write a clear claim for my letter by studying how Lincoln states his position and sets it apart from the positions of others.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Which of these is a claim a reader can see clearly? (A) “There are a lot of things to think about with old buildings.” (B) “The historical society should place a marker at the old train station.” Write one sentence explaining your choice.
Why is sentence B the stronger claim?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A claim is a stand. The introduction of an argument does two jobs: it tells the reader what the topic is, and it states the writer’s claim so clearly that nobody is left in doubt. Lincoln even says so: “I have not meant to leave any one in doubt.”
How Lincoln sets his position apart. He describes two groups: those who would not save the Union unless they could save slavery, and those who would not save it unless they could destroy slavery. He disagrees with both. Then he states his own position in one sentence. Naming other positions makes his own position sharper.
Reading it as history. This letter is not the whole story. One month earlier, in July 1862, Lincoln had already shown his Cabinet a draft of the Emancipation Proclamation, and he issued the preliminary proclamation that September. A public letter shows the position a writer chooses to present, so historians read it beside other evidence. Enslaved people were also pressing the question themselves by escaping to Union lines.
Worked example 1: Destiny sharpens her claim. Destiny writes, “I think maybe the old school should have something.” She uses Lincoln’s test: would anyone be left in doubt? She revises: “The historical society should place a marker at the site of our community’s first school.”
Worked example 2: Omar sets his claim apart. Omar knows some neighbors want the old firehouse torn down and others want it fully restored. He writes: “Some neighbors want the firehouse removed, and others want it restored at great cost. I believe there is a better first step: a marker that tells its history.” Like Lincoln, he names other views to make his own clear.
Your introduction. Open with the place and why it caught your attention, introduce yourself to the reader and state your claim in one clear sentence near the end of the first paragraph.
Read the letter twice: once for its message and once for its structure.
Write the introduction of your argument letter.
Draft your introduction (4-6 sentences): greet your reader, introduce yourself, name the site and why it matters to you, and state your claim in one clear sentence. Underline the claim.
Point-of-view check: name one position that differs from yours (for example, doing nothing, or a much bigger project). Write one sentence that sets your position apart from it, the way Lincoln does.
Lincoln did not want to leave anyone in doubt. Neither should you.
Exit ticket: read your claim to a partner. Could they repeat it back exactly? Write what they said.
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 9, mini lecture 9, guided practice 10, introduction draft 6, closure 2.
Teaching slavery accurately: keep the history direct. Slavery was the central cause of the war. Lincoln’s letter describes his public position as president; he had already drafted the Emancipation Proclamation, issued the preliminary proclamation on September 22, 1862, and the final proclamation on January 1, 1863. Black Americans, enslaved and free, pushed the question forward by escaping, by petitioning and, from 1863, by serving in large numbers in the Union army. Discuss the word coloured as a historical term printed in this British edition, and use “Black Americans” or “enslaved people” in class discussion.
Likely misconceptions: that Lincoln did not care about slavery (he separates official duty from personal wish); that a claim must be first sentence (it can come after a short opening); that naming other views weakens an argument (it sharpens it).
Supports: read the letter aloud first. Give a claim frame: “The ___ should ___ at/about ___ because ___.” English learners may highlight the repeated sentence openings in one color. Stretch: write a second version of the claim with parallel structure.
Answer guide: sample introduction: “Dear Members of the Historical Society: My name is Ana, and I am a seventh grader at East Allegheny. Every Saturday I walk past the old railroad station on my way to the library, and I always wonder about its story. I am writing to ask the society to create a display about the station at the public library.” Sample open answer: a writer may hold back a plan that is not ready or that could cause opposition, so one document may not show the whole truth; historians compare it with other records, such as the draft proclamation.
Project Gutenberg, Speeches and Letters of Abraham Lincoln, 1832-1865, edited by Merwin Roe (1907), eBook #14721 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
In August 1862 the Civil War had been going on for more than a year. Horace Greeley, editor of the New York Tribune, published a letter to President Lincoln in his newspaper, pressing him to act against slavery. Lincoln answered in a public letter of his own, which newspapers printed.
Lincoln’s answer is famous for its clear structure. He sets aside Greeley’s tone, states his “paramount object,” then names two groups he disagrees with. Notice how he repeats sentence patterns so the reader can follow every step. Notice also the last sentence, where he separates his “official duty” from his “personal wish.”
Words to know: instant here means of this month; erroneous means wrong; controvert means argue against; waive means set aside; deference means respect; paramount means most important; forbear means hold back from doing; coloured is this British edition’s spelling of colored, a term used in the 1800s for Black Americans.
I have just read yours of the 19th instant, addressed to myself through the “New York Tribune.”
If there be in it any statements or assumptions of fact which I may know to be erroneous, I do not now and here controvert them.
If there be in it any inferences which I may believe to be falsely drawn, I do not now and here argue against them.
If there be perceptible in it an impatient and dictatorial tone, I waive it, in deference to an old friend whose heart I have always supposed to be right.
As to the policy I “seem to be pursuing,” as you say, I have not meant to leave any one in doubt. I would save the Union. I would save it in the shortest way under the Constitution.
The sooner the national authority can be restored, the nearer the Union will be,–the Union as it was.
If there be those who would not save the Union unless they could at the same time save slavery, I do not agree with them.
If there be those who would not save the Union unless they could at the same time destroy slavery, I do not agree with them.
My paramount object in this struggle is to save the Union, and not either to save or to destroy slavery.
If I could save the Union without freeing any slave, I would do it; if I could save it by freeing all the slaves, I would do it; and if I could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone, I would also do that.
What I do about slavery and the coloured race, I do because I believe it helps to save the Union; and what I forbear, I forbear because I do not believe it would help to save the Union.
I shall do less whenever I shall believe that what I am doing hurts the cause; and I shall do more whenever I shall believe doing more will help the cause.
I shall try to correct errors where shown to be errors, and I shall adopt new views as fast as they shall appear to be true views.
I have here stated my purpose according to my views of official duty, and I intend no modification of my oft-expressed personal wish that all men everywhere could be free.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Speeches and Letters of Abraham Lincoln, 1832-1865, edited by Merwin Roe (1907), eBook #14721 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)