support each reason in my letter with relevant evidence from accurate, credible sources, and explain how it supports my claim.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. You read three statements about a building: (1) a National Park Service record, (2) an anonymous comment on a social-media post, (3) your cousin, who thinks he heard it somewhere. Rank them from most to least credible and give one reason.
What makes the National Park Service record the most credible?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Evidence is what makes a reader believe you. In an argument letter, each reason needs evidence: facts, numbers or quotations from sources the reader can trust. Then you explain how that evidence supports your reason. Writers call this pattern reason, evidence, explanation.
Is the source credible? Ask four questions. Who wrote it, and are they an expert or an official agency? Why was it written? When was it written or updated? Can I check it in another source? A National Park Service page passes these tests better than an anonymous post.
Accurate means exact. Quote or paraphrase only what the source says, and name it in your sentence: “According to the National Park Service…” If a detail is not in your sources, leave it out or keep researching.
Worked example 1: Jordan uses the criteria as a reason. In the mentor letter, Jordan’s first reason is that the building is officially recognized. Today’s page explains why that matters: places are judged on events, people and architecture. Jordan could add, “The National Park Service says a place must be associated with important events, people or architecture to be eligible, and this building’s record lists all three.” That is evidence plus explanation.
Worked example 2: Priya catches a weak source. Priya finds a post saying her site is “the oldest building in the county.” No author or source is named. She searches the National Register database and a historical society page and cannot confirm it, so she leaves the claim out. Being accurate made her letter more trustworthy.
Use word clues. When a source uses a technical word, use context and word parts. Archeological contains archaeo-, a Greek root meaning “ancient,” and -logy, meaning “study of.” A dictionary confirms it.
Use the page and the mentor letter.
Gather and test evidence for your own letter.
Make an evidence chart with two rows, one per reason: Reason | Evidence (quoted or paraphrased) | Source | Why it is credible | How it supports the reason. Use at least two different credible sources.
Your reader may not know the words criteria or significance. Write one sentence for your letter that uses one of them and makes its meaning clear from context.
A council member may check your facts. Make sure every one of them checks out.
Exit ticket: which piece of your evidence is strongest, and what makes its source credible?
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 8, mini lecture 9, guided practice 10, evidence chart 7, closure 2. Students may need device time for research; the chart can be finished in the next lesson.
Likely misconceptions: that a website ending in .com is never credible or that .gov is always perfect (judge by who, why and when); that evidence speaks for itself (it needs explanation); that National Register listing protects a building from any change (the page says it generally does not).
Supports: provide a short list of teacher-checked sources for local sites. Model a paraphrase aloud. Students who struggle with research may use the NPGallery record and this page for the Wilmerding site. Stretch: find a primary source, such as a historic photograph with its catalog record.
Answer guide: sample paragraph: “First, this building has national importance. According to the National Park Service, a place must be connected to important events, people or architecture to join the National Register. The building’s record lists all three, including George Westinghouse. If the nation recognizes the building for these reasons, our own community should help people learn about it.” The vocabulary task (criteria, significance) assesses CC.1.2.7.J; the integrity and archeological items assess CC.1.2.7.K.
National Park Service, National Register of Historic Places: How to List a Property · U.S. government work (National Park Service), public domain
This National Park Service page explains how a place joins the National Register of Historic Places, the official list of the nation’s historic places worthy of preservation. The process usually begins with the State Historic Preservation Office. Property owners, historical societies, government agencies and other groups can submit nominations.
To be eligible, a place is judged by its age, its significance and its integrity. It is generally at least 50 years old and still looks much as it did. It is connected to important events, important people, architecture or engineering, or it can teach us about the past through archeology. After state review, the National Park Service makes a final decision.
The page also says what listing does not do: it does not, by itself, stop a private owner from changing or even tearing down the property in most cases. Owners can order a bronze plaque to mark a listing.
Words to know: eligible means allowed to be chosen; integrity here means how much a place still looks as it did; archeological means about digging up and studying objects from the past.
How are Properties Evaluated?
To be considered eligible, a property must meet the National Register Criteria for Evaluation. This involves examining the property’s age, significance, and integrity.
Age and Integrity: Is the property old enough to be considered historic (generally at least 50 years old) and does it still look much the way it did in the past?
Significance: Is the property associated with events, activities, or developments that were important in the past? With the lives of people who were important in the past? With significant architectural history, landscape history, or engineering achievements? Does it have the potential to yield information through archeological investigation about our past?
Source: National Park Service, National Register of Historic Places: How to List a Property (nps.gov)