compare two government sources on early radio, assess each one’s credibility and accuracy, and explain why a claim about being first depends on definitions.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. The ITS page in 2.06 called KDKA’s 1920 broadcast the first of its kind. Today’s page is from another government agency. Write: if two government pages seem to disagree, does that mean one is lying? What else could explain it?
A sample post online says: “KDKA was the first radio station in the world, starting in 1915!” (This is a made-up sample.) What should a researcher do?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Credibility: can I trust who made this? Ask: Who wrote or published it? What do they know about the topic? Why did they publish it? When was it written or updated? Does it show its evidence?
Accuracy: are the facts right? Check a fact against at least one other trustworthy source. Look for exact dates, names and numbers that match. If sources differ, find out why before choosing.
Worked example 1: a difference in definitions. Hannah compared the two pages. Both say KDKA’s broadcast was November 2, 1920, and both say WWV started in May 1920. So why does one call KDKA first? She found the key word: the NIST page calls KDKA “generally acknowledged” as the first commercial broadcast station. WWV was an experimental government station. “First” depends on first at what.
Worked example 2: a source inside a source. Jamal noticed the NIST page quotes a news release from May 28, 1920. That release is a primary source, written at the time. The NIST page around it is a secondary source, written later. He wrote: “The dated quotation makes the page more credible, because I can see the evidence it relies on.”
Purpose matters. Both agencies are proud of their own history. That does not make them wrong, but it reminds us to check claims that make an organization look good.
A model evaluation of my own. The NIST page is credible because a government science agency published it, it gives exact dates and measurements, and it quotes a 1920 news release. Its dates match the ITS page. Its claim that KDKA was the first commercial station is careful wording that fits both sources.
Use today’s page and your 2.06 log entry.
Evaluate a source.
Fill in a source evaluation card for the NIST page: publisher, purpose, date or update, evidence it shows, whether it agrees with the ITS page. Rate its credibility from 1 to 4 and explain your rating in two sentences.
Find one more source for your own research question. Fill in a second evaluation card for it and add one new focused question to your log.
We check before we broadcast. Next we turn from sources to a speaker: we will map Roosevelt’s argument.
Exit ticket: on our show, how will you say a “first” claim carefully so it is accurate?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 5, reading 8, mini lesson 8, guided practice 10, evaluation cards 9.
Source notes: the NIST page indents the 1920 news release as a block quotation; we show it as its own paragraph. NIST’s companion blog (used in 2.13) gives the call-letter date as Oct. 1, 1919. The sample social post in the Do Now is invented for practice; say so.
Likely misconceptions: that disagreement means one source is lying; that .gov guarantees accuracy; that a primary source is always more accurate than a secondary one.
Supports: a printed evaluation card with sentence starters (“I trust this source because…”). Stretch: other accounts credit announcer Leo Rosenberg with reading the 1920 returns; how could both ITS’s wording and those accounts be accurate?
Answer guide: credibility rating 3-4 with reasons (government science agency, exact dates, quoted 1920 release, matches ITS dates); a strong answer also names the agency’s interest in its own history. Exit ticket: “KDKA is generally called the first commercial radio station.”
National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), History of Radio Station WWV · U.S. government work, public domain (U.S. Department of Commerce)
About the source. NIST is a U.S. government science agency. In 1920 it was called the National Bureau of Standards. This page tells the history of its radio station, WWV.
What it says. The call letters WWV were given to the bureau in October 1919; no one knows why those letters were chosen. Testing began in Washington, D.C., in May 1920 with Friday evening music concerts from 8:30 to 11 p.m. The weak signal could be heard about 40 kilometers away. The page quotes a news release from May 28, 1920, that imagined music being heard “hundreds of miles away.” It then reminds readers that KDKA of Pittsburgh, “generally acknowledged” as the first commercial station, did not go on the air until November 2, 1920. From December 1920 to April 1921, WWV broadcast farm market news for the Department of Agriculture.
Words to know. Commercial means run as a business. Apparatus is equipment. Transmissions are signals sent out. Radiated means sent out in waves.
WWV has a long and storied history that dates back to the very beginning of radio broadcasting. The call letters WWV were assigned to NIST (then called the National Bureau of Standards) in October 1919. Although the call letters WWV are now synonymous with the broadcasting of time signals, it is unknown why those particular call letters were chosen or assigned. Testing of the station began from Washington, D.C. in May 1920, with the broadcast of Friday evening music concerts that lasted from 8:30 to 11 p.m. The 50 W transmissions used a wavelength of 500 m (about 600 kHz, or near the low end of today’s commercial AM broadcast band), and could be heard out to about 40 kilometers. A news release dated May 28, 1920 hinted at the significance of this event:
This means that music can be performed at any place, radiated into the air by means of an ordinary radio set, and received at any other place even though hundreds of miles away. The music received can be made as loud as desired by suitable operation of the receiving apparatus. Such concerts are sometimes sent out by the radio laboratory of the Bureau of Standards in connection with trials of experimental apparatus. This music can be heard by anyone in the states near the District of Columbia having a simple amateur receiving outfit. The pleasant evenings which have been experienced by persons at a number of such receiving stations suggest interesting possibilities of the future.
Interesting possibilities, indeed! Keep in mind that KDKA of Pittsburgh, generally acknowledged as the first commercial broadcast station, did not go on the air until November 2, 1920.
On December 15, 1920 the station began assisting the Department of Agriculture in the distribution of market news to farm bureaus and agricultural organizations. A 2 kW spark transmitter was used to broadcast 500 word reports, called the Daily Market Marketgram, on 750 kHz. The operating radius was about 300 kilometers out of Washington. These broadcasts continued until April 15, 1921.
Source: National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), History of Radio Station WWV (nist.gov)