review how poets use structure and history, and practice a text-dependent analysis, so I am ready for the unit check.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Last lesson you read the 1830 newspaper paragraph. Holmes answered it with a poem two days later. Before you read: if you wanted to save a ship with a poem, would you praise it, or pretend to agree with tearing it apart? Write one sentence.
A poem begins, “Ay, tear her tattered ensign down.” What is the speaker probably doing?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Review 1: structure adds meaning. The poem moves in three steps. Stanza 1 mourns the flag. Stanza 2 remembers the battles on the deck and names the danger: “The harpies of the shore shall pluck / The eagle of the sea!” Stanza 3 turns: “Oh better that her shattered hulk / Should sink beneath the wave.” The order builds to a surprising claim: a glorious sinking would be better than being taken apart.
Review 2: fiction and history. The National Park Service says the Constitution was launched in Boston in 1797 and that in the War of 1812 its crew defeated four British frigates in three battles. It earned its nickname because enemy cannonballs seemed unable to break its oak hull. Holmes keeps none of these facts. He uses images (“the cannon’s roar,” “heroes’ blood”) to make readers feel the history. A poet may change or leave out facts to serve a purpose.
Review 3: word meaning. Use context, word parts and allusions. Ensign has several meanings (a flag, or a junior officer); here the next lines, “That banner in the sky,” show it means flag. Harpies is an allusion to Greek myth.
Text-dependent analysis (TDA). A TDA answers a question about a text with a clear claim, evidence quoted from the text and explanation. Use this plan: Introduction (title, author, your claim), two body paragraphs (each with a point, a quotation and an explanation), conclusion.
Worked example 1: Zoe writes a TDA claim. Question: How does Holmes argue the ship should not be broken up? Zoe writes: “In ‘Old Ironsides,’ Holmes uses a mocking opening and a surprising final stanza to argue that destroying the ship would dishonor its history.”
Worked example 2: Andre explains evidence. Andre quotes “The harpies of the shore shall pluck / The eagle of the sea!” and explains: “By calling the people who would scrap the ship harpies, Holmes makes them monsters and makes the ship a proud eagle. Readers are pushed to side with the eagle.”
Review questions. Answer from the poem.
Score and improve your TDA.
Use the TDA checklist: clear claim that answers the question; two quotations copied exactly; an explanation after each; transitions; a conclusion. Mark what you have, then revise one paragraph to fix what is missing.
History check: Holmes leaves out every fact the Park Service gives. Explain in three or four sentences why a poet arguing to save the ship might make that choice, and whether it is a problem or a power.
You have now practiced every reading skill on the unit check. Tomorrow you will use them on a new poem.
Exit ticket: which skill do you feel ready for, and which one will you review tonight?
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading 6, mini lecture 8, review questions 6, TDA practice 15, closure 2. The self-score can be homework.
Flex lesson (review): this lesson reviews the Part 1 reading codes (CC.1.3.7.E structure, H fiction vs. history, I and J vocabulary) on a new text and introduces the full TDA format for CC.1.4.7.S. Use results to group students for 1.24.
Sources: ship facts in the mini lecture come from the National Park Service page on USS Constitution (nps.gov/bost/learn/historyculture/ussconst.htm). The poem is complete as printed in Holmes’s collected works.
Likely misconceptions: that the speaker wants the flag torn down (irony); that the poem is a factual history; that a TDA summarizes the poem instead of analyzing it.
Supports: read the poem aloud twice. Provide a TDA frame and a quotation sandwich (introduce, quote, explain). Stretch: add a third body paragraph on the ending.
Answer guide: sample TDA body paragraph: “Holmes begins with irony to make readers angry. The speaker says, ‘Ay, tear her tattered ensign down,’ as if agreeing with the plan. The rest of the stanza remembers how ‘many an eye has danced to see / That banner in the sky,’ so the order sounds cruel. By pretending to agree, Holmes makes readers want to say no.” Score the TDA with the S rows of the 1.25 rubric for practice only.
Project Gutenberg, The Poetical Works of Oliver Wendell Holmes, Complete, eBook #7400 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
Oliver Wendell Holmes wrote “Old Ironsides” in September 1830, after reading that the Navy might break up the frigate Constitution. His note says it was first printed in the Boston Daily Advertiser, two days after he read the paragraph that inspired it. Here is the complete poem.
The poem has three stanzas of eight lines. Notice what each stanza focuses on: the flag, the deck, and finally a different fate for the ship. Notice that the speaker never names the ship, a battle or a date. Listen for the bitter, mocking tone of the first line.
Words to know: ay means yes; ensign is a ship’s flag; meteor here means a bright streak across the sky; vanquished means defeated; harpies are winged monsters from Greek myths that snatch things away; hulk is the body of an old ship; threadbare means worn thin; gale means a strong wind.
OLD IRONSIDES
AY, tear her tattered ensign down
Long has it waved on high,
And many an eye has danced to see
That banner in the sky;
Beneath it rung the battle shout,
And burst the cannon’s roar;–
The meteor of the ocean air
Shall sweep the clouds no more.Her deck, once red with heroes’ blood,
Where knelt the vanquished foe,
When winds were hurrying o’er the flood,
And waves were white below,
No more shall feel the victor’s tread,
Or know the conquered knee;–
The harpies of the shore shall pluck
The eagle of the sea!Oh better that her shattered hulk
Should sink beneath the wave;
Her thunders shook the mighty deep,
And there should be her grave;
Nail to the mast her holy flag,
Set every threadbare sail,
And give her to the god of storms,
The lightning and the gale!
Source: Project Gutenberg, The Poetical Works of Oliver Wendell Holmes, Complete, eBook #7400 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)