reflect on how writers and communities shape the memory of history and answer our driving question with evidence from the unit.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Look back at your first answer to the driving question from the start of the unit: When writers change history, is that a problem or a power? Write one sentence about whether your answer has changed.
A famous battle is named after a hill, but the monument for it stands on a different hill. Why might that happen?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Every unit has an ending and a beginning. You started this unit comparing a poem and an eyewitness account. You end it as a writer who has asked a real community to remember a real place.
Names, poems and monuments shape memory. The battle is still called Bunker Hill, though its monument stands on Breed’s Hill, where the fort was built. Whittier’s poem made a legend of Barbara Frietchie. Holmes’s poem helped stir the public feeling that saved a ship. Each one changed how people remember the past.
Problem or power? A change can be a problem when readers mistake a legend for fact. It can be a power when it helps people care about the past and protect it. Often it is both, which is why we read the poem and the note.
Worked example 1: Liam reflects with evidence. “At first I said changing history is always a problem. Now I think it can be a power. Holmes never named a battle in ‘Old Ironsides,’ but the Navy’s history says public sentiment, stirred partly by his poem, helped save the ship.”
Worked example 2: Nadia reflects on her writing. “My biggest growth was answering the other side. In my first draft I ignored people who worried about cost. After studying Ruskin, I named that concern and answered it with a grant idea.”
Your reflection answers the driving question with evidence from at least two texts and names your growth as a writer.
Use the page and the texts from our unit.
Write your unit reflection.
Final reflection (two paragraphs). Paragraph 1: answer the driving question, When writers change history, is that a problem or a power? Use evidence from at least two texts, quoted or paraphrased with the title. Paragraph 2: name the checklist item where you grew most as a writer, with a before-and-after example from your letter.
Point of view: the Park Service page was written to inform visitors. How is its purpose different from Whittier’s purpose in “Barbara Frietchie”? Give one example from each.
Places remember because people write, speak and build. This unit, you joined them.
Exit ticket: finish this sentence: “When writers change history, …”
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 7, mini lecture 7, guided practice 8, reflection 16, closure 3.
Assessment: the reflection assesses CC.1.4.7.S (evidence for reflection) and CC.1.3.7.H (how authors use or change history); the point-of-view question assesses CC.1.2.7.D. If any recipient replies to the class letters, share the reply in a later lesson.
Likely misconceptions: that the battle took place only on Bunker Hill (the page places the monument and fort on Breed’s Hill); that a monument is neutral (it reflects choices about what to remember).
Supports: provide a reflection frame: “At first I thought… Now I think… because in [text] … My biggest growth as a writer was…” Stretch: propose what a fair marker for Barbara Frietchie’s house should say.
Answer guide: sample reflection paragraph: “When writers change history, it is both a problem and a power. Whittier’s note admits his story ‘was probably incorrect in some of its details,’ so readers can be misled. But the Navy’s history credits public feeling, stirred partly by Holmes’s poem, with saving the Constitution. The power is real, so writers owe readers the facts too.” Sample point of view answer: the Park Service informs with numbers such as “some 2,400 British soldiers”; Whittier persuades with images such as “Shoot, if you must, this old gray head.”
National Park Service, Boston National Historical Park: Bunker Hill Monument · U.S. government work (National Park Service), public domain
This National Park Service page describes the Bunker Hill Monument in Charlestown, Massachusetts, part of Boston National Historical Park. On June 17, 1775, New England soldiers faced the British army in a pitched battle for the first time. The fight is popularly known as the Battle of Bunker Hill. The British held the field, but of about 2,400 British soldiers and Marines engaged, about 1,000 were wounded or killed. The Provincial soldiers came from Massachusetts, Connecticut and New Hampshire.
Fifty years after the battle, the Marquis de Lafayette set the cornerstone of a monument. The 221-foot granite obelisk took more than seventeen years to build and was dedicated in 1843. It stands on Breed’s Hill, where the Provincial forces built an earthen fort, and it remains the focal point of the battle’s memory.
Words to know: commemorates means honors the memory of; pitched battle means a planned battle between armies; obelisk means a tall, four-sided stone pillar; redoubt means a small fort.
Source: National Park Service, Boston National Historical Park: Bunker Hill Monument (nps.gov)