give and use specific feedback on argument drafts, using the checklist and an 1830 newspaper argument as practice.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think of a time someone gave you feedback that actually helped. What made it helpful? Write two words that describe good feedback.
Which comment is the most helpful for a writer?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Readers help writers. Before a letter goes to a real reader, a practice reader can catch what the writer cannot see. In a peer conference, the reviewer reads the draft, names one strength (a glow) and one specific suggestion (a grow), each tied to a checklist number.
Steps of our conference. (1) The writer reads the letter aloud. (2) The reviewer states the claim back in one sentence. If they cannot, the claim needs work. (3) The reviewer gives a glow and a grow with checklist numbers. (4) The writer asks one question and records the feedback. (5) The writer decides what to change.
Practice on 1830. The newspaper’s claim is that the ship “should never by any act of our government cease to belong to the Navy.” Its evidence is the case of the British ship Victory, which was saved after the public protested. Its weak spot is the source: it says only “upon good authority,” without naming anyone.
Worked example 1: Noah reviews the 1830 paragraph. “Glow (checklist 8): the ending asks the Secretary of the Navy for a specific choice, ‘either let her remain in ordinary or rebuild her.’ Grow (checklist 4): name the ‘good authority’ so readers can trust the report.”
Worked example 2: Bella reviews a classmate. “Your claim is: the society should place a marker at the old mill. Glow (checklist 6): you state the cost objection fairly. Grow (checklist 5): after your quotation from the Park Service, add a sentence explaining why it matters for the mill.”
The writer decides. Write down every suggestion, then choose. If you do not use a suggestion, write why. That is what professional writers and editors do.
Practice peer review on the 1830 paragraph, then confer about your own drafts.
Hold your peer conference, then plan your revision.
Record your conference: your partner’s one-sentence restatement of your claim, their glow, their grow and the question you asked. Was the restatement what you meant?
Write your revision plan with two or three numbered changes, each linked to a checklist item (especially 1, 2, 4 and 6). Add one suggestion you chose not to use and explain why.
According to the U.S. Navy’s Dictionary of American Naval Fighting Ships, a survey in 1830 found the USS Constitution to be unseaworthy, and the ship was set aside to be sold or scrapped. Then the public spoke up. The Navy’s history says that public feeling, stirred partly by Oliver Wendell Holmes’s “memorable poem,” led instead to money for rebuilding the ship. Reconstruction began in Boston in 1833.
Newspapers spread both the warning and the poem. Readers wrote, talked and pushed. Today, the National Park Service notes, the Constitution is the oldest commissioned warship afloat in the world, and Navy sailors still serve aboard it at the Charlestown Navy Yard in Boston.
Think about it: The newspaper paragraph and the poem argued for the same thing in different forms. Why might many voices and forms together persuade leaders more than one letter alone? What does this suggest for our class letters?
In 1830 ordinary readers helped change what happened to a ship. Your feedback today helps a classmate’s letter do the same for a local place.
Exit ticket: what is one thing your partner noticed that you would not have seen on your own?
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading 6, mini lecture 6, case study 6, guided practice 7, two conference rounds 10, plan and closure 2.
Assessment: use the first draft and conference record to assess CC.1.4.7.G, H and I (checklist items 1, 2, 4 and 6) before revision. The guided questions on the 1830 paragraph assess CC.1.2.7.H (tracing the claim and judging whether the evidence is sufficient).
Sources: case study facts come from the Naval History and Heritage Command’s Dictionary of American Naval Fighting Ships entry “Constitution” (history.navy.mil, opened 2026-11-21) and the National Park Service page on USS Constitution (nps.gov/bost/learn/historyculture/ussconst.htm). The Navy entry credits public sentiment “partly” to the poem. Present it that way: the poem helped, among many voices. The Navy page is cited here rather than as a reading because it blocks some automated link checks.
Likely misconceptions: that peer review means finding mistakes only; that the reviewer decides; that a glow can be general.
Supports: pair students thoughtfully and post stems: “Your claim is…” “I was convinced when…” “I wondered where this fact came from…” Model a conference with a volunteer using the mentor letter. Students anxious about reading aloud may hand the draft to their partner.
Answer guide: sample glow and grow for 1830: “Glow (checklist 4): the Victory example is relevant because it shows the public saving a famous ship before. Grow (checklist 4): name the ‘good authority,’ because readers cannot check an unnamed source.”
Project Gutenberg, The Poetical Works of Oliver Wendell Holmes, Complete, eBook #7400 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
The USS Constitution is a U.S. Navy warship launched in 1797 and nicknamed “Old Ironsides.” In 1830 newspapers reported that it might be taken apart. The young poet Oliver Wendell Holmes read one of those reports and quickly wrote a poem in response.
Years later, when his poems were collected, Holmes added a note before the poem. In it he reprints the newspaper paragraph that inspired him, from the Boston Daily Advertiser of September 14, 1830, which had copied it from the New York Journal of Commerce. That paragraph is a short argument: a claim about what should happen to the ship, evidence from a similar case in England and a request to the Secretary of the Navy.
Words to know: frigate means a fast warship; affirmed means stated as true; dispose of means get rid of; disapprobation means disapproval; lamentations means loud expressions of sorrow; in ordinary means kept out of service but cared for; subjoin means add at the end; impromptu means done without planning.
This was the popular name by which the frigate Constitution was known. The poem was first printed in the Boston Daily Advertiser, at the time when it was proposed to break up the old ship as unfit for service. I subjoin the paragraph which led to the writing of the poem. It is from the Advertiser of Tuesday, September 14, 1830:–
“Old Ironsides.–It has been affirmed upon good authority that the Secretary of the Navy has recommended to the Board of Navy Commissioners to dispose of the frigate Constitution. Since it has been understood that such a step was in contemplation we have heard but one opinion expressed, and that in decided disapprobation of the measure. Such a national object of interest, so endeared to our national pride as Old Ironsides is, should never by any act of our government cease to belong to the Navy, so long as our country is to be found upon the map of nations. In England it was lately determined by the Admiralty to cut the Victory, a one-hundred gun ship (which it will be recollected bore the flag of Lord Nelson at the battle of Trafalgar,) down to a seventy-four, but so loud were the lamentations of the people upon the proposed measure that the intention was abandoned. We confidently anticipate that the Secretary of the Navy will in like manner consult the general wish in regard to the Constitution, and either let her remain in ordinary or rebuild her whenever the public service may require.”–New York Journal of Commerce.
The poem was an impromptu outburst of feeling and was published on the next day but one after reading the above paragraph.
Source: Project Gutenberg, The Poetical Works of Oliver Wendell Holmes, Complete, eBook #7400 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)