delineate the argument in part of Roosevelt’s fireside chat by separating his main claim, his specific claims and the facts he reports.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now: listen for because. Your teacher will play part of the March 12, 1933 broadcast again. Each time you hear a reason (a “because” or “in order to” idea), make a tally mark and jot two words to remember it.
Roosevelt has to tell people that some banks will open days after others. What will listeners most need to hear?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Delineate means outline. To delineate an argument is to trace its shape: the main claim, the specific claims that support it, and the reasons and evidence behind each one. You must do this before you can judge it.
Claim or fact? A fact reports something that can be checked (“By the afternoon of March 3 scarcely a bank in the country was open”). A claim is a point the speaker wants you to accept, which could be argued (“A bank that opens on one of the subsequent days is in exactly the same status as the bank that opens tomorrow”).
Worked example 1: mapping one claim. Nia wrote the claim at the top of a box: If your bank opens later, it is not in trouble. Under it she listed his reason: reopening is “extended over a period” so banks can get loans and currency and the government can “make common sense checkups.”
Worked example 2: a fact is not the claim. Ethan first wrote that the main claim was “scarcely a bank in the country was open.” His partner asked: is he trying to convince us of that, or reporting it? Ethan moved it to the evidence row. The main claim is what all the facts are building toward.
Listening versus reading. A listener in 1933 heard this once, with no rewind. Roosevelt helps them with signposts: “A question you will ask is this,” “The answer is simple,” “Let me make it clear to you.” Signposts tell an ear where the argument is going.
A model argument map of my own. Main claim: the step-by-step reopening will keep banks safe. Specific claim 1: banks are not all reopening at once to prevent “another epidemic of bank failures.” Specific claim 2: a later opening is not a bad sign. Evidence: the rush on banks; the closings by March 3; the Treasury’s first examination.
Use the passage. Keep your F and C marks in front of you.
Build an argument map.
Make an argument map for this passage. Checklist: (1) the main claim in your own words, (2) two specific claims, each with an exact quotation, (3) at least two facts he uses as evidence, (4) one signpost phrase and how it helps a listener.
Now we know the shape of the argument. Next we judge it: is the reasoning sound and the evidence enough?
Exit ticket: which specific claim do you think a 1933 listener most needed to hear, and why?
Pacing (40 min): listening Do Now 6, reading 8, mini lesson 8, guided practice 9, argument map 9.
Text notes: the transcript prints “WE” in capitals and uses dashes and hyphens as printed. The cut skips the second and third steps (Congress’s law and the Treasury rules).
Nonpartisan framing: we outline and evaluate the argument’s structure. Students are not asked whether Roosevelt or the New Deal was right.
Likely misconceptions: that every sentence in a speech is a claim; that a fact cannot be used as evidence; that the main claim must be stated in one sentence.
Supports: an argument-map graphic (claim box, two branches, evidence rows). Stretch: why does he predict the listener’s question (“A question you will ask”) before answering it?
Sample map: Main claim: reopening banks in stages will restore a safe system. Claim 1: they open in stages so there is no “epidemic of bank failures.” Claim 2: a later opening is not a bad sign (“exactly the same status”). Evidence: the rush to withdraw; closings by March 3; banks “found to be all right” by the Treasury. Signpost: “The answer is simple,” which tells listeners an answer is coming.
FDIC (Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation), Transcript of Speech by President Franklin D. Roosevelt Regarding the Banking Crisis, March 12, 1933 · U.S. government work, public domain (a president's official address, transcript published by the FDIC)
Where we are. After explaining how banks use deposits, Roosevelt tells what happened in late February and early March 1933. Many people lost confidence and rushed to turn their deposits into currency or gold. Even strong banks could not pay everyone at once. By March 3, almost every bank was closed, and he declared a nationwide “bank holiday.”
The plan. Banks would reopen in stages: on Monday in the twelve Federal Reserve Bank cities, on Tuesday in about 250 more cities, and from Wednesday on in smaller places, after government checks.
What to notice. Some sentences report what happened. Others are claims he wants you to accept. Mark facts with F and claims with C.
Words to know. Assets are things of value a bank owns, such as loans. Panic prices are very low prices from rushed selling. A proclamation is an official order. Clearinghouses are offices where banks settle checks with each other. Subsequent means later. An epidemic is a fast-spreading outbreak.
Read the passage under “The text” once for meaning and once with a pencil.
What, then, happened during the last few days of February and the first few days of March? Because of undermined confidence on the part of the public, there was a general rush by a large portion of our population to turn bank deposits into currency or gold. — A rush so great that the soundest banks could not get enough currency to meet the demand. The reason for this was that on the spur of the moment it was, of course, impossible to sell perfectly sound assets of a bank and convert them into cash except at panic prices far below their real value.
By the afternoon of March 3 scarcely a bank in the country was open to do business. Proclamations temporarily closing them in whole or in part had been issued by the Governors in almost all the states.
It was then that I issued the proclamation providing for the nation-wide bank holiday, and this was the first step in the Government’s reconstruction of our financial and economic fabric.
[…]
A question you will ask is this – why are all the banks not to be reopened at the same time? The answer is simple. Your Government does not intend that the history of the past few years shall be repeated. WE do not want and will not have another epidemic of bank failures.
As a result we start tomorrow, Monday, with the opening of banks in the twelve Federal Reserve Bank cities — those banks which on first examination by the Treasury have already been found to be all right. This will be followed on Tuesday by the resumption of all their functions by banks already found to be sound in cities where there are recognized clearinghouses. That means about 250 cities of the United States.
On Wednesday and succeeding days banks in smaller places all through the country will resume business, subject, of course, to the Government’s physical ability to complete its survey. It is necessary that the reopening of banks be extended over a period in order to permit the banks to make applications for necessary loans, to obtain currency needed to meet their requirements and to enable the Government to make common sense checkups.
Let me make it clear to you that if your bank does not open the first day you are by no means justified in believing that it will not open. A bank that opens on one of the subsequent days is in exactly the same status as the bank that opens tomorrow.
Source: FDIC (Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation), Transcript of Speech by President Franklin D. Roosevelt Regarding the Banking Crisis, March 12, 1933 (fdic.gov)