write a claim-evidence-reasoning response explaining how and why Longfellow altered the history of Revere’s ride, using the poem, Revere’s letter and a National Park Service account.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Review your Fact or Fiction log. Star the change you think matters most. Why does it matter?
The poem was published in December 1860, just as Southern states were beginning to leave the Union. What purpose might a poem about 1775 serve then?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
From what to why. We have listed what Longfellow used, changed and left out. CC.1.3.7.H also asks us to understand how authors of fiction use or alter history, which means asking why. The NPS article gives one strong answer: purpose.
Purpose and audience. In December 1860 the nation was splitting apart. A poem about Americans rising together in 1775 spoke to readers who feared a civil war. One lone rider who wakes “every Middlesex village and farm” is a clear symbol of a call to action.
Worked example 1: a CER paragraph. Here is a model I wrote. Claim: Longfellow altered the history of the ride to create a single hero who could inspire unity. Evidence: In the poem Revere reaches “the bridge in Concord town,” but in his letter only “the Doctor … got to Concord.” The Park Service says the poem “was a call for unity on the eve of the American Civil War.” Reasoning: By cutting Dawes and Prescott and finishing the ride himself, Revere becomes a simple symbol readers in 1860 could rally around.
Worked example 2: the cost. Zoe notices the article’s phrase “arguably at the expense of other, equally significant figures.” She adds: The change had a cost: Dawes’s great-grandson complained, and Longfellow joked that Holland “convicts me of high historic crimes and misdemeanors.” Real people were left out of the story Americans remember.
Problem and power together. The same change can be both. The poem made Revere “an indelible American symbol” and even led to efforts to preserve his house, which opened as a museum in 1908. But it pushed others out of memory. A strong argument admits both sides, then weighs them.
Connecting to our letter. A historical marker faces the same choice: which names go on it? Your letter will need to be accurate and fair to the people involved.
Have the poem, the letter and today’s article side by side.
Write a full CER response, a step toward the argument letter.
CER: How and why did Longfellow alter the history of Paul Revere's ride? Write 8-10 sentences. Checklist: (1) a claim that names a change and a reason, (2) evidence from the poem, (3) evidence from Revere's letter, (4) evidence from the NPS article, (5) reasoning that connects the evidence, (6) one sentence on the cost of the change.
Peer check: trade with a partner. Mark their claim C, each quotation E and their explanation R. Write one question that would make their reasoning stronger.
We know what changed, and why. Next we compare two very different ways of remembering Lincoln.
Exit ticket: if you could add one sentence to a marker about Revere's ride, what would it say?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 3, reading 7, mini lesson 9, guided practice 9, CER and peer check 12.
Assessment: the CER is a formative check on CC.1.3.7.H (both targets). Collect it to plan Part 2 argument writing.
Context: the article’s cut parts quote the poem’s opening and the Somerset stanza (students know them from 1.01) and describe an HMS Somerset fragment sent to Longfellow. Holland’s lecture was in 1876; his book appeared in 1878.
Likely misconceptions: that Longfellow lied out of ignorance (the article frames the choices as purposeful); that a change must be either good or bad, not both.
Supports: CER organizer with three evidence boxes, one per source. Stretch: was the Somerset really there? The article says Revere “was rowed past HMS Somerset,” matching both poem and letter. Why do accurate details make the invented ones more believable?
Sample CER: see the model in the mini lesson; strong responses add the omission of Dawes (“a Mr. William Dawes” in the letter) and the cost (“at the expense of other, equally significant figures”).
National Park Service, Longfellow House-Washington's Headquarters National Historic Site, “Washington's Cambridge Headquarters and the Memory of the American Revolution” · U.S. government work, public domain
About the article. The National Park Service runs the house in Cambridge, Massachusetts, where George Washington had his headquarters in 1775-1776 and where Henry Wadsworth Longfellow later lived and wrote. This article explains how poets, historians and preservationists kept the memory of the Revolution alive, “with varying degrees of accuracy.” Our passage comes from the section on “Paul Revere’s Ride,” which the park staff illustrate with objects from the house’s museum collection.
What to notice. Find the purpose the article gives for the poem and the cost it names. Then read about William Dawes’s great-grandson and Longfellow’s reply. Last, notice what the poem led people to do with Revere’s house.
Words to know. To elevate is to raise up; elevated is its past form. Near-mythic means almost like a hero from a myth. Indelible means impossible to erase. Entanglement means a twisted mix. Backlash is a strong negative reaction. Misdemeanors are minor crimes; Longfellow is joking.
Read the passage under “The text” once for meaning and once with a pencil.
Henry Longfellow’s poem “Paul Revere’s Ride” was a call for unity on the eve of the American Civil War. Longfellow drew upon the American Revolution for its setting and elevated Revere’s status to that of a near-mythic American hero, arguably at the expense of other, equally significant figures. A sensation from its publication in December 1860, the poem made Paul Revere and his ride an indelible American symbol:
[…]
This fragment of wood illustrates the complicated entanglement of fact and myth around Paul Revere’s historic ride and the poem. Paul Revere was rowed past HMS Somerset in Boston Harbor on the night of April 18, 1775.
[…]
Longfellow’s promotion of Revere received backlash from Henry W. Holland, great-grandson of Revere’s fellow rider William Dawes. In 1876 Holland delivered a lecture to the New England Historical Genealogical Society highlighting Dawes’s role. After its publication Longfellow remarked of Holland, “he convicts me of high historic crimes and misdemeanors.”
[…]
Longfellow’s poem created enduring interest in Paul Revere. Efforts to preserve Revere’s Boston home began in 1902, and it opened as a museum in 1908.
Source: National Park Service, Longfellow House-Washington's Headquarters National Historic Site, “Washington's Cambridge Headquarters and the Memory of the American Revolution” (nps.gov)