use primary and secondary sources to separate facts from folklore and use peer critique to make our guide accurate and fair.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Many people believe the Liberty Bell rang on July 4, 1776, and cracked that day. Write whether you think that is true. Then read what the National Park Service says.
Is there evidence the Liberty Bell rang on July 4, 1776?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Today we critique like historians. Teams will swap drafts and check each claim. But first, a warm-up case: the Liberty Bell. It shows how a story can grow bigger than the evidence.
Corroborate. To corroborate means to check a claim against more than one source. If only a story says something happened, and no record from the time agrees, we call it folklore or fiction, not fact.
The bell’s meaning grew. At first it was a bell for the Pennsylvania State House. Abolitionists, people working to end slavery, gave it the name Liberty Bell in 1835. Women seeking the right to vote used a copy, the Justice Bell. As rights grew, the bell came to stand for more people.
Worked example 1: Hannah checks a claim. A draft says, “The Liberty Bell cracked when it rang on July 4, 1776.” Hannah checks the National Park Service page. She writes as feedback: “No evidence it rang that day, and the crack probably came in the 1840s. Try: The bell’s famous crack probably began in the early 1840s.”
Worked example 2: Dev gives kind, specific feedback. Dev uses our three-part frame: “I noticed your page names the Sixth Amendment and gives a school-safe example. I wonder which source told you a trial must be speedy. Next step: add the National Archives as your source.”
Critique rules. Be kind, be specific, be helpful. Check every claim against the criteria: accurate, fair, clear and complete. Flag any page that names a political party or candidate, or tells families what to think about a current political issue.
Check claims about the bell, then critique a partner’s draft.
Use your critique to plan revisions.
List the feedback you received. For each item, write what you will change and which source you will check.
Write a 60-word Liberty Bell card for our How Rights Grew section that separates fact from folklore and explains how the bell's meaning grew.
A good story is not the same as good evidence. Families deserve both.
Exit ticket: what is one claim in your own draft that you will corroborate before family night?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 7, bell checks 6, peer critique 13, revision plan 5, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that the bell cracked in 1776; that folklore is the same as lying (it can hold meaning even when it is not proved); that critique means criticism.
Supports: post the critique frame and model it with a sample draft. Pair readers thoughtfully. Watch for pages that drift into current political debates and redirect them to practical examples. Stretch: explain why the bell is a primary source about 1753 but not about July 4, 1776.
Answer guide: fact: ordered in 1751, recast and dated 1753, named by abolitionists in 1835, crack likely early 1840s, widened in 1846. Folklore: rang and cracked on July 4, 1776. Growth: abolitionists and suffragists used it as a symbol for people left out of liberty.
National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, The Liberty Bell · U.S. government work, public domain
In 1751 Isaac Norris, Speaker of the Pennsylvania Assembly, ordered a bell from a foundry in London. It cracked the first time it was tested. Two local metalworkers, John Pass and John Stow, melted it down and recast it in Philadelphia. The bell is dated 1753.
Its words come from the Bible: “Proclaim Liberty Throughout All the Land Unto All the Inhabitants thereof.” Norris may have chosen them to mark 50 years since William Penn’s 1701 Charter of Privileges.
What about the famous crack? No record shows exactly when or why it first cracked. The best guess is a thin crack in the early 1840s. A repair in 1846 widened it, and the bell has not rung freely since. The park says the bell likely rang about the Stamp Act, but there is no evidence it rang on July 4 or 8, 1776.
The name came later. In 1835 an antislavery magazine first called it the Liberty Bell. In 1847 a fictional story helped make it famous. In 1915 Pennsylvania women seeking the vote toured a copy called the Justice Bell, kept silent until the 19th Amendment passed.
“Proclaim LIBERTY throughout all the Land unto all the Inhabitants thereof Lev. XXV X.” (inscription on the Liberty Bell, as given by the National Park Service)
Source: National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, The Liberty Bell (nps.gov)