organize my claim, reasons and evidence in a logical order and connect them with transitions, using Daniel Webster’s 1825 Bunker Hill address as a model.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Put these sentences in the best order and add one transition word: (a) The record lists three criteria. (b) The council should support a display. (c) This shows the building matters to the nation.
Which order makes the most logical argument?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Organization is a promise kept. A logical argument tells the reader what it is about and then proves it, one step at a time. Webster begins, “The Society whose organ I am was formed for the purpose of rearing some honorable and durable monument,” and every sentence after that explains the purpose.
The body of your letter. Give each reason its own paragraph. Start the paragraph with the reason (a topic sentence), give your evidence, explain it and link it back to your claim. Put your strongest reason first or last, where readers remember it best.
Transitions create cohesion. Cohesion means the parts hold together. Words (first, also, however), phrases (for example, in addition, as a result) and clauses (because the record lists three criteria, …) show how ideas connect: adding, contrasting, showing cause or giving an example. Webster’s indeed and But mark a turn: first he admits a limit, then he answers it.
Worked example 1: Grace traces Webster’s steps. Grace maps the passage: Purpose – a lasting monument to the early friends of independence. Step 1 – why now, here and today: “no time… no place… no day.” Step 2 – a limit: history is already “spread over the earth.” Step 3 – the turn: “But our object is…” Reason – people are moved by “imagination also, and sentiment.”
Worked example 2: Tyrell adds transitions. Tyrell’s draft says: “The station is old. Trains made our town grow. A marker would teach visitors.” He revises: “The station is more than old. Because trains brought workers and goods, our town grew around it. As a result, a marker there would teach visitors how our community began.”
Point of view. Webster speaks for the people building the monument, to a crowd that already honors the battle. Knowing his purpose and audience explains why he admits what a monument cannot do before saying what it can.
Trace the organization of Webster’s passage.
Draft the body of your argument letter.
Draft your two reason paragraphs from your outline. Each needs a topic sentence, evidence with its source and an explanation. Circle every transition.
Evaluate Webster: is his reasoning sound? He admits that history is already known around the world, then says a monument is still worth building. Explain whether his reason convinces you, and quote one phrase.
Webster told his audience the purpose of the monument and then explained it step by step. Your reader deserves the same.
Exit ticket: copy your favorite transition from your draft and label what it shows (add, contrast, cause or example).
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 9, mini lecture 8, guided practice 10, body draft 8, closure 1. Drafting may continue as homework.
Context: Webster gave this address at the laying of the cornerstone on June 17, 1825; the Marquis de Lafayette was present, and the National Park Service page read in 1.27 says Lafayette set the cornerstone. The edition’s note says the monument, a 221-foot granite obelisk, stands on Breed’s Hill rather than Bunker Hill; this connects to 1.27. The passage is two paragraphs from a much longer speech, shown without cuts.
Likely misconceptions: that transitions are decoration (they show logic); that more reasons are always better (two or three well-supported reasons beat five thin ones); that admitting a limit weakens an argument (Webster uses it to set up his main point).
Supports: post a transition bank by purpose. Read the long sentences aloud and chunk them at commas. Provide a paragraph frame: “First/Another reason is that ___. According to ___, ___. This shows that ___.” Stretch: begin one paragraph with a dependent clause that links it to the paragraph before.
Answer guide: warm-up order is b, a, c (option index 2), with a transition such as “This shows that.” Sample evaluation: “His reasoning is sound. He admits a monument cannot tell people anything new, but he says its object is ‘to keep alive similar sentiments,’ and people are moved by ‘imagination also, and sentiment,’ so a thing they can see still matters.”
Project Gutenberg, Daniel Webster for Young Americans, notes by Charles F. Richardson (Little, Brown, 1907), eBook #41300 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
Daniel Webster was a lawyer and member of Congress from Massachusetts, famous as a speaker. On June 17, 1825, fifty years after the Battle of Bunker Hill, a huge crowd gathered in Charlestown, Massachusetts, to lay the cornerstone of the Bunker Hill Monument, and Webster gave the main address. He spoke for the society that was raising the monument. Our copy comes from a 1907 school edition of his speeches.
In this part of the speech Webster explains why the monument is being built. Watch his order. He states the society’s purpose, explains why this time, place and day were chosen, admits what a monument cannot do, and then turns with But to what it can do. Notice the repeated “no time… no place… no day” and “We know… We know…”
Words to know: organ here means spokesperson; rearing means building up; propitious and auspicious both mean favorable, a good sign; prosecuted here means carried on to the end; emblem means symbol; illustrious means famous and admired; entablatures are the flat stone bands along the top of a building; edifice means a large building; sentiment means feeling.
The Society whose organ I am was formed for the purpose of rearing some honorable and durable monument to the memory of the early friends of American Independence. They have thought that for this object no time could be more propitious than the present prosperous and peaceful period, that no place could claim preference over this memorable spot, and that no day could be more auspicious to the undertaking than the anniversary of the battle which was here fought. The foundation of that monument we have now laid. With solemnities suited to the occasion, with prayers to Almighty God for his blessing, and in the midst of this cloud of witnesses, we have begun the work. We trust it will be prosecuted, and that, springing from a broad foundation, rising high in massive solidity and unadorned grandeur, it may remain as long as Heaven permits the works of man to last, a fit emblem, both of the events in memory of which it is raised, and of the gratitude of those who have reared it.
We know, indeed, that the record of illustrious actions is most safely deposited in the universal remembrance of mankind. We know that if we could cause this structure to ascend, not only till it reached the skies, but till it pierced them, its broad surfaces could still contain but part of that which, in an age of knowledge, hath already been spread over the earth, and which history charges itself with making known to all future times. We know that no inscription on entablatures less broad than the earth itself can carry information of the events we commemorate where it has not already gone; and that no structure which shall not outlive the duration of letters and knowledge among men can prolong the memorial. But our object is, by this edifice, to show our own deep sense of the value and importance of the achievements of our ancestors; and, by presenting this work of gratitude to the eye, to keep alive similar sentiments, and to foster a constant regard for the principles of the Revolution. Human beings are composed, not of reason only, but of imagination also, and sentiment; and that is neither wasted nor misapplied which is appropriated to the purpose of giving right direction to sentiments, and opening proper springs of feeling in the heart.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Daniel Webster for Young Americans, notes by Charles F. Richardson (Little, Brown, 1907), eBook #41300 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)