use sources to explain what happened in Boston on March 5, 1770, and how Crispus Attucks has been remembered.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Look again at Paul Revere’s picture from lesson 1.02. List two things it shows. Then list one thing you wish you knew about the people in the crowd.
Five men died after soldiers fired on King Street. What do you think historians know about Crispus Attucks, the first named victim?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Why soldiers were in Boston. In 1768, British soldiers began occupying Boston to stop violent protests over taxes. Many Bostonians resented them. Fights between townspeople and soldiers grew.
The night of March 5. A crowd surrounded a soldier on guard at the Custom House on King Street. Captain Thomas Preston brought more soldiers. People threw snowballs, ice and insults. The soldiers fired. Crispus Attucks, Samuel Gray, James Caldwell, Samuel Maverick and Patrick Carr died.
Evidence and legend. A legend is a story told over and over that may not be proven. Historians separate what sources show from what people later believed. For Attucks, the sources show where he was and how he died. They do not prove whether he was ever enslaved.
Worked example 1: known or possible? Amara sorts two facts. “Two musket balls killed him” goes under Known, because witnesses and records describe it. “He escaped slavery in 1750” goes under Possible, because the ad might not be about him.
Worked example 2: why memory changes. Noah notices that Black abolitionists honored Attucks in the 1850s, when slavery still existed in the South. He writes, “They used his story to show that Black Americans helped start the fight for liberty.”
Points of view. At the soldiers’ trial, the defense described the crowd with insulting words, including about Attucks’s race. That source shows prejudice of the time. Next lesson we study the trial itself.
Use the reading and a Known / Possible / Legend sorting chart.
Draft a person card for our Black Americans gallery.
Write a person card for Crispus Attucks with three parts: Known (with the source), Possible (and why it is uncertain), and How he is remembered.
Compare: what does Revere's picture show about the crowd, and what does the Park Service reading add?
Five men died, and the soldiers were arrested. Next time: should the soldiers get a fair trial, and who would defend them?
Exit ticket: write one fact about Crispus Attucks you are sure of and name the source.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 9, practice 10, person card 8.
Accuracy: NPS gives 1723 as his birth year and Framingham as his birthplace. Do not teach that he was a runaway as fact. Patrick Carr died days later; NPS pages give slightly different counts of days, so avoid an exact number. The trial quotation about the crowd is on the NPS page; do not read the slurs aloud. Describe them as insulting words about race and background.
Likely misconceptions: that the crowd was peaceful or that the soldiers fired for no reason (sources disagree and the trial weighed this); that Revere’s picture is a photograph.
Supports: sorting cards for Known / Possible. Stretch: find what the name Attucks suggests about his Native ancestry.
Answer guide: 1850s abolitionists used Attucks to show Black Americans’ role in the founding while slavery continued. Person cards cite NPS.
National Park Service, People: Crispus Attucks · U.S. government work, public domain
Crispus Attucks was a sailor of mixed African and Indigenous ancestry, born around 1723 in Framingham, Massachusetts. His last name likely comes from a Natick word for “deer.” The Park Service says his life is far less documented than his death.
A 1750 newspaper ad looked for a man named “Crispas” who had escaped slavery. It might be him, but this is not certain. No source from the time of his death calls him enslaved, and we do not know how he gained his freedom.
On the night of March 5, 1770, witnesses saw Attucks at the front of a group of sailors heading to King Street. A crowd threw snowballs, ice and insults at British soldiers. The soldiers fired. Two musket balls killed Attucks. Four other men died too.
Later, Black Bostonians made him a hero. In 1855, William Cooper Nell called him the first martyr of the Revolution, and Black Bostonians have marked March 5 since at least the 1850s. Boston still honors Crispus Attucks Day.
Source: National Park Service, People: Crispus Attucks (nps.gov)