organize my segment so it presents claims and findings in a focused, coherent way, and delineate a speaker’s claims to check that each one is supported.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Your segment has about five minutes. Write the one claim your whole segment makes, in one sentence of 15 words or fewer.
Which sentence is a claim that a segment could support with findings?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Focused and coherent. A focused segment makes one claim. A coherent segment puts its findings in an order listeners can follow, with each part connected to the claim. Jessie’s mother gives the best advice: make it “so interesting and informative that they can’t laugh.”
Claim, findings, so what. Build your segment in three moves. Claim: say it in the first 30 seconds. Findings: two or three facts, each with its source, each with a detail or example that makes it concrete. So what: restate the claim and tell listeners why it matters to them. Salient points, the ones that stand out, go first and last.
Delineate before you present. To delineate an argument is to trace it: list the claim, then each supporting claim and its evidence. Do this for your own segment, and you will spot the claim that has no evidence before your listeners do. In Part 1 you did this for other speakers.
Worked example 1: Gabriela delineates Burd. Burd’s claim: people are “ready and willing to be bunkoed a little” for a good cause. His evidence: none, just a joke. Amy’s counterclaim: Jessie’s lecture is “well worth the price of admission alone.” Her evidence: also none yet; she is loyal to her friend. Gabriela writes: “Both claims are opinions. Jessie’s talk will have to provide the evidence.”
Worked example 2: Liam tightens his segment. Liam’s draft has four findings, but one is about Fessenden’s childhood in Ontario. He checks it against his claim (“A Pittsburgh teacher helped make voice radio possible”) and moves it to the show notes. Now every finding supports the claim, and his part fits in about 75 seconds.
Memorize or read? Miss Seymour suggests Jessie write the talk and learn it by heart. On radio, you may read your script, but rehearse until it sounds like talking, not reading.
Use the bazaar passage, then your own segment.
Revise for focus.
Revise your script so the claim comes in the first 30 seconds and returns at the end. Cut or move any finding that does not support it, and add a detail or example to your weakest finding.
Listen to a teammate read their part. Write their claim and each finding you heard. Then compare your list with their script: did the most salient point come through?
Jessie spent a whole morning making ready. Our practice starts with knowing exactly what we claim.
Exit ticket: write your segment’s claim and the single most salient finding that supports it.
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 7, mini lecture 9, guided practice 12, revision and partner listening 6, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that more findings make a stronger segment; that a claim is any true fact; that Burd and Amy are giving real arguments (both are teasing). Note the setting: the chapter’s bazaar charges admission to the radio tent for a church fund-raiser, and Momsy is Jessie’s name for her mother. The dash “——” shows Jessie breaking off mid-sentence.
Supports: give a three-box organizer (claim, findings, so what) and a delineation chart (claim, supporting claim, evidence, sound or not). Stretch: write one counterclaim a listener might raise and a one-sentence answer with evidence.
Answer guide: sample delineation: Claim – “A teacher from Pittsburgh helped make voice radio possible.” Finding 1 – he taught at the Western University in Pittsburgh, then joined the Weather Bureau in 1900 (NPS). Finding 2 – he sent a voice one mile on Cobb Island (NPS). Finding 3 – at Roanoke Island he found a way to carry voice and music on continuous waves (NPS). So what – the voices on today’s radio and podcasts began with experiments like his. The partner listening task assesses CC.1.5.7.B:1a (delineating a speaker’s claims).
Project Gutenberg, The Radio Girls of Roselawn by Margaret Penrose (Cupples & Leon, 1922), eBook #71771 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
In Chapter XIII of The Radio Girls of Roselawn (1922), the girls’ church holds a bazaar, a fair that raises money, on the Fourth of July at Jessie’s house. One tent will offer radio shows, and many people in town have never heard a radio. Someone must explain radio to each audience before the show begins.
Jessie is nervous. Her teacher, Miss Seymour, and her mother give her advice. Then Jessie plans a schedule of programs and practices her talk. Notice the advice each adult gives and what Jessie does to prepare.
Words to know: prose essay means a short piece of ordinary writing; off-hand means without preparing; informative means full of useful facts; wave lengths are the settings that tune in different stations; bunkoed is old slang for tricked; timid means shy or easily frightened.
When she had talked it over with Momsy and Miss Seymour, however, Jessie Norwood took up the thought of the radio lecture quite seriously. Somebody must explain and manage the entertainment in the radio tent, and who better than Jessie?
“It is quite wonderful how much you young people have learned about radio—so much more than I had any idea,” said the school teacher. “Of course you can write a little prose essay, Jessie, get it by heart, and repeat it at each session in the tent, if you feel timid about giving an off-hand talk on the subject.”
“You can do it if you only think you can, Jessie,” said her mother, smiling. “I am sure I have a very smart daughter.”
“Oh, now, Momsy! If they should laugh at me——”
“Don’t give them a chance to laugh, dear. Make your talk so interesting and informative that they can’t laugh.”
Thus encouraged, Jessie spent all the forenoon of the Fourth shut up in her own room making ready for the afternoon and evening. She had already made a careful schedule of the broadcasting done by all the stations within reach of her fine radio set, and found that it was possible, by tuning her instrument to the wave lengths of different stations, to get something interesting into every hour from two o’clock on until eleven.
Naturally, some of the entertainments would be more interesting or amusing than others; but as New Melford people for the most part were as yet unfamiliar with radio, almost anything out of the air would seem curious and entertaining.
“Besides,” Burd Alling said in comment on this, “for a good cause we are all ready and willing to be bunkoed a little.”
“Let me tell you, Mr. Smarty,” said Amy, “that Jessie’s lecture is well worth the price of admission alone. Never mind the radio entertainment.”
Source: Project Gutenberg, The Radio Girls of Roselawn by Margaret Penrose (Cupples & Leon, 1922), eBook #71771 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)