review the unit’s skills by comparing Poe’s poem on the page with recorded readings, analyzing a speaker’s claims and checking sources.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Say the word “tinkle” aloud, then “clang.” Which one sounds small and light, and which sounds big and heavy? Write one more word that sounds like what it means.
A word that sounds like the noise it names, such as “tinkle,” is an example of
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Review lab. Today we practice every skill the unit check will ask for: comparing a text with its audio version, analyzing ideas in media, tracing a speaker’s claims and judging sources. We use a poem built for the ear.
On the page. The page shows things a listener cannot see: the short indented lines, the dashes, the exclamation points, the way “bells” piles up at the end of each part. You can reread a hard word like tintinabulation as many times as you like.
In your ears. A recording adds the reader’s choices: speed, pauses, loudness and tone. Two readers can make the same lines feel different. One reader might race through the sleigh bells; another might slow down and make them dreamy. That is why LibriVox’s 18 recordings of one poem run from under four minutes to about six.
Worked example 1: Imani compares two readings. Imani hears Reader A finish Part I quickly and brightly, with “tinkle, tinkle, tinkle” almost like real sleigh bells. Reader B reads slowly and softly. She writes: “On the page, the repeated words look like a list. Reader A makes them sound like ringing, which fits the ‘merriment’ in line 3. Reader B’s slow pace makes Part I feel calm instead of fun.”
Worked example 2: Theo analyzes a claim. A classmate says in a review, “Recordings are always better than reading.” Theo delineates: the claim is “always better”; the evidence is one recording she liked. He writes: “Relevant, but not sufficient. The page lets us study line shape and spelling that a recording hides.”
Stations. You will rotate through three review stations: Listen and Compare, Claims and Evidence, and Source Check.
Station work: use the poem and the two recordings your teacher plays.
Finish the other two stations.
Claims and Evidence station: a podcast host says, “Poe’s poem proves that sound matters more than meaning.” Delineate the claim, name what evidence it would need, and judge whether the poem alone is sufficient.
Source Check station: you want to tell listeners when “The Bells” was first published. Name two kinds of sources you could use, how you would check each one’s credibility, and how you would cite it in show notes.
Poe wrote a poem you can almost hear on the page. Your segment is a story your listeners will hear with no page at all.
Exit ticket: which unit skill do you feel strongest in, and which one will you review before the unit check?
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading and two recordings 9, mini lecture 6, three stations 18, closure 2 (some station work finishes at home).
Recordings: preview the LibriVox catalog page for “The Bells” (librivox.org/the-bells-by-edgar-allan-poe; 18 recordings, Fortnightly Poetry project, catalogued 2011) and choose two readers with clearly different pacing; play only Parts I and II. LibriVox recordings are public domain in the United States. The passage is Parts I and II only; Parts III and IV (alarm and funeral bells) are darker and are not needed.
Likely misconceptions: that a recording is the “real” poem; that one reading is right and the other wrong; that onomatopoeia means any sound-related word (“melody” is about sound but does not imitate it).
Supports: give a two-column listening chart (page / audio). Play recordings twice. Pre-teach tintinabulation by clapping its syllables. Stretch: compare a third reading and rank all three for one purpose.
Answer guide: sample comparison: “Reader A says ‘tinkle, tinkle, tinkle’ quickly and lightly, like real sleigh bells, which fits ‘merriment.’ Reader B pauses after each ‘tinkle,’ which sounds lonely. On the page I could not hear either choice; I could only see the word three times.” Sample claim analysis: “The claim is that sound matters more than meaning. The poem shows sound matters a lot, but each part also has a clear meaning (fun, then joy), so one poem is not sufficient evidence for ‘more than meaning.’” The quiz items and comparison assess CC.1.3.7.G and CC.1.5.7.C (main ideas presented orally) as a formative review.
Project Gutenberg, The Poetical Works of Edgar Allan Poe (Sampson Low, 1858), eBook #79019 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
Edgar Allan Poe (1809–1849) was an American poet and story writer. “The Bells” was published after his death in 1849. It has four parts, each about a different kind of bell. We read the first two: silver sleigh bells on a winter night and golden wedding bells. This printing comes from an 1858 London edition of his poems; it spells “tintinabulation” with one n.
LibriVox, a volunteer project whose recordings are public domain in the United States, offers 18 different recordings of this poem by different readers. Their lengths range from under four minutes to about six. Your teacher will play two of them.
Words to know: sledges are sleds; merriment means fun and laughter; foretells means tells ahead of time; crystalline means clear and sparkling like crystal; Runic means like old, mysterious writing or verse; tintinabulation means the ringing of bells; mellow means soft and rich; euphony means pleasant sound; voluminously means in a great amount; rapture means great joy.
THE BELLS.
I.
Hear the sledges with the bells—
Silver bells!
What a world of merriment their melody foretells!
How they tinkle, tinkle, tinkle,
In the icy air of night!
While the stars that oversprinkle
All the heavens, seem to twinkle
With a crystalline delight;
Keeping time, time, time,
In a sort of Runic rhyme,
To the tintinabulation that so musically wells
From the bells, bells, bells, bells,
Bells, bells, bells—
From the jingling and the tinkling of the bells.II.
Hear the mellow wedding bells,
Golden bells!
What a world of happiness their harmony foretells!
Through the balmy air of night
How they ring out their delight!
From the molten-golden notes,
And all in tune,
What a liquid ditty floats
To the turtle-dove that listens, while she gloats
On the moon!
Oh, from out the sounding cells,
What a gush of euphony voluminously wells!
How it swells!
How it dwells
On the Future! how it tells
Of the rapture that impels
To the swinging and the ringing
Of the bells, bells, bells,
Of the bells, bells, bells, bells,
Bells, bells, bells—
To the rhyming and the chiming of the bells!
Source: Project Gutenberg, The Poetical Works of Edgar Allan Poe (Sampson Low, 1858), eBook #79019 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)