give and use specific feedback in a table read, evaluating whether each segment’s reasoning is sound and its evidence relevant and sufficient.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think of the most helpful comment anyone ever gave you about something you made. What made it helpful? Write one sentence.
Which comment is most helpful in a table read?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A table read. Before a show records, the cast sits around a table and reads the whole script aloud. Listeners take notes, and writers learn what works by ear. Today each team reads its segment aloud for another team.
Listen like an evaluator. In Part 1 you judged speakers’ arguments. Now use the same questions on your classmates’ segments. Is the reasoning sound? Does each finding really lead to the claim, or is there a jump? Is the evidence relevant? Does it connect to this claim? Is it sufficient? Is there enough of it, from credible sources?
Feedback protocol. (1) Retell: the listening team states the segment’s claim in one sentence. (2) Glow: one specific strength. (3) Evidence check: one place where reasoning or evidence needs work. (4) Sound check: one moment that was hard to hear or follow. The writers listen, say “thank you,” and decide what to change.
Worked example 1: Noor evaluates a claim. A segment claims, “Fessenden invented radio.” Its only evidence is that he sent a voice one mile. Noor comments: “Your evidence is relevant, but it is not sufficient for ‘invented radio.’ The Park Service says he improved on the Marconi system. Could your claim say he helped make voice radio possible?” The team narrows the claim to fit the evidence.
Worked example 2: Kofi uses the shared document. Kofi types his notes as comments right on the team’s script, each linked to the exact line: “Line 12: say the source before the number.” The writer replies, makes the change, and marks the comment resolved. The comment history becomes part of the team’s revision log.
Use the BLS page, then run the table read.
Use your feedback.
Revision log: list each comment your team received, what you changed (or why you did not), and the line number. Resolve each comment in the shared document.
Which BLS quality (research, writing, speaking or persistence) does your segment need most right now? Write one step you will take before recording.
Professionals audition many times. Every table read makes our segments stronger.
Exit ticket: what was the most useful comment your team received today, and what will you change because of it?
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading and career 6, mini lecture 7, table reads (two rounds, 8 minutes each) 16, revision log 6, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that feedback means criticism; that relevant evidence is automatically enough; that a writer must accept every comment. Remind students that the BLS describes the job, not the only path into it, and that pay and job numbers on the page change each year.
Supports: provide feedback stems (“Your claim seems to be…”, “This evidence connects because…”, “I needed more proof when…”) and a printed protocol card. Seat teams so readers face listeners. Stretch: the listening team proposes one sentence that narrows an overreaching claim.
Answer guide: sample evidence check: “Your claim is that early radio surprised people. Your Parkville quote is relevant, but it is from a novel, so add a historical source too.” The table-read comments assess CC.1.5.7.B:2a (evaluating soundness, relevance and sufficiency); the comments and resolved revisions in the shared document assess CC.1.4.7.U:2a (using digital tools to collaborate).
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook: Announcers and DJs · U.S. government work, public domain
The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes the Occupational Outlook Handbook, a guide to hundreds of jobs. This page describes announcers and DJs, the people who present music, news and information on radio and TV or at live events.
According to the page, announcers interview guests, research topics, choose what goes on a show, read scripts and comment during events. Radio announcers usually work in soundproof studios. The page lists the qualities they need. Research skills: they must research important topics. Writing skills: they normally write their own material. Speaking skills: a pleasant, well-controlled voice, good timing and excellent pronunciation. Persistence: getting hired is very competitive, and people may audition many times. They also need computer skills for editing software.
Many jobs ask for a bachelor’s degree in communications, broadcasting or journalism. The page says school radio stations, internships, speech classes and making school announcements all help.
Words to know: persistence means continuing to try after setbacks; to audition is to try out for a role.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook: Announcers and DJs (bls.gov)