write a claim-evidence-reasoning response comparing Scrooge’s Christmas morning in the book, in an audio reading and in the 1910 film, analyzing a technique unique to each medium.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Recall the 1910 film’s title cards from 2.05. Which card showed Scrooge’s change on Christmas morning? Write what you remember, then predict what Dickens’s book will do differently.
In the book, what do you think first breaks into Scrooge's joy on Christmas morning?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Claim, evidence, reasoning. A strong comparison makes a claim (which version shows the change most powerfully, or how they differ), gives evidence from at least two versions (a quotation, a title card, a sound you heard), and explains the reasoning: which technique creates which effect.
Sound on the page. “Clash, clang, hammer; ding, dong, bell.” Dickens uses onomatopoeia, words that imitate sounds, and then flips the order: “Bell, dong, ding; hammer, clang, clash!” The reversal sounds like bells swinging back and forth.
Worked example 1: three bells. Lena compared the versions. Print: the reader hears the bells through the words. Audio: a reader can ring real bells under the voice, or let the words themselves ring. Silent film: no sound, so the card says a Christmas carol awakens him, and the pictures must show it without a sound. Lena wrote: “Each medium chose the tool it had.”
Worked example 2: the knocker. Sam focused on “What an honest expression it has in its face!” In print we remember the ghostly face from Stave I and feel how far Scrooge has come. In audio, the actor’s joyful voice carries the change. On film, a close-up of Scrooge patting the knocker could show it without a word.
A model CER paragraph of my own. The audio version shows Scrooge’s change most powerfully. In the book he cries “Hallo! Whoop! How are you! Merry Christmas!” and the reader must imagine the sound. Heard aloud, the same lines burst out in a laughing voice that is the opposite of the harsh, cold voice from Stave I. Because sound is the whole tool of audio, the listener hears the change in the voice itself.
Toward our show. What you learn here becomes our sound design: choose the medium’s best tool for the effect you want.
Use the passage, an audio reading of it and your 2.05 notes on the film.
Write a claim-evidence-reasoning response.
Which version of Scrooge's Christmas morning shows his change most powerfully: the book, an audio reading or the 1910 film? Write 7-9 sentences. Checklist: (1) a clear claim, (2) evidence from at least two versions, including one exact quotation from today's passage, (3) one technique unique to each version you discuss, (4) reasoning that explains each technique's effect, (5) a closing sentence that connects to “How does hearing a story change it?”
We have followed one story across three media. Next we turn our research questions into a plan.
Exit ticket: one technique from today you want to borrow for our show's sound design.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading and audio 9, mini lesson 7, guided practice 8, CER writing 12.
Audio: use the Stave V chapter of the LibriVox public-domain recording or a strong student or teacher reading. The cuts skip Scrooge dressing in a rush and the turkey errand; tell students the turkey goes anonymously to Bob Cratchit.
Care note: the book’s Tiny Tim, Bob’s young son, has a disability. If students discuss him from their own reading or film knowledge, keep the focus on the family’s love and on Scrooge’s change, not on pity.
Likely misconceptions: that the book is always best; that a change in an adaptation is a mistake; that evidence must come only from print.
Supports: a CER frame (“The ___ version shows… In the book… In the ___ version… This is because…”). Stretch: compare how each medium handles time (the bells “Bell, dong, ding” reversal vs. a quick film card).
Sample response: The book shows Scrooge’s change most powerfully because its words become sounds. When the bells ring “Clash, clang, hammer; ding, dong, bell,” I hear the joy in my head, and the reversed order sounds like bells swinging. The 1910 film cannot use sound, so it uses a title card saying he was awakened by a Christmas carol to a new life. That tells us the change but does not let us feel it as long. Hearing the book read aloud adds a voice, but the onomatopoeia already works on the page. So hearing a story can add feeling, but Dickens built the sound in first. Grade with the CC.1.3.7.G target: compares at least two versions and names techniques and effects.
Charles Dickens, A Christmas Carol (1843), Project Gutenberg eBook #46 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #46
Where we are. The three spirits have shown Scrooge his past, his present and a lonely future death. Now he wakes in his own bed, alive, with time to change. He is so happy he can barely stand still. He calls to a boy in the street and soon sends him to buy a huge turkey, which Scrooge secretly sends to his clerk, Bob Cratchit.
What to notice. Dickens writes the church bells as sounds. He piles up describing words for the morning. Scrooge shouts, repeats himself and even talks to the door knocker that scared him in Stave I. Mark one line that would be strongest heard aloud and one that would be strongest seen on screen.
Words to know. To make amends is to make up for wrongs. Transports here means strong feelings of joy. Lustiest means strongest and loudest. Peals are loud ringings of bells. Loitered means lingered with no hurry. Hallo is an old spelling of hello.
Read the passage under “The text” once for meaning and once with a pencil.
YES! and the bedpost was his own. The bed was his own, the room was his own. Best and happiest of all, the Time before him was his own, to make amends in!
[…]
He was checked in his transports by the churches ringing out the lustiest peals he had ever heard. Clash, clang, hammer; ding, dong, bell. Bell, dong, ding; hammer, clang, clash! Oh, glorious, glorious!
Running to the window, he opened it, and put out his head. No fog, no mist; clear, bright, jovial, stirring, cold; cold, piping for the blood to dance to; Golden sunlight; Heavenly sky; sweet fresh air; merry bells. Oh, glorious! Glorious!
“What’s to-day!” cried Scrooge, calling downward to a boy in Sunday clothes, who perhaps had loitered in to look about him.
“EH?” returned the boy, with all his might of wonder.
“What’s to-day, my fine fellow?” said Scrooge.
“To-day!” replied the boy. “Why, CHRISTMAS DAY.”
“It’s Christmas Day!” said Scrooge to himself. “I haven’t missed it. The Spirits have done it all in one night. They can do anything they like. Of course they can. Of course they can. Hallo, my fine fellow!”
“Hallo!” returned the boy.
[…]
“I shall love it, as long as I live!” cried Scrooge, patting it with his hand. “I scarcely ever looked at it before. What an honest expression it has in its face! It’s a wonderful knocker!–Here’s the Turkey! Hallo! Whoop! How are you! Merry Christmas!”
Source: Charles Dickens, A Christmas Carol (1843), Project Gutenberg eBook #46 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)