acknowledge an opposing claim fairly and answer it, after evaluating how well John Ruskin answers the people who disagree with him.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Imagine a council member reads your letter and thinks, “That costs too much.” Write one sentence you could say back that is respectful and gives a reason.
Which answer to an opposing view is most likely to persuade a reader who holds that view?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Why answer the other side? A reader who disagrees with you is already thinking of an objection. When you name it first, fairly, and answer it, you show that you understand the topic and you take away the reader’s best reason to say no. This move is called a counterclaim and rebuttal.
Ruskin’s pattern. Ruskin states the objection in the other side’s words: “But, it is said, there may come a necessity for restoration!” Then he does something clever. He says “Granted,” which means “I agree that can happen,” and then he renames the necessity: “It is a necessity for destruction.” Granting part of a point before answering it is called a concession.
Evaluating his answer. To judge an argument, ask two questions. Is the reasoning sound, meaning does the answer really follow? Is the evidence relevant and sufficient, meaning is it on topic and enough? Ruskin’s point about stone “worn half an inch down” is a reason: if the carving’s finish is gone, a new carving can only guess at it. But calling restoration “a Lie” and comparing a rebuilt building to a model of a corpse are strong words, not proof.
Worked example 1: Kayla evaluates one answer. Kayla writes: “Ruskin argues that copying worn stone is guesswork, because ‘the whole finish of the work was in the half inch that is gone.’ This reasoning is relevant. It would be stronger with a real example of a building that was copied badly.”
Worked example 2: Luis writes a fair counterclaim. Luis first writes, “People who don’t want a marker just don’t care about history.” He notices it insults the reader. He revises: “Some people may argue that the borough has more urgent needs. That is a fair concern. However, a marker is a one-time cost that can be paid by a grant or a fundraiser.”
Connotation matters. Rebuilt and a Lie can describe the same new wall, but a Lie carries a much harsher feeling. In your letter, choose neutral, respectful words for the other side and its ideas.
Trace Ruskin’s argument with a partner. Mark his claim, the objection and his answer.
Write the counterclaim paragraph for your letter.
Write the strongest objection your reader might have to your proposal. State it fairly, in words that person would accept. Then answer it with at least one reason or piece of evidence. Use a frame if it helps: “Some people may argue that ___. That is a fair concern. However, ___.”
Connotation check: list two neutral words you could use for people who disagree with you, and two loaded words you will avoid.
Ruskin’s words are memorable, but his reason about worn stone is what makes a reader think. Strong words are memorable; strong reasons are persuasive.
Exit ticket: one thing Ruskin does that you will copy, and one thing you will not, with a reason.
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading 10, mini lecture 9, guided practice 11, counterclaim paragraph 6, closure 1.
Context: The Seven Lamps of Architecture was first published in London in 1849; the Project Gutenberg file is a Boston edition (Dana Estes & Company). Ruskin’s view is one side of a long debate. Present it fairly: many people then and now believe careful repair and restoration can save a building, and Ruskin himself urges constant care (see 1.20). Students proposing a “preservation step” can use Ruskin either as support (care for what is there) or as a counterclaim to answer. The cut […] removes his sentences about the spirit of the original workmen; the shown passage keeps his reason about worn carving.
Likely misconceptions: that mentioning the other side weakens an argument; that strong words equal strong evidence; that “Granted” means Ruskin gives up his claim (he concedes only that the need can arise).
Supports: give a two-column organizer: “They say” / “Ruskin answers.” Read the long middle sentence aloud and pause at each semicolon. Stretch: rewrite the “a Lie” sentence so it criticizes the practice without accusing anyone of lying.
Answer guide: sample evaluation: “Ruskin’s point about the half inch is sound. If the finish of a carving has worn away, a new copy can only be made ‘conjecturally,’ so it is relevant to whether restoration is truthful. Calling restoration ‘a Lie’ is weak because it is a label, not evidence.” Sample counterclaim: “Some people may argue that a display is unnecessary because the information is online. That is a fair point. However, a display reaches people who would never think to search.”
Project Gutenberg, The Seven Lamps of Architecture by John Ruskin (Boston: Dana Estes & Company), eBook #35898 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
John Ruskin was an English writer who wrote about art and buildings. His book The Seven Lamps of Architecture first appeared in England in 1849; our copy is an American edition printed in Boston. In the chapter called “The Lamp of Memory” he argues about what people should do with very old buildings.
Ruskin’s claim is surprising: he says that restoring an old building, rebuilding its worn parts to look new, actually destroys it. In this passage he gives a reason, then names the objection a reader would raise (“But, it is said…”) and answers it. Some of his answer is reasoning. Some is strong, emotional language. As you read, sort them.
Words to know: restore means repair something so it looks as it once did; conjecturally means by guessing; fidelity means exactness; gleaned means gathered bit by bit; desolated means ruined and empty; Nineveh was an ancient city left in ruins, and Milan is an Italian city where old buildings were rebuilt; ballast means heavy material used to weigh down a ship or fill a road bed.
Do not let us deceive ourselves in this important matter; it is impossible, as impossible as to raise the dead, to restore anything that has ever been great or beautiful in architecture. […] What copying can there be of surfaces that have been worn half an inch down? The whole finish of the work was in the half inch that is gone; if you attempt to restore that finish, you do it conjecturally; if you copy what is left, granting fidelity to be possible (and what care, or watchfulness, or cost can secure it?), how is the new work better than the old?
Do not let us talk then of restoration. The thing is a Lie from beginning to end. You may make a model of a building as you may of a corpse, and your model may have the shell of the old walls within it as your cast might have the skeleton, with what advantage I neither see nor care; but the old building is destroyed, and that more totally and mercilessly than if it had sunk into a heap of dust, or melted into a mass of clay: more has been gleaned out of desolated Nineveh than ever will be out of re-built Milan. But, it is said, there may come a necessity for restoration! Granted. Look the necessity full in the face, and understand it on its own terms. It is a necessity for destruction. Accept it as such, pull the building down, throw its stones into neglected corners, make ballast of them, or mortar, if you will; but do it honestly, and do not set up a Lie in their place. And look that necessity in the face before it comes, and you may prevent it.
Source: Project Gutenberg, The Seven Lamps of Architecture by John Ruskin (Boston: Dana Estes & Company), eBook #35898 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)