show what I have learned by analyzing a story passage and a speaker’s argument, writing a short radio script on demand and submitting our finished segment.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Take two slow breaths. Then write one thing you know now about writing for listeners that you did not know at the start of this unit.
On a reading check, what should you do first with each question?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
How the unit check works. Today has three parts. Part A is a reading and listening check on the passage: answer each question from the text. Your teacher will also read the passage aloud once, so you can think about how it sounds. Part B is a short on-demand script. Part C is turning in your finished segment.
Reminders for Part A. To delineate an argument, list the claim, the supporting reasons and the evidence for each. To evaluate it, ask whether the reasoning is sound and whether the evidence is relevant and sufficient. To compare media, ask what the page shows that a listener cannot hear, and what a voice or sound adds.
Reminders for Part B. Write for the ear: short sentences, speaker labels, a sound cue on its own line, and a clear point. Keep the characters true to the passage.
Reminders for Part C. Your packet holds your final script with on-air credits, the recording, the show notes with links and citations, your research log with your new questions, your revision log and your medium note. Check it against the producer’s checklist.
| # | Producer’s checklist | Standard |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Our segment answers one focused research question, and our most important finding comes early and comes back at the end. | V, D |
| 2 | We used at least three credible sources, named them aloud and cited them in the show notes; quotes are exact and paraphrases are in our own words. | W |
| 3 | My script is written for the ear: short sentences, signposts and a repeated key point. | X |
| 4 | I adapted my speech to my role (host, narrator, interviewer) and to our listeners. | E |
| 5 | Sound elements and one visual (episode art or an image in the show notes) clarify a point instead of just decorating. | F |
| 6 | I speak with adequate volume, a steady pace and clear pronunciation. | D |
| 7 | I use standard English when I speak, except for a quotation or a character voice I chose on purpose. | G |
| 8 | We wrote in a shared document and published the episode with show notes that link to and cite sources. | U |
| 9 | My research log, drafts and revision log show work over time. | X |
| 10 | My medium note explains one way hearing our story changes it from reading it. | 1.3.G |
Constraints: each segment runs about five minutes; each student writes and voices 150 to 200 words. Use only sounds and music you made yourself, public-domain audio or audio your teacher approves, and cite them. First names only on air.
Part A: Reading and listening check. Work alone. Use the passage. Answer each question from the passage.
Parts B and C.
Part B (on-demand writing, about 15 minutes): Write a 60-second radio script that turns the end of this scene into an audio play. Use speaker labels for JESSIE and AMY, at least one sound cue that tells listeners Amy is knitting on a porch, one line where Amy’s tone shows she is teasing, and an ending line that shows Jessie’s next step. Keep both characters true to the passage.
Part C: Submit your segment packet: final script with on-air credits, recording, show notes with links and citations, research log with at least two new questions for further research, revision log and medium note.
Jessie went looking for a better source. You have spent a unit doing just that.
Exit ticket: which question on the check felt strongest for you, and which skill will you keep practicing?
Pacing: warm-up 2 minutes, reading (silent, then read aloud by the teacher once) 7, brief reminders 3, Part A 15, Part B 13. Collect Part C at the end or by the next lesson.
Coverage: Part A covers CC.1.5.7.B:1a (questions 1, 2 and the short response delineation), B:2a (question 2 and the evaluation), CC.1.3.7.G:1a and G:2a (question 6 and the short response medium comparison), CC.1.5.7.C:1a (question 7, quantitative information presented in a source) and CC.1.4.7.W:2a (question 3: credibility of print). Part B covers CC.1.4.7.X:1a (writing in a short time frame), CC.1.5.7.E:1a (adapting voice and tone in a script) and CC.1.3.7.G:2a (sound techniques). Part C covers CC.1.4.7.V:1a and V:2a (research question, several sources, new questions), W:1a and W:2a (sources, credibility, quotes and citations), X:1a (work over an extended time), U:2a (shared-document history) and the production rows. Delivery, publishing and spoken conventions (CC.1.5.7.D, F, G and CC.1.4.7.U:1a) are scored on the recording here and confirmed at the premiere in 2.26.
Supports: read the passage aloud for students with reading accommodations (Part A then measures comprehension and listening). Allow typed responses. Cuts are marked […]; the omitted lines are jokes that are not needed. Demise is left out of the words to know on purpose, so question 4 tests context clues. The Civil War grandfather is a joke in the story; no further context is needed.
Scoring Part A: questions 1-7 are 1 point each. The short response is scored 0-5: 1 for Jessie’s claim, 1 for two accurate reasons with evidence, 1 for a judgment of soundness, 1 for a judgment of relevance and sufficiency, and 1 for an explained medium comparison with a quotation. Part B is scored 0-4 with rows 3, 4 and 5 of the rubric (average, rounded).
Segment rubric (Part C and the recording). Score each row 4 (exceeds), 3 (meets), 2 (approaching) or 1 (beginning).
| Row | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Research (V) | A focused question answered from several sources, with two or more strong new questions | A focused question answered from several sources, with a new question | The question is broad or only one source is used | No clear question |
| 2. Sources and citation (W) | Credible sources, judged in the log; exact quotes, true paraphrases, credits on air and complete citations | Credible sources, credited aloud and cited | Some sources uncredited or citations incomplete | Copied wording or no citations |
| 3. Writing for the ear and process (X) | Short, clear sentences, signposts and repetition; logs show steady work and real revision | Mostly clear for listeners; logs show revision | Some long or confusing sentences; little revision | Reads like an essay; no logs |
| 4. Claims and findings, delivery (D) | One claim, salient points first and last; strong volume, pace and pronunciation (plus eye contact in the live introduction) | Focused claim with supported findings; clear delivery | Findings wander from the claim, or delivery is hard to follow in places | No clear claim, or delivery cannot be understood |
| 5. Adapted speech (E) | Voice and words fit each role and the audience throughout | Mostly fits role and audience | Same flat voice for every role | Not suited to listeners |
| 6. Sound and visual (F) | Every sound and the visual clarify a key point; voices always clear | Sound and visual mostly clarify | Sounds decorate or cover voices | No sound plan or visual |
| 7. Spoken conventions (G) | Standard grammar throughout, with intentional exceptions marked | Minor slips that do not distract | Frequent errors | Errors block understanding |
| 8. Publishing and collaboration (U) | Show notes complete with working links; comment history shows active collaboration | Show notes with links; some collaboration | Missing links or little collaboration | Not ready to publish |
| 9. Medium note (1.3.G) | Explains with evidence how hearing changes the story, naming techniques unique to audio and print | Explains one difference with evidence | Names a difference without evidence | No medium note |
A total of 27-36 meets the standard for publishing. Below 27, confer and allow one more revision before the premiere.
Answer key: 1 = D (index 3), 2 = A (0), 3 = B (1), 4 = C (2), 5 = B (1), 6 = D (3), 7 = A (0). Sample short response: “Jessie claims she can and should put a radio set in her house. Her reasons are that radio is ‘much improved’ and that ‘Anybody can have a receiving set.’ Her evidence is a magazine article and the idea that ‘Everybody is doing it.’ The article is relevant, but her reasoning is not sound when she says it must be true because ‘it is printed here,’ and popularity is not sufficient proof. Amy is right that ‘You mustn’t believe everything you see in print.’ Performed aloud, Amy’s line ‘There’s one right in this town’ would sound like a joke from her tone, while on the page I only realize it is a joke when she describes the gossip’s house.” Sample Part B: SOUND: a porch swing creaks; knitting needles click. JESSIE: “It’s printed right here, Amy!” AMY (teasing): “My grandfather was printed dead once, and he came home for supper.” JESSIE: “Then I’ll find a real radio book. Tomorrow.” SOUND: the screen door bangs.
Project Gutenberg, The Radio Girls of Roselawn by Margaret Penrose (Cupples & Leon, 1922), eBook #71771 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
This passage comes from the very first chapter of The Radio Girls of Roselawn (1922), before Jessie has a radio. Jessie Norwood has just read a magazine article about radio and is excited. Her friend Amy Drew is knitting on the porch and loves to joke. Jessie wants to install a radio set at home and wants Amy to help.
As you read, notice each reason Jessie gives and how Amy answers. Amy is teasing, but one of her points is serious.
Words to know: receiving set means a radio that picks up broadcasts; aerials are antennas; erect here means to put up; chuckled means laughed quietly; gossips are people who spread news about others; writhed means twisted as if in pain; obituary is a newspaper notice that someone has died. Other words you will figure out from context.
“Oh, but Amy!” cried Jessie, with a toss of her blond head, “that is old stuff. The radio of to-day is very different—much improved. Anybody can have a receiving set and hear the most wonderful things out of the air. It has been brought to every home.”
“‘Have you a little radio in your home?’” chuckled Amy, her fingers still flying. […]
“I mean to have a radio set,” repeated Jessie quite seriously. “It says in this magazine article that one can erect the aerials and all, oneself. And place the instrument. I am going to do it.” […]
“It has to be sent from a broadcasting station,” announced Jessie.
“There’s one right in this town,” declared Amy, with vigor.
“No!”
“Yes, I tell you. She lives in the second house from the corner of Breen Street, the yellow house with green blinds——”
“Now, Amy! Listen here! Never mind local gossips. They only broadcast neighborhood news. But we can get concerts and weather reports and lectures——”
Amy painfully writhed in her chair at this point. “Say not so, Jess!” she begged. “Get lectures enough at school—and from dad, once in a while, when the dear thinks I go too far.” […]
“Now listen!” She read a long paragraph from the magazine article. “You see, it is the very latest thing to do. Everybody is doing it. And it is the most wonderful thing!”
Amy had listened with more seriousness. She could be attentive and appreciative if she wished. The paragraph her chum read was interesting.
“Go ahead. Read some more,” she said. “Is that all sure enough so, Jess?”
“Of course it is so. Don’t you see it is printed here?”
“You mustn’t believe everything you see in print, Jess. My grandfather was reported killed in the Civil War, and he came home and pointed out several things they had got wrong in the newspaper obituary—especially the date of his demise. Now this——”
“I am going to get a book about it, and that will tell us just what to do in getting a radio set established.”
Source: Project Gutenberg, The Radio Girls of Roselawn by Margaret Penrose (Cupples & Leon, 1922), eBook #71771 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)