim and introduction (G, H) | Site, reader and a specific, debatable proposal are clear at once | Clear claim with a specific proposal | Claim is vague or appears late | No clear claim |
| 2. Reasons and evidence (I) | Two or three reasons, each with accurate, named, credible evidence | Reasons with mostly credible, named evidence | Evidence is thin, unnamed or partly inaccurate | Little or no evidence |
| 3. Counterclaim (I) | Opposing claim stated fairly and answered with reasons and evidence | Opposing claim stated and answered | Opposing claim mentioned but not answered | No opposing claim |
| 4. Organization and conclusion (J) | Logical order, varied transitions, a conclusion that follows and asks for a specific action | Clear order, some transitions, a fitting conclusion | Order sometimes unclear; conclusion repeats or stops | Hard to follow; no conclusion |
| 5. Style (K) | Formal, precise and varied throughout | Mostly formal and precise | Some slang or vague words | Informal throughout |
| 6. Analysis claim (S) | A clear, insightful claim that answers the whole question | A clear claim that answers the question | A claim that answers part of the question | No claim, or a summary only |
| 7. Evidence explained (S) | Well-chosen exact quotations from both texts, each fully explained | Accurate quotations with explanation | Quotations with little explanation | Little or no evidence |
| 8. Conventions (L) | Few or no errors; letter format correct | Minor errors that do not distract | Frequent errors | Errors make it hard to read |
Part B: 12 points possible (rows 6-8); 9 or more meets the standard. Part C: 28 points possible (rows 1-5, 7-8); 21 or more meets the standard and the letter is ready to send. Below that, confer and allow one more revision before 1.26.
Sample TDA paragraph: “Whittier’s change is a power because it turns a real act of loyalty into a picture readers can carry. His note says she ‘waved her flag and cheered’ Union troops, but in the poem she cries, ‘Shoot, if you must, this old gray head, / But spare your country’s flag.’ The steady couplets make the line easy to remember. Still, it is also a problem, because his own note admits ‘the story was probably incorrect in some of its details,’ so readers who never see the note learn a legend as history.”
Project Gutenberg, Poems in Wartime, from Volume III of The Works of Whittier, eBook #9578 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
John Greenleaf Whittier was an American poet who spoke out against slavery. He published “Barbara Frietchie” in 1863, during the Civil War. The poem tells of an old woman in Frederick, Maryland, who flies the Union flag as Confederate General Stonewall Jackson’s troops march through town in September 1862.
Years later, when his works were collected, Whittier added a note before the poem. In it he admits that the story has been questioned and explains what people agree really happened. You will read the note first, then the poem. Some couplets are cut, marked […].
Words to know: conformity means agreement; testimony means statements from witnesses; Slavery Rebellion is Whittier’s name for the Confederate war; General Burnside led Union troops; Qnantrell is a printing error in this file for the name Quantrell; spires means pointed church towers; staff means flagpole; slouched means with a drooping brim; sash means a window frame; famished means very hungry.
Whittier’s note
This poem was written in strict conformity to the account of the incident as I had it from respectable and trustworthy sources. It has since been the subject of a good deal of conflicting testimony, and the story was probably incorrect in some of its details. It is admitted by all that Barbara Frietchie was no myth, but a worthy and highly esteemed gentlewoman, intensely loyal and a hater of the Slavery Rebellion, holding her Union flag sacred and keeping it with her Bible; that when the Confederates halted before her house, and entered her dooryard, she denounced them in vigorous language, shook her cane in their faces, and drove them out; and when General Burnside’s troops followed close upon Jackson’s, she waved her flag and cheered them. It is stated that May Qnantrell, a brave and loyal lady in another part of the city, did wave her flag in sight of the Confederates. It is possible that there has been a blending of the two incidents.
BARBARA FRIETCHIE
Up from the meadows rich with corn,
Clear in the cool September morn.The clustered spires of Frederick stand
Green-walled by the hills of Maryland.Round about them orchards sweep,
Apple and peach tree fruited deep,Fair as the garden of the Lord
To the eyes of the famished rebel horde,On that pleasant morn of the early fall
When Lee marched over the mountain-wall;Over the mountains winding down,
Horse and foot, into Frederick town.[…]
Up rose old Barbara Frietchie then,
Bowed with her fourscore years and ten;Bravest of all in Frederick town,
She took up the flag the men hauled down;In her attic window the staff she set,
To show that one heart was loyal yet.Up the street came the rebel tread,
Stonewall Jackson riding ahead.Under his slouched hat left and right
He glanced; the old flag met his sight.“Halt!”–the dust-brown ranks stood fast.
“Fire!”–out blazed the rifle-blast.It shivered the window, pane and sash;
It rent the banner with seam and gash.Quick, as it fell, from the broken staff
Dame Barbara snatched the silken scarf.She leaned far out on the window-sill,
And shook it forth with a royal will.“Shoot, if you must, this old gray head,
But spare your country’s flag,” she said.A shade of sadness, a blush of shame,
Over the face of the leader came;The nobler nature within him stirred
To life at that woman’s deed and word.“Who touches a hair of yon gray head
Dies like a dog! March on!” he said.[…]
1863.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Poems in Wartime, from Volume III of The Works of Whittier, eBook #9578 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)