determine Benjamin Franklin’s position and purpose in his last speech to the Constitutional Convention, analyze how he distinguishes his position from the delegates who still objected, and explain how word connotations shape his argument.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Your group has finished a project, but two members still dislike parts of it. You want everyone to sign off. What is the first thing you would say to them? Write one sentence.
In September 1787, delegates in Philadelphia finished a plan for a new national government, the Constitution. Some still disliked parts of it. Benjamin Franklin, the oldest delegate, wanted all of them to sign. How do you predict his speech began?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Point of view and purpose. In nonfiction, an author’s point of view is the position he or she takes on a topic. The purpose is what the author wants the audience to think or do. Franklin’s position: the Constitution has faults, but it should be signed and supported. His purpose: get every delegate, even the doubters, to sign it.
Distinguishing a position. Strong arguers do not just state their view; they show how it differs from others. Franklin’s audience includes delegates who still had “objections.” He agrees with part of their view (the plan is not perfect) and disagrees with their conclusion (so do not sign).
Worked example 1: admit, then contrast. Aiden studies the first sentence: “I confess that there are several parts of this constitution which I do not at present approve, but I am not sure I shall never approve them.” Aiden writes: Franklin starts on the doubters’ side. Then the word “but” sets him apart: he is willing to doubt his own judgment, and he hints that they should too. Admitting a point to the other side is called a concession.
Worked example 2: answering the other side. Brianna looks for the doubters’ complaint, that the plan is not perfect. Franklin answers with a question: “From such an assembly can a perfect production be expected?” Brianna writes: He turns their complaint around. Any meeting brings people’s “prejudices” and “selfish views,” so a perfect plan is impossible, and this one is surprisingly close.
Connotation. Franklin says he will “sacrifice” his opinions “to the public good.” Sacrifice suggests giving up something valuable for others, which makes signing sound generous, not weak. His final wish that each member “doubt a little of his own infallibility” is gently humorous: no one claims to be infallible, so the phrase makes stubbornness sound silly.
Fact, fiction and history again. We know these words through Madison’s notes. Because Franklin wrote his speech down, Madison could record it closely. Notice that Franklin himself chose what history would hear: “Within these walls they were born, and here they shall die.” He kept his objections out of the public record on purpose.
Underline Franklin’s view in one color and the doubters’ view in another.
Analyze point of view.
How does Benjamin Franklin distinguish his position from that of the delegates who still object? Write 5-6 sentences. Checklist: (1) state Franklin's position and purpose, (2) quote the concession he makes, (3) quote one reason he gives, (4) explain how his answer sets him apart from the doubters.
Problem or power? Franklin says of his objections, “Within these walls they were born, and here they shall die.” Is it a problem or a power when a leader keeps doubts out of the public record? Explain in 3 sentences.
Franklin agreed with his opponents before he disagreed with them. Next we trace the reasoning of the most famous short speech in American history.
Exit ticket: write one sentence that admits a fair point to someone before you disagree, the way Franklin begins.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading aloud 8, mini lesson 9, guided practice 10, analysis 9.
Text note: the passage is from Madison’s notes for Monday, September 17, 1787, in The Journal of the Debates in the Convention which Framed the Constitution, ed. Gaillard Hunt (G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1908), vol. 2, Project Gutenberg #41095. The small raised letters (Docr, Mr) are Madison’s abbreviations for Doctor and Mister. Cuts, each marked […], remove a joke about church beliefs with a French quotation, the second half of one long sentence, one clause about foreign enemies, and a passage about reporting objections at home.
Historical accuracy: the Constitution Franklin urged delegates to sign included compromises that protected slavery (for example, counting three-fifths of enslaved people for representation and allowing the slave trade to continue until 1808). Franklin had enslaved people earlier in his life and later led the Pennsylvania Abolition Society. Name this directly if students ask what “faults” the plan had; the speech itself does not say which parts Franklin disliked. Not every delegate was persuaded: a few who were present refused to sign.
