compare how Whitman’s short Lincoln poems and Dr. Leale’s account portray Lincoln, and explain how poetic form lets an author use history to express a judgment.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Write a four-line poem or a four-sentence report about someone you admire. Which form lets you say more about how you feel?
Whitman wrote a short poem for the day Lincoln was buried, as if spoken by soldiers. What do you predict the soldiers do with their weapons?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Same man, different tools. Leale’s account gave us times, places and actions. Whitman’s poems give us judgments and feelings. Both use history; they use it for different purposes.
Form in “Hush’d Be the Camps.” The poem speaks as soldiers, using “us” and “our.” It is a kind of command: “Hush’d be the camps.” The long, unrhymed lines feel like a quiet gathering, not a march. The form makes readers part of the mourning army.
Worked example 1: the epitaph. Darius studies “This Dust Was Once the Man.” It is one sentence, like words carved on a gravestone (an epitaph). Four adjectives describe Lincoln: “Gentle, plain, just and resolute.” Darius writes: The short form forces Whitman to choose only what matters most, so every word is a judgment.
Worked example 2: comparing with history. Elena compares Whitman’s “No more for him life’s stormy conflicts” with Leale’s “The dawn of peace was again clouded.” She writes: Both use weather imagery, but Whitman says the storms are over for Lincoln, while Leale says the nation’s storm has returned. The poet gives Lincoln peace; the witness shows the country’s fear.
History in a judgment. “Against the foulest crime in history known in any land or age” is Whitman’s judgment, not a neutral fact. A historian would explain events; a poet can declare what they mean. Whitman uses history (the saved Union) to argue for Lincoln’s greatness.
Writing a comparison. Use a clear structure: claim, a point of similarity with evidence from both texts, a point of difference with evidence from both, and a sentence about why the authors differ.
Reopen Leale’s account from 1.06 beside today’s poems.
Write a comparison.
Compare how Whitman (in one of today's poems or “O Captain! My Captain!”) and Leale portray Lincoln's death. Write 8 sentences: claim, one similarity (evidence from both), one difference (evidence from both), and an explanation of how the poem's form lets Whitman use history to make a judgment.
Driving question check: after Revere, Lincoln, Franklin and Brutus, has your answer changed? Write your current position in one sentence and your best piece of evidence.
We compared a poet’s Lincoln with a witness’s Lincoln. Next we pull the unit together and plan our argument letters.
Exit ticket: which of Whitman's four adjectives would you put on a marker about Lincoln, and why?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 5, mini lesson 9, guided practice 10, comparison 12.
Context: the date note “[May 4, 1865” appears in the Gutenberg file’s poem heading; Lincoln was buried in Springfield, Illinois, that day. “This Dust Was Once the Man” first appeared in the 1871 edition of Leaves of Grass. The cut lines in “Hush’d” describe the coffin being placed in the tomb.
Likely misconceptions: that a poem’s judgment is a fact; that “celebrate” in line 3 means party (here it means honor with ceremony; discuss this multiple meaning).
Supports: a comparison frame “Both ___. However, ___.” Stretch: “the foulest crime in history” may refer to slavery and the war or to the assassination; argue for one reading with evidence.
Sample comparison: Whitman and Leale both show Lincoln’s death as a loss at the end of a long struggle. Leale reports that the President was dead “at twenty minutes past seven,” while Whitman’s soldiers say “No more for him life’s stormy conflicts.” Leale’s facts show a real morning; Whitman’s poem shows what the loss meant. In “This Dust Was Once the Man,” the short epitaph form lets Whitman judge Lincoln as “Gentle, plain, just and resolute,” the man under whose hand “Was saved the Union.”
Walt Whitman, Leaves of Grass, Project Gutenberg eBook #1322 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #1322
About the poems. Both poems are in the “Memories of President Lincoln” section of Walt Whitman’s Leaves of Grass. The first carries the date May 4, 1865, the day of Lincoln’s funeral and burial. It is spoken by soldiers to their “dear commander.” The second is only four lines long and sums up Lincoln’s life. Neither poem names Lincoln, but readers then and now know who the “commander” is.
What to notice. In the first poem, who speaks and what do they ask for? What has ended for their commander? In the second, list the four words Whitman uses to describe the man, and find what Whitman says was saved.
Words to know. To drape is to cover loosely with cloth, as for mourning. War-worn means worn out by war. Musing means thinking quietly and deeply. Ceaseless means never stopping. Resolute means firm and determined. The word Union means the United States as one nation.
Read the passage under “The text” once for meaning and once with a pencil.
Hush’d Be the Camps To-Day
Hush’d be the camps to-day,
And soldiers let us drape our war-worn weapons,
And each with musing soul retire to celebrate,
Our dear commander’s death.No more for him life’s stormy conflicts,
Nor victory, nor defeat–no more time’s dark events,
Charging like ceaseless clouds across the sky.[…]
This Dust Was Once the Man
This dust was once the man,
Gentle, plain, just and resolute, under whose cautious hand,
Against the foulest crime in history known in any land or age,
Was saved the Union of these States.
Source: Walt Whitman, Leaves of Grass, Project Gutenberg eBook #1322 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)