evaluate a historian’s reasoning about an early biography, show understanding of the unit’s texts in a reading check, and plan an argument letter that answers the driving question.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Patrick Henry, a Virginia leader in the Revolution, is remembered for a famous speech he gave in 1775. No one wrote it down word for word at the time. How could a writer 40 years later know what he said?
Historian Moses Coit Tyler wrote about William Wirt, who wrote the first full biography of Henry. Do you predict Tyler attacks Wirt or defends him?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Evaluating a historian. Tyler makes an argument: Wirt’s book is limited, but Wirt deserves credit. To evaluate it, ask: are his reasons relevant? Is his evidence sufficient? Does the conclusion follow?
Tracing Tyler. Reason 1: Wirt finished in 1817, before many records were published. Reason 2: so Wirt relied on “somewhat imaginative traditions” and memories that were “nearly always vague … often inaccurate.” Conclusion: readers should “applaud him for making so good a book, rather than to blame him for not making a better one.”
Worked example 1: judging soundness. Noah writes: Tyler’s reasoning is sound. If the records were not yet available, Wirt could not use them, so he had to depend on memories. That fairly explains the weak parts of his book.
Worked example 2: judging sufficiency. Priya adds: In this passage Tyler asserts that the memories were inaccurate but does not show an example. To be sufficient, he would need to compare one remembered story with a record. The rest of his book may do that, but this paragraph alone does not.
Back to the driving question. Longfellow, Whitman, Shakespeare and Wirt all changed or rebuilt history. Sometimes it was a power: it inspired unity, gave a nation words for grief, kept a speech alive. Sometimes it was a problem: Dawes and Prescott were pushed aside, and a reconstruction can be mistaken for a record. Your argument letter will take a position on how a local place should be remembered, accurately and powerfully.
Planning the letter. An argument letter has a claim (what you propose), reasons, evidence (facts you can verify), a counterclaim you answer respectfully, like Franklin in 1.08, and a clear request.
Reading check, part 1: today’s passage. Then part 2 reviews the unit.
Reading check, part 3, and your letter plan.
Short response (reading check): Choose ONE pair we studied (Longfellow and Revere, or Whitman and Leale). Explain how the fiction used or altered the history, and whether that change was a problem or a power. Use at least one quotation from each text. (6-8 sentences)
Argument letter plan: (1) the local place, (2) what you propose (marker, preservation step or school display), (3) your claim in one sentence, (4) two reasons, (5) one fact you must still verify and where you will check it, (6) a counterclaim someone might raise and your respectful answer.
We have read, investigated and made sense of how writers change history. In Part 2 we draft, revise and send our argument letters.
Exit ticket: answer the driving question in one sentence: When writers change history, is that a problem or a power?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 3, reading 6, mini lesson 8, reading check 13, letter plan 10.
Reading check scoring (formative, 20 points): five quizzes and the true/false at 2 points each (12); the open question on Tyler, 4 points (2 for a judgment of soundness, 2 for a relevant quotation); the short response, 4 points (claim 1, quotation from each text 2, problem-or-power judgment 1). Part 2’s unit check scores the argument letter with the full rubric.
Evidence of learning: this lesson assesses CC.1.2.7.H (Tyler), CC.1.2.7.D (Tyler’s position on Wirt), CC.1.2.7.K (disinterested) and CC.1.3.7.H (short response). Collect letter plans for Part 2.
Likely misconceptions: that disinterested means uninterested; that a reconstruction is worthless; that sound reasoning must also have sufficient evidence (they are separate questions).
Supports: read the long Tyler sentence in chunks; the letter plan as a graphic organizer. Stretch: compare Tyler’s judgment of Wirt with the NPS judgment of Longfellow.
Sample answers: open question: Tyler’s reasoning is sound: because records were “not within the reach of Wirt,” he had to use memories. But this passage only asserts the memories were “often inaccurate” without an example, so the evidence here is not sufficient on its own. Short response: see the samples in 1.04, 1.06 and 1.12.
Moses Coit Tyler, Patrick Henry (Houghton Mifflin, 1887), Project Gutenberg eBook #29368, Preface · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #29368
About the text. In 1887 Moses Coit Tyler published a biography of Patrick Henry. In his preface he explains why the only earlier full biography, by William Wirt (finished in 1817), had trouble telling the truth. Wirt wrote before many letters, diaries and records were published. Tyler weighs how much that matters. His judgment helps us decide how far to trust the stories in Wirt’s book, which is where the words of Henry’s famous 1775 speech come from. Notice that Tyler is a historian judging another writer, which is exactly what careful readers do.
What to notice. Trace Tyler’s argument: what Wirt lacked, what he relied on instead, and how Tyler judges him in the end. Notice the words Tyler uses to describe old people’s memories.
Words to know. A memoir here means a biography. Inaccessible means impossible to reach or use. Traditions are stories passed down by word of mouth. Disinterested means not gaining anything personally, so fair. Memoranda are written notes and records. To ascertain is to find out for certain.
Read the passage under “The text” once for meaning and once with a pencil.
Notwithstanding the great popular interest attaching to the name of Patrick Henry, he has hitherto been the subject of but one memoir founded on original investigation, and that, of course, is the Life by William Wirt. When it is considered, however, that Wirt’s book was finished as long ago as the year 1817,–before the time had fairly come for the publication of the correspondence, diaries, personal memoranda, and official records of every sort, illustrating the great period covered by Patrick Henry’s career,–it will be easy to infer something as to the quantity and the value of those printed materials bearing upon the subject, which are now to be had by us, but which were not within the reach of Wirt. Accordingly, in his lack of much of the detailed testimony that then lay buried in inaccessible documents, Wirt had to trust largely to the somewhat imaginative traditions concerning Patrick Henry which he found floating in the air of Virginia; and especially to the supposed recollections of old people,–recollections which, in this case, were nearly always vague, not always disinterested, often inaccurate, and generally made up of emotional impressions rather than of facts. Any one who will take the trouble to ascertain the enormous disadvantages under which Wirt wrote, and which, as we now know, gave him great discouragement, will be inclined to applaud him for making so good a book, rather than to blame him for not making a better one.
Source: Moses Coit Tyler, Patrick Henry (Houghton Mifflin, 1887), Project Gutenberg eBook #29368, Preface (gutenberg.pglaf.org)