Likely misconceptions: that a concession weakens an argument (here it builds trust); that “abroad” means overseas (here it means in public); that point of view means first person.
Supports: a T-chart “The doubters think / Franklin says”; sentence frame “Franklin admits ___, but he argues ___.” Stretch: find the one rhetorical question and explain its effect on listeners.
Sample analysis: Franklin believes the delegates should sign the Constitution even though it has faults. He begins with a concession: “I confess that there are several parts of this constitution which I do not at present approve.” Then he sets himself apart from the doubters by saying he is “not sure I shall never approve them.” He argues that any meeting brings “their prejudices, their passions, their errors of opinion,” so no group could write a perfect plan. By agreeing that the plan is imperfect but disagreeing about what to do, Franklin makes signing look like the wise and generous choice. Open question: sacrifice suggests a noble gift for others; drop would sound careless and would make him seem to give up easily.
James Madison, The Journal of the Debates in the Convention which Framed the Constitution of the United States, vol. 2, ed. Gaillard Hunt (G. P. Putnam's Sons, 1908), Project Gutenberg eBook #41095 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #41095
About the speech. In the summer of 1787, delegates from the states met in Philadelphia and wrote the Constitution of the United States. On September 17, the last day, the finished plan was read aloud. Benjamin Franklin, who was 81 and the oldest delegate, had written a short speech. James Madison, a delegate from Virginia, kept detailed notes on the meeting. His notes, printed in this 1908 edition, say that Franklin rose “with a speech in his hand” and that another delegate, James Wilson, read it aloud for him.
What to notice. The passage opens with one sentence by Madison, then Franklin’s words. Watch how Franklin admits his own doubts before he argues. Notice whom he means by “others” and “most men.” Find the reason he gives for thinking no meeting could do better, and what he asks for in the last sentence.
Words to know. To confess is to admit. Sentiments are opinions or feelings. Administered means run or managed. Prejudices are opinions formed before knowing the facts. Abroad here means outside the meeting, in public. Infallibility means never being wrong. Unanimity means complete agreement. An instrument here is a formal written document.
Read the passage under “The text” once for meaning and once with a pencil.
Docr Franklin rose with a speech in his hand, which he had reduced to writing for his own conveniency, and which Mr Wilson read in the words following.
Mr President
I confess that there are several parts of this constitution which I do not at present approve, but I am not sure I shall never approve them: For having lived long, I have experienced many instances of being obliged by better information or fuller consideration, to change opinions even on important subjects, which I once thought right, but found to be otherwise. It is therefore that the older I grow, the more apt I am to doubt my own judgment, and to pay more respect to the judgment of others. Most men indeed as well as most sects in Religion think themselves in possession of all truth, and that wherever others differ from them it is so far error. […]
In these sentiments, Sir, I agree to this Constitution with all its faults, if they are such; because I think a general Government necessary for us, and there is no form of Government but what may be a blessing to the people if well administered, […] I doubt too whether any other Convention we can obtain may be able to make a better Constitution. For when you assemble a number of men to have the advantage of their joint wisdom, you inevitably assemble with those men, all their prejudices, their passions, their errors of opinion, their local interests, and their selfish views. From such an assembly can a perfect production be expected? It therefore astonishes me, Sir, to find this system approaching so near to perfection as it does; […] Thus I consent, Sir, to this Constitution because I expect no better, and because I am not sure, that it is not the best. The opinions I have had of its errors, I sacrifice to the public good. I have never whispered a syllable of them abroad. Within these walls they were born, and here they shall die. […]
On the whole, Sir, I cannot help expressing a wish that every member of the Convention who may still have objections to it, would with me, on this occasion doubt a little of his own infallibility, and to make manifest our unanimity, put his name to this instrument.
Source: James Madison, The Journal of the Debates in the Convention which Framed the Constitution of the United States, vol. 2, ed. Gaillard Hunt (G. P. Putnam's Sons, 1908), Project Gutenberg eBook #41095 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)