show what I have learned about the Constitution, the Bill of Rights, Pennsylvania’s government and history, and the rights and responsibilities of citizens.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Take a slow breath. You have been working like civics researchers for weeks. Read the passage first. You will use it as evidence on the checkpoint.
How confident are you that you can I am ready to use evidence from the reading and from our unit.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
This checkpoint is your chance to show your thinking. It covers our plan of government, the Bill of Rights, Pennsylvania history and citizenship. Read each question fully. Use the reading and what you remember from our work.
For written answers, use claim, evidence, reasoning. State your answer. Give a fact or detail. Explain how the fact supports your answer.
Worked example 1: Zoe answers a rights question. Question: how does the Bill of Rights protect a person accused of a crime? Zoe writes: “It promises a fair trial. The reading says the Sixth Amendment gives a speedy, public trial, a fair jury and a lawyer. This means the government must prove its case fairly.”
Worked example 2: Marcus answers a history question. Question: how did people respond to the whiskey tax? Marcus writes: “Some worked peacefully to repeal it, and some attacked tax collectors. Albert Gallatin urged people to obey the law. This shows that people chose different ways to disagree.”
Be fair. When a question asks about a disagreement, explain both sides before you give your reasoning. You do not need to share your family’s political views on any question.
Part A. Answer on your own. Use the reading.
Part B. Answer each part in 2 to 4 sentences with evidence.
1. Founding documents. (a) What is the main idea of the Declaration of Independence? (b) Explain one main idea of the Constitution and one of the Bill of Rights. (c) Describe how the government protects people's rights and property, using one amendment from the reading.
2. Pennsylvania roots. (a) Explain one main idea of Penn's Charter, the Charter of Privileges or Pennsylvania's Declaration of Rights, and one thing the Pennsylvania Constitution does for people. (b) Compare the Pennsylvania and U.S. preambles. (c) Describe what Benjamin Franklin or James Madison did, and one role Pennsylvanians played. (d) Explain how Native Americans, Europeans and Africans contributed to early Pennsylvania.
3. How rules are made. (a) Compare how a rule is made in a direct democracy and in a republic. (b) Explain the common good and one way government works for it. (c) Describe how to respect the flag and explain why people say the Pledge or stand for the anthem.
4. Thinking like a historian. (a) Write a historical question about early Pennsylvania that evidence can answer. (b) Name one primary and one secondary source from our unit. (c) Name one piece of folklore and the fact that corrects it. (d) Give one example of cooperation and one of conflict in early Pennsylvania, and explain why the 1780 law mattered.
5. Settling conflict. (a) Explain how courts settled the disagreement in Tinker v. Des Moines. (b) Name two other peaceful ways citizens settle disagreements. (c) Describe what happened to people and the community when laws were broken in the Whiskey Rebellion. (d) Explain why a leader like Albert Gallatin mattered.
6. Citizens and government. (a) Compare a political right with a personal or economic right, and a responsibility to yourself with one to your community. (b) Explain how one right comes with a responsibility. (c) Explain what William Penn meant by “Governments, like clocks, go from the motion men give them.” (d) Describe the difference between limited and unlimited government.
Look back through your answers. Add evidence wherever you can.
Which answer best shows your growth as a civics researcher? Why?
How confident are you that you can I can explain how the Constitution and Bill of Rights protect people.
Pacing: reading 6 minutes, directions and examples 4, Part A 8, Part B 20, closure 2. Part B is long: allow extended time or split it across two sittings (questions 1-3, then 4-6).
Evidence map: Part A: Sixth Amendment 5.3.6.G:1a; checks 5.1.6.C:2a; popular sovereignty 5.1.6.C:1a; General Assembly 5.3.6.B:2a; republic 5.1.6.I:1a; preamble 5.1.6.F:1a; Flag Code 5.1.6.G:1a. Part B: Q1 5.1.6.E:1a, 5.1.6.E:2a, 5.1.6.J:1a; Q2 5.1.6.D:1a, 5.1.6.D:2a, 5.1.6.F:2a, 5.1.6.H:1a, 5.1.6.H:2a, 8.2.6.A:1a; Q3 5.1.6.I:2a, 5.1.6.J:2a, 5.1.6.G:1a, 5.1.6.G:2a; Q4 8.1.6.D:1a, 8.1.6.D:2a, 8.1.6.D:3a, 8.2.6.D:1a, 8.2.6.D:2a, 8.2.6.D:3a; Q5 5.1.6.L:1a, 5.2.6.C:1a, 5.2.6.F:1a, 5.2.6.D:1a; Q6 5.2.6.A:1a, 5.2.6.A:2a, 5.2.6.B:1a, 5.1.6.M:1a, 5.1.6.M:2a, 5.3.6.K:1a. The branch jobs (5.3.6.B:1a) are also assessed by the Part A checks question and in 2.23.
Supports: read aloud, allow oral responses, provide sentence frames and the branch organizer. Never require students to state a personal political opinion.
Answer guide (3 points per part): 3 = correct, specific evidence and clear reasoning; 2 = correct with limited evidence; 1 = partly correct or unsupported. Q1: people have rights and may form a government that protects them; Fifth Amendment fair payment for property, Fourth searches, Sixth trials. Q2: elected assembly and liberty of conscience; the PA Constitution sets up state government and protects rights; both preambles begin with the people. Q4: folklore such as the bell ringing on July 4, 1776, or a single great treaty under the elm; 1780 law was the first state law to begin ending slavery. Q5: appeals up to a 7-2 Supreme Court ruling; voting, compromise, petition; treason trials, fear, a death. Q6: Penn means government depends on the people who run it.
National Archives, The Bill of Rights: What Does it Say? · U.S. government work, public domain
The Bill of Rights is the first ten amendments to the Constitution. The National Archives says it protects Americans’ rights against their government and sets rules for fair treatment by the law.
The First Amendment protects speech, the press, gathering peacefully, petitioning the government and religion. The Second protects the right to keep and bear arms. The Third says soldiers cannot be housed in people’s homes, which British law had allowed before the Revolution. The Fourth protects people and their things from unreasonable searches.
The Fifth says people cannot be tried twice for the same crime or forced to speak against themselves, and the government cannot take property without fair payment. The Sixth promises a speedy, public trial, a fair jury and a lawyer. The Seventh gives jury trials in many other court cases. The Eighth forbids unfairly high bail and fines and cruel and unusual punishment.
The Ninth says that listing some rights does not mean people have no others. The Tenth says powers not given to the national government belong to the states or the people.
Source: National Archives, The Bill of Rights: What Does it Say? (archives.gov)