tell facts from opinions and legends in a historical account and explain how specific women shaped the Revolution.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. You may have heard of “Molly Pitcher,” a woman who carried water to soldiers and fired a cannon in battle. Was she one real person? Make a guess, then read what the National Archives found.
Was Molly Pitcher one real, single person?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Three kinds of statements. A fact can be checked with evidence: “Congress gave Margaret Corbin a pension on July 6, 1779.” An opinion is what someone thinks or feels: “She was the bravest person in the war.” A legend is a story told so often that people believe it, even though the evidence is weak or missing.
Women shaped the war in many ways. About 400 women traveled with the army at Valley Forge. Women cooked, washed, nursed the sick and carried water. A few fought. At home, women ran farms and shops, refused to buy British goods and raised money for soldiers. Some women were Loyalists, and enslaved women made their own choices about escape and freedom.
Historians check the record. Records such as the journals of Congress, pension files and soldiers’ diaries are strong evidence. A story first written down many years later, with no record behind it, is weaker evidence.
Worked example 1: Lucia sorts a label. Lucia’s draft says: “Molly Pitcher was the greatest hero ever. Washington made her a sergeant. Mary Hays carried water at Monmouth.” She sorts it: the first sentence is an opinion, the second is a legend with no record, and the third is a fact the article supports. She keeps the fact and labels the legend.
Worked example 2: Andre writes about one person. Andre writes: “Margaret Corbin fought at Fort Washington after her husband was killed. Congress gave her a pension in 1779. This shows that Congress recognized a woman’s service in battle.” He explains how one specific person shaped history.
Our museum rule: label legends as legends. We can include a famous story, but we must tell visitors what the records show and what they do not.
Sort each statement. Use the reading.
Check your own panel.
Copy two sentences from your draft label. Mark each as fact, opinion or legend. Fix any sentence that states a legend or opinion as fact.
Write a 40-word card that tells visitors the true record behind the Molly Pitcher story.
Good historians honor brave people by telling their stories truthfully.
Exit ticket: why might a story grow into a legend over many years?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 8, career note 2, guided practice 11, panel check 8, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that opinions are always wrong (they are fine when labeled); that legends are lies (they often grow from real events); that women did not take part in the war.
Supports: give a three-column sorting chart (fact, opinion, legend). Stretch: find another woman of the Revolution, such as Deborah Sampson, who is also named in the article, and check her story.
Answer guide: person responses should name a woman such as Margaret Corbin or Mary Ludwig Hays with a checkable fact and its importance (for example, Congress recognizing a woman’s service). Exit tickets may say that people retell stories, add details and combine several people into one. The 400 women at Valley Forge figure comes from the National Park Service Valley Forge history page. Career facts come from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Occupational Outlook Handbook page on archivists, curators and museum workers.
National Archives, Prologue Magazine, Summer 1999, Will the Real Molly Pitcher Please Stand Up? · National Archives publication; retold in our own words with a link to the source
Two real women are often linked to the name Molly Pitcher. Records support much of their stories.
Margaret Corbin went with her husband, John, to the Battle of Fort Washington in New York. When he was killed, she took his place firing a cannon and was badly wounded. On July 6, 1779, the Continental Congress voted to give her half a soldier’s monthly pay. She was the first woman to receive a pension, or regular payment, from Congress.
Mary Ludwig Hays was the daughter of German immigrants. At the Battle of Monmouth in New Jersey in 1778, she carried water to tired soldiers and took her husband’s place at a cannon. Many years later, Pennsylvania gave her a yearly pension of forty dollars. She died near Carlisle, Pennsylvania, in 1833.
Some popular stories go further than the records. One says George Washington made Mary Hays a sergeant. The article says military records show no evidence of that. One historian suggests “Molly Pitcher” became a legend built from the brave acts of many women, a nