evaluate whether the reasoning at the end of Roosevelt’s fireside chat is sound and whether his evidence is relevant and sufficient.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now: sound or not? Decide whether each sample argument (all invented) is sound. (1) “Our team will win Friday because we have won our last six games against teams with better records.” (2) “Our team will win Friday because our new uniforms are blue.” (3) “Our team will win Friday because we really believe in ourselves.”
Which sample argument has the most relevant evidence?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Three tests for an argument. Sound reasoning: do the reasons logically lead to the claim? Relevant evidence: is the evidence actually about the claim? Sufficient evidence: is there enough of it to be convinced? An argument can pass one test and fail another.
Appeals to feeling. Speakers also stir emotions, such as hope, pride or fear. An emotional appeal can be honest and useful, but it is not evidence. Notice when a line makes you feel something without proving anything.
Worked example 1: relevant but sufficient? Grace tested the claim “it is safer to keep your money in a reopened bank than under the mattress.” His reason is that “the banks will take care of all needs.” She called it relevant, then added: “In this part he does not give numbers. The evidence about Treasury checks came earlier, in the plan. On its own, this paragraph is not sufficient.”
Worked example 2: an admission builds trust. Andre noticed that Roosevelt admits “Some of our bankers had shown themselves either incompetent or dishonest.” Andre wrote: “Admitting a real problem makes him sound honest. It also supports his reasoning: if only a few banks were bad, the people were wrong to fear all of them.”
Judging the argument, not the person. We are not deciding whether Roosevelt was a good president. We are practicing a skill every listener needs, for speeches, ads and podcasts alike, including our own show.
A model evaluation of my own. Roosevelt’s reasoning is mostly sound: if banks can now pay everyone, then fear is the only remaining danger. His evidence is relevant, but in this part it is thin; he relies on assurances (“I can assure you”) and emotional appeals (“Together we cannot fail”). The admission about dishonest bankers makes the argument more believable.
Use the passage and your R, E and F marks.
Write an evaluation.
Write a 6-8 sentence evaluation: Is the reasoning in this part of the fireside chat sound, and is the evidence relevant and sufficient? Checklist: (1) state his claim, (2) judge the reasoning, (3) judge relevance and sufficiency, each with a quotation, (4) name one emotional appeal and its effect, (5) a concluding sentence with your overall judgment.
Investigate is done: we have studied stories in three media, two sources and a speech. Next we make sense of it all, starting with how photos, sound and words work together.
Exit ticket: write one rule for your own radio segment so your claims are backed by enough evidence.
Pacing (40 min): sample arguments 5, reading 8, mini lesson 8, guided practice and discussion 11, evaluation 8.
Context: the sample team arguments are invented. Keep the discussion on reasoning and evidence; accept any well-supported judgment. “Hoarding” here means keeping cash at home; it is not a mental-health term in this text, but be ready to clarify gently.
Likely misconceptions: that emotional appeals are always bad; that an argument with any evidence is automatically sufficient; that admitting a problem always weakens an argument.
Supports: a three-test checklist (sound? relevant? sufficient?) with yes/partly/no boxes. Stretch: what evidence would you want if you were a listener in 1933?
Sample evaluation: Roosevelt claims that money is now safer in reopened banks than at home. His reasoning is sound: if banks can meet “all needs,” hiding cash is unnecessary. His evidence is relevant, but in this part it is not sufficient, because he relies on “I can assure you” instead of facts. His admission that “some of our bankers” were “incompetent or dishonest” builds trust. “Together we cannot fail” is an emotional appeal that gives listeners courage. Overall, the argument is convincing as a whole speech but thin in this section.
FDIC (Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation), Transcript of Speech by President Franklin D. Roosevelt Regarding the Banking Crisis, March 12, 1933 · U.S. government work, public domain (a president's official address, transcript published by the FDIC)
Where we are. These paragraphs come near the end of the talk. Roosevelt expects that a few frightened people may still pull their money out when banks reopen. He argues that money is safer in a reopened bank than hidden at home. He admits that some bankers had been careless or dishonest with people’s money, though he says most were not. He ends by saying that the people’s confidence matters more than currency or gold, and asks listeners to support the plan together.
What to notice. Mark each reason with R, each piece of evidence with E and each appeal to feeling with F. Which kind does he use most?
Words to know. Hoarding is storing up a large supply and hiding it. A phantom is a ghost or something imagined. Incompetent means not able to do a job well. Speculations are risky investments made for quick profit. To differentiate is to tell things apart. Stampeded means pushed into a rush by panic.
Read the passage under “The text” once for meaning and once with a pencil.
It is possible that when the banks resume a very few people who have not recovered from their fear may again begin withdrawals. Let me make it clear that the banks will take care of all needs — and it is my belief that hoarding during the past week has become an exceedingly unfashionable pastime. It needs no prophet to tell you that when the people find that they can get their money — that they can get it when they want it for all legitimate purposes — the phantom of fear will soon be laid. People will again be glad to have their money where it will be safely taken care of and where they can use it conveniently at any time. I can assure you that it is safer to keep your money in a reopened bank than under the mattress.
[…]
We had a bad banking situation. Some of our bankers had shown themselves either incompetent or dishonest in their handling of the people’s funds. They had used the money entrusted to them in speculations and unwise loans. This was of course not true in the vast majority of our banks but it was true in enough of them to shock the people for a time into a sense of insecurity and to put them into a frame of mind where they did not differentiate, but seemed to assume that the acts of a comparative few had tainted them all. It was the Government’s job to straighten out this situation and do it as quickly as possible — and the job is being performed.
[…]
After all there is an element in the readjustment of our financial system more important than currency, more important than gold, and that is the confidence of the people. Confidence and courage are the essentials of success in carrying out our plan. You people must have faith; you must not be stampeded by rumors or guesses. Let us unite in banishing fear. We have provided the machinery to restore our financial system; it is up to you to support and make it work.
It is your problem no less than it is mine. Together we cannot fail.
Source: FDIC (Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation), Transcript of Speech by President Franklin D. Roosevelt Regarding the Banking Crisis, March 12, 1933 (fdic.gov)