describe conflict and cooperation between the Lenape (Delaware) Nation and the United States, using the 1778 Treaty of Fort Pitt as evidence.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Fort Pitt stood where the Allegheny and Monongahela rivers meet to form the Ohio River, in what is now downtown Pittsburgh, just a few miles from our school. In 1778 leaders of the Lenape (Delaware) Nation met American officials there. What might each side have wanted from the other?
The Treaty of Fort Pitt was made between the United States and which nation?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Native nations were independent nations. During the Revolution, Native nations such as the Lenape, the Shawnee and the six nations of the Haudenosaunee made their own decisions. Each one had to protect its land and its people while two armies fought around them. Some chose the British, some chose the Americans and some tried to stay neutral.
Settlement was the big pressure. Before the war, Britain had tried to limit settlement west of the Appalachian Mountains. Many colonists wanted that land. Native leaders could see that an American victory might bring more settlers. That helps explain why many Native nations sided with Britain.
Cooperation and conflict can happen in the same story. The Treaty of Fort Pitt was one of the earliest treaties between the United States and a Native nation. It began as cooperation. It ended in conflict. In 1782 Pennsylvania militia killed peaceful Christian Lenape men, women and children at a village called Gnadenhutten, in Ohio. Many Lenape then left the Ohio Valley.
Worked example 1: Sofia uses a detail as evidence. Sofia’s claim is: “At first, the Lenape and the Americans cooperated.” Her evidence: “The treaty promised peace and friendship, and the Lenape agreed to guide the army.” Her reasoning: “Guiding an army is a way of working together.”
Worked example 2: Jonah shows two points of view. Jonah writes a label sentence: “American leaders saw the signed paper as the finished deal. Lenape leaders saw it as the start of a relationship that needed care.” He does not pick a winner. He shows visitors why the sides disagreed.
Living nations today. The Lenape did not disappear. Their descendants include the Delaware Nation and the Delaware Tribe of Indians in Oklahoma and Lenape communities in Ontario, Canada. Our Native Nations gallery should end in the present, not the past.
Use the reading and a map of western Pennsylvania.
Draft a card for the Native Nations gallery or the Timeline Wall.
Write a card of 40 words or fewer about the Treaty of Fort Pitt. Include the date, the place, the Lenape leaders and what happened next.
Choose one detail from the reading and use it as evidence for this claim: “The United States did not keep its promises to the Lenape.”
A treaty is more than a paper. It is a promise, and promises have to be kept.
Exit ticket: why does it matter that this treaty was signed so close to where we live today?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, guided practice 12, card draft 8, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that all Native nations fought on one side; that the Lenape are only a people of the past; that a treaty settles things forever. Gnadenhutten was a massacre of about 96 peaceful people; mention it plainly and briefly, without graphic detail.
Supports: show Fort Pitt on a map (Point State Park today). Provide a T-chart for cooperation and conflict. Stretch: compare the two meanings of a treaty and explain why the difference mattered.
Answer guide: cooperation: guiding the army, the promise of peace and friendship. Conflict: White Eyes’s death, broken promises, settlers taking land, Gnadenhutten. Evidence for the claim: the trade goods never came, Congress never discussed the state, or settlers were not stopped. The exit ticket may connect the treaty to Pittsburgh’s place on Lenape and other Native lands. The Delaware Nation and Delaware Tribe of Indians are federally recognized nations in Oklahoma.
U.S. Department of State, National Museum of American Diplomacy, Treaty of Fort Pitt · U.S. government work, public domain
In 1778 the Continental Army planned to march west to attack the British fort at Detroit. The route crossed lands of the Lenape (Delaware) Nation in the Ohio Valley. So American officials met Lenape leaders at Fort Pitt, in western Pennsylvania. The leaders included White Eyes (Koquethagechton), John Killbuck (Gelelemend) and Captain Pipe (Hopocan).
On September 17, 1778, they signed a treaty. The Lenape agreed to let the army cross their land and to guide it. Both sides promised peace and friendship. The Americans promised a fort to protect Lenape families and trade goods. The treaty even raised the idea of a future state led by Native nations, with a voice in Congress.
The friendship did not last. White Eyes died soon after. Officials said it was smallpox, but evidence suggests he was killed by militia. The trade goods never came, Congress never discussed the new state, and settlers kept moving onto Lenape land. The two sides also saw the treaty differently. Americans saw the paper as the end of the deal. The Lenape saw it as the start of a relationship that needed care.
Source: U.S. Department of State, National Museum of American Diplomacy, Treaty of Fort Pitt (diplomacy.state.gov)