Argument letter
When writers change history, is that a problem or a power?
The mystery: Students compare two versions of Paul Revere’s ride: a poem stanza and his own letter.
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
read Paul Revere’s own account of the night, compare it with the poem’s opening and identify at least two ways Longfellow used or changed history.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Reread stanza 2 of the poem. Who is the signal for? Write your answer with a quotation.
Revere wrote his own account in a letter about 23 years after the ride. What do you predict he says about the lanterns?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Meet the primary source. Revere wrote this letter because Jeremy Belknap was collecting history. Revere says he wanted to share facts he had not seen in any history of the Revolution. That is his purpose. Remember that he wrote more than twenty years later, from memory, so we read him carefully too.
Same night, two versions. The poem and the letter agree on a lot: April 18, the North Church, two lanterns for the water route, a row across the Charles River past the Somerset, a horse in Charlestown. They disagree on other details, and those differences are where we learn how the poet worked.
Worked example 1: a change. Owen compares stanza 2 with the letter. In the poem Revere says, “I on the opposite shore will be.” In the letter, Revere agreed with “a Colonel Conant and some other gentlemen” in Charlestown, and later “they said they had seen our signals.” Owen writes: Longfellow changed who the signal was for. In history it told the patriots in Charlestown; in the poem it tells Revere when to ride.
Worked example 2: a leaving-out. Ana notices a name: Dr. Warren “had sent an express by land to Lexington, — a Mr. William Dawes.” The poem never mentions Dawes. Ana writes: The poem leaves out a second rider, which makes Revere look like the only hero.
Use, change or leave out. Every time you compare fiction with history, sort each detail: did the author use it, change it or leave it out? Then ask why.
Vocabulary strategy: context clues. “An express by land” might confuse you, because today express often means fast delivery. The next words, “a Mr. William Dawes,” show that an express here is a person, a messenger. Words can have more than one meaning; context decides.
Annotate the letter: S for same as the poem, C for changed, N for not in the poem.
Return to your Fact or Fiction log.
Fill the right column of your log for the three poem claims from 1.01. For each, quote the letter and label it used, changed or left out.
Audience check: our argument letter goes to real readers who care about local history. Name one local place you might propose for a marker or display, and one question you would need to research to describe it accurately.
We have two versions of one night. Next we look closely at how the poem is built to make its version unforgettable.
Exit ticket: does knowing about Dawes change how you feel about the poem? Explain in two sentences.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, read the letter aloud 10, mini lesson 8, guided practice 10, log and audience check 8.
Text note: the letter is printed in Goss (1891) from the Massachusetts Historical Society manuscript (Goss notes it was first printed in 1798 with changes). Spelling such as “lanthorns” is Revere’s. The dash after “Lexington,” is Goss’s. Goss notes the original letter has no date; the printed version is dated 1798, so Revere wrote it about 23 years after the ride, possibly earlier.
Likely misconceptions: that a primary source must be perfectly accurate (memory fades; Revere wrote decades later); that the lanterns were for Revere (the letter says they were for the Charlestown patriots).
Supports: give a simple map (Boston, Charles River, Charlestown, Lexington, Concord); pre-teach the words in the box. Stretch: Revere wrote about 23 years later; which details would be easiest to misremember?
Answer guide: changes: signal for Revere (poem) vs. for Conant and others (letter); omission of Dawes; Revere waiting on the shore vs. arranging the signal two days earlier, “The Sunday before.” Why: one hero and one moment of suspense make a clearer, more exciting poem.
Paul Revere, letter to Jeremy Belknap (about 1798), printed in Elbridge H. Goss, The Life of Colonel Paul Revere, vol. 1 (1891), Internet Archive · Public domain in the U.S. (letter written about 1798; book published 1891); Internet Archive scan
About the letter. Around 1798, Paul Revere, a Boston silversmith, wrote a long letter to the Reverend Jeremy Belknap of the Massachusetts Historical Society, telling what he remembered about the start of the Revolution. In 1891 Elbridge Goss printed it in a biography of Revere, using the society’s copy of the original handwritten letter. A letter like this is a primary source: it was written by someone who took part in the events.
What to notice. Track who gives orders, who else is sent to Lexington, who makes the signals and who sees them. Compare each detail with stanzas 2 and 3 of the poem.
Words to know. An express is a fast messenger. To acquaint someone is to inform them. Lanthorns is an old spelling of lanterns. Apprehensive means worried that something bad may happen. A surtout is a long overcoat. Young flood means the tide had just begun to rise.
Read the passage under “The text” once for meaning and once with a pencil.
On Tuesday evening, the 18th, it was observed that a number of soldiers were marching towards the bottom of the Common. About ten o’clock, Dr. Warren sent in great haste for me, and begged that I would immediately set off for Lexington, where Messrs. Hancock and Adams were, and acquaint them of the movement, and that it was thought they were the objects. When I got to Dr. Warren’s house, I found he had sent an express by land to Lexington, — a Mr. William Dawes. The Sunday before, by desire of Dr. Warren, I had been to Lexington, to Messrs. Hancock and Adams, who were at the Rev. Mr. Clark’s. I returned at night through Charlestown; there I agreed with a Colonel Conant and some other gentlemen, that if the British went out by water, we would show two lanthorns in the North Church steeple; and if by land, one as a signal; for we were apprehensive it would be difficult to cross the Charles River, or get over Boston Neck. I left Dr. Warren, called upon a friend, and desired him to make the signals. I then went home, took my boots and surtout, went to the north part of the town, where I kept a boat; two friends rowed me across Charles River a little to the eastward where the Somerset man-of-war lay. It was then young flood, the ship was winding, and the moon was rising.
They landed me on the Charlestown side. When I got into town, I met Colonel Conant and several others; they said they had seen our signals. I told them what was acting, and went to get me a horse; I got a horse of Deacon Larkin.
Source: Paul Revere, letter to Jeremy Belknap (about 1798), printed in Elbridge H. Goss, The Life of Colonel Paul Revere, vol. 1 (1891), Internet Archive (archive.org)