choose a local historic site and a specific proposal for my argument letter, and learn the checklist our readers will use.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. In Part 1 you saw how Longfellow and Paul Revere told the same night in very different ways, and in 1.14 you made a letter plan. Take out that plan. If you have not chosen a place yet, list two places in our communities (East McKeesport, North Versailles, Wall or Wilmerding) that you think have a story, and one thing a visitor should know about each.
A borough council gets a letter from a seventh grader asking for a history display. What would make the council take it seriously?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Writers, welcome to Build. In Part 1 you asked whether it is a problem or a power when writers change history. Now you will use the power of writing yourself. Each of you will write a formal argument letter that asks a real reader, the borough council or a local historical society, to help people remember a local place.
Your task. Choose a local historic site. Then propose one specific action: a historical marker, a preservation step (such as cleaning, repairing or protecting something) or a school or public display. Your letter must make a claim, support it with reasons and evidence from credible sources, answer the other side and end with a request.
What an argument is. An argument is not a fight. It is a reasoned case for a claim, a statement someone could disagree with. “The building is old” is a fact. “The borough should approve a display about the building” is a claim.
Read our mentor letter. A mentor text is a model we study to learn craft. Our class mentor was written for this unit, and its facts come from today’s National Park Service record. We will return to it in every lesson.
Mentor letter: “A Display for a Building We Pass Every Day” (written for our class; the student is invented)
Dear Members of the Borough Council:
My name is Jordan, and I am a seventh grader in the East Allegheny School District. Every day my bus passes the Westinghouse Air Brake Company General Office Building at Marguerite and Bluff Streets in Wilmerding. Most students on my bus do not know why it matters. I am writing to ask the council to support a student-made history display about the building in our school and in the borough building.
First, the building is officially recognized as part of our nation’s history. According to the National Park Service, it was listed in the National Register of Historic Places. Its National Register record is dated March 6, 1987. The record lists three reasons it qualifies: an important event, its architecture and engineering, and an important person, George Westinghouse.
Second, the building tells the story of work in our own valley. The same record names “industry” and “community planning and development” as areas of significance. In other words, this building is connected to the jobs and the town plan that shaped Wilmerding.
Some people may argue that a display costs money and that anyone can look the building up online. That is a fair concern. However, our class will research, write and design the display ourselves, so the main cost is a wall and a frame. Also, a record online only helps people who already know to search for it. A display meets people where they are.
For these reasons, I ask the council to approve wall space for a student history display by the end of the school year. Our town’s past is standing right on the corner. Please help us make sure the next generation knows its name.
Respectfully,
Jordan, Grade 7
Worked example 1: Aaliyah narrows her site. Aaliyah starts with “old buildings in North Versailles.” That is too broad for one letter. She asks: Which one place can I find real sources about? She chooses one site, checks that she can find at least two sources and writes it on her planning card.
Worked example 2: Mateo turns a topic into a proposal. Mateo writes, “Trains are important to our town.” His partner asks, “What do you want the reader to do?” Mateo revises: “The historical society should create a display about our town’s railroad history at the library.” Now there is a reader, an action and a place.
Our checklist. Our readers will judge every letter by these ten points. We will build each skill in the lessons ahead.
| # | Writer’s checklist | Standard |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | My introduction names the site and my reader and states my claim clearly. | H |
| 2 | My claim proposes one specific action: a marker, a preservation step or a display. | G |
| 3 | I give two or three clear reasons, each in its own paragraph. | J |
| 4 | My evidence comes from accurate, credible sources, and I name each source. | I |
| 5 | I explain how each piece of evidence supports my reason. | S |
| 6 | I acknowledge an opposing claim fairly and answer it with reasons. | I |
| 7 | Transition words, phrases and clauses connect my claim, reasons and evidence. | J |
| 8 | My conclusion follows from my argument and asks the reader to act. | J |
| 9 | I use a formal style, precise words and varied sentences. | K |
| 10 | Grammar, punctuation, spelling and letter format are correct. | L |
Constraints: 300 to 500 words, in business-letter form (greeting, body, closing, first name and grade). Every fact must come from a source you can name. Be respectful of the people and places you write about. Your teacher will confirm who receives the letters before anything is sent.
Use the record and the mentor letter. Talk with a partner before you answer the open questions.
Plan your argument letter.
Update your 1.14 letter plan on a planning card: (1) the site, (2) the reader (borough council or historical society), (3) your proposal in one sentence, (4) two sources you will check and (5) one question you still have.
Vocabulary in context: using the record, explain what areas of significance means. Then write one sentence that uses the word significance about your own site.
A council member reads many letters. Yours will stand out if it asks for one clear thing and proves why.
Exit ticket: write your proposal as one sentence that names the reader, the action and the site.
Pacing: warm-up 5 minutes, reading 7, mini lecture with the mentor letter 10, guided practice 10, planning card 6, closure 2.
Recipient: before Build begins, confirm a real recipient (the borough council of one of the district’s communities or a local historical society) and how letters will be delivered. Tell students who will read their letters; it changes how they write.
Likely misconceptions: that an argument means arguing angrily; that a topic (“trains”) is the same as a claim; that any likely-sounding detail can be added. Stress that the NPGallery record is short and that its full nomination is not yet digitized, so students should not invent details about the building.
Supports: offer a short site bank the teacher has checked (for example the Wilmerding building in the mentor letter, or another listed place found through the National Register database or a local historical society). Students may write about a place outside the district if they have a personal connection, with teacher approval. Stretch: find a second credible source about the site tonight.
Answer guide: sample planning card: “(1) the Westinghouse Air Brake General Office Building, (2) the borough council, (3) The council should approve a student display about the building in the borough building, (4) the NPS National Register record and the National Park Service page on how places are listed, (5) What did the building do in 1926?” Sample vocabulary answer: “Areas of significance are the parts of history where a place matters, like industry or architecture.”
National Park Service, NPGallery: Westinghouse Air Brake Company General Office Building, National Register record 87000376 · U.S. government work (National Park Service), public domain
NPGallery is the National Park Service’s online library of records for the National Register of Historic Places, the nation’s official list of historic places. This page is the record for the Westinghouse Air Brake Company General Office Building in Wilmerding, Allegheny County, at Marguerite and Bluff Streets.
The record is short, but every line is evidence. It lists three applicable criteria, or reasons the building qualified: an event, architecture and engineering, and a person. The significant name is George Westinghouse. The architects were Frederick J. Osterling and the firm Janssen and Cocken, and the styles include Renaissance and Romanesque. The areas of significance are industry, community planning and development, architecture and social history. The significant years are 1890, 1896 and 1926, and the record is dated March 6, 1987.
Notice one more fact: the full nomination document for this record is not yet digitized, so a careful writer uses only what the record says.
Words to know: criteria means the standards used to judge something; significance means importance; resource here means a historic place or thing.
Source: National Park Service, NPGallery: Westinghouse Air Brake Company General Office Building, National Register record 87000376 (npgallery.nps.gov)