reflect on our museum and explain how the fight against slavery continued after the war, showing both change and continuity.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Read three visitor feedback cards from our museum opening. What did visitors learn? Whose story did they want to hear more about? Then read about what happened in Philadelphia a few years after the war.
After the war, when George Washington lived in Philadelphia as president, did he bring enslaved people with him?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reflection is how historians grow. Today we look back at our museum. What did we get right? Whose stories are still missing? What did visitors want to know more about?
The war ended, but the fight for freedom did not. The Revolution changed who governed the United States. It did not end slavery. In Pennsylvania the 1780 law slowly began to end it. In the South, slavery and cash crops such as tobacco and rice kept growing. Enslaved people like Hercules and Ona Judge kept resisting by escaping.
Ideas can change life over time. The Declaration’s words about equality and the Liberty Bell’s call for liberty became tools. Free Black Philadelphians, abolitionists and freedom seekers used those ideas to argue against slavery. A belief written in 1776 helped change life for later generations.
Worked example 1: Gabriela’s change-and-continuity sentence. Gabriela writes: “Change: by 1790 the United States was independent and its capital was in Philadelphia. Continuity: the president still held people in slavery, even in a state that had begun to end it.”
Worked example 2: Noah’s reflection. Noah writes: “Our museum showed many points of view. A visitor asked what happened to enslaved people after the war. Next time, we would add Ona Judge and Hercules to the Black Americans gallery, because they show resistance continued.” He uses feedback to plan an improvement.
Our driving question, one more time. How can a museum show the Revolution through the eyes of Patriots, Loyalists, enslaved and free Black Americans, Native nations and women? Your answer today is your own, built from everything you have learned.
Use the reading, the visitor cards and your panel.
Write your reflection.
Explain how slavery and resistance to it continued to shape the new nation after the war. Use Ona Judge or Hercules as evidence.
How did cash crops keep slavery growing in the southern states after the war, while Pennsylvania began to end it?
Answer our driving question in one paragraph: how can a museum show the Revolution through many eyes? Use one example from your own gallery.
History is not finished. Each generation asks new questions and finds people whose stories still need telling.
Exit ticket: what is one thing you now understand about the words “all men are created equal” that you did not understand at the start of this unit?
How confident are you that you can I can explain how many people shaped the Revolution and what it left unfinished.
Pacing: warm-up and feedback cards 7 minutes, reading 5, mini lecture 7, guided practice 10, reflection writing 8, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that slavery ended with independence; that Washington could not have avoided bringing enslaved people; that resistance was rare. Present Washington’s choices with evidence from the source and without name-calling; students can hold that he led the army and also enslaved people.
Supports: frames for reflection (“Our museum did ___ well. Next time we would ___ because ___.”). Be ready for strong feelings. Stretch: research the President’s House Site memorial on Independence Mall.
Answer guide: resistance answers should name an escape and its date and connect it to slavery continuing after 1783. Cash-crop answers: southern planters relied on enslaved labor to grow tobacco and rice, while Pennsylvania’s 1780 law began to end slavery slowly. Driving-question paragraphs should mention more than one point of view and evidence. Exit tickets often note that the words did not include everyone in 1776 but became a tool for people demanding freedom.
National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, President's House Site: Enslaved People in the Washington Household · U.S. government work, public domain
From 1790 to 1797, Philadelphia was the nation’s capital. President George Washington lived in a house near Independence Hall. Nine enslaved people from his Virginia home, Mount Vernon, lived and worked there. The National Park Service names each of them, including Hercules, Ona Judge, Austin, Moll and Christopher Sheels.
Hercules was the household’s skilled chief cook. In 1791 he learned he was being sent back to Virginia. The reason was Pennsylvania’s Gradual Abolition Act: staying in the state could have helped him gain his freedom by law. In early 1797 Hercules escaped. He was never recaptured.
Ona Judge was a talented seamstress who served Martha Washington. In 1796 she escaped from Philadelphia and made a new life in New Hampshire. Washington tried more than once to have her captured and brought back, but she stayed free. She married a free Black sailor and lived until 1848. She was remembered for her “abiding love of freedom.”
Source: National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, President's House Site: Enslaved People in the Washington Household (nps.gov)