describe who the framers were, what Franklin, Madison and Washington did at the Convention, and why the Convention kept its work secret.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. It is summer 1787 in Philadelphia. The doors of a meeting room are closed to the public, and no visitors or reporters are allowed inside. Why might leaders want to talk in secret?
Who do you think was chosen to lead the meeting?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
The framers. We call the delegates who wrote the Constitution framers, because they built the frame of our government. They were all men, and they were all white. Many were lawyers, merchants or planters, and some held people in slavery. They did not speak for everyone who lived in the nation.
Three key roles. Washington presided, which means he led the meetings. Madison arrived with ideas, helped shape the Virginia Plan and wrote down the debates, which is why we know so much today. Franklin, the oldest, often urged the delegates to compromise. On the last day he asked the doubters to doubt “a little of his own infallibility” and sign.
Pennsylvania’s delegation. Pennsylvania sent eight delegates, more than any other state, including Franklin, James Wilson, Gouverneur Morris and Robert Morris. You will meet Wilson and Gouverneur Morris again in this unit.
Worked example 1: a timeline. Lucia places the events in order: May 25, the Convention opens; May 29, the Virginia Plan; June 13, the New Jersey Plan; September 17, the signing. She notes that the work took almost four months.
Worked example 2: a role card. Ben writes a role card for Madison: “Came every day. Took the fullest notes. Helped plan three branches. Why it matters: his notes are one of our best sources on the debates.”
The room itself. The National Park Service, which cares for the building now called Independence Hall, says Washington sat in a chair carved with a sun. As the delegates signed, Franklin said he now knew it was a rising sun, not a setting one.
Use the reading and your timeline.
Make framer role cards for our guide’s timeline.
Write a role card for Franklin or Washington: what he did, and why it mattered.
The framers did not include women, Native nations or Black Americans. Write one question our guide should ask about whose voices were missing.
We know who was in the room. Next we watch big states and small states battle over votes.
Exit ticket: put three Convention events in order and explain what came between them.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, role cards 5.
Accuracy: the 55, 74, ages and dates come from the National Archives page. The rising-sun story and Washington’s chair come from the NPS Assembly Room page. The Franklin quotation is from the NPS day-by-day account for September 17, 1787. Pennsylvania’s eight delegates is a standard fact; their full list also includes Thomas Mifflin, George Clymer, Thomas FitzSimons and Jared Ingersoll.
Likely misconceptions: that Jefferson wrote the Constitution (he was in France); that the framers all agreed.
Supports: pre-printed timeline strips to order. Stretch: why would Madison’s private notes be both valuable and limited as a source?
Answer guide: secrecy let delegates change their minds without public pressure, but the public could not follow or respond.
National Archives, America's Founding Documents: The Constitution of the United States: A History · U.S. government work, public domain
On May 25, 1787, the Convention opened in the Pennsylvania State House in Philadelphia. The delegates all voted for George Washington to lead it.
States chose 74 delegates, and 55 came. Rhode Island sent no one. The average delegate was 42 years old. Benjamin Franklin, at 81, was the oldest, and Jonathan Dayton, at 27, was the youngest. James Madison of Virginia came every day and took the most complete notes of the debates. The meetings were closed to reporters and visitors.
On May 29, Edmund Randolph of Virginia offered the Virginia Plan. It called for three branches of government. On June 13, William Paterson offered the New Jersey Plan, which would only revise the Articles. The delegates rejected it.
After months of debate, the delegates signed the Constitution on September 17, 1787. Three delegates who were present, George Mason, Elbridge Gerry and Edmund Randolph, refused to sign. Then the states had to decide whether to approve it.
Source: National Archives, America's Founding Documents: The Constitution of the United States: A History (archives.gov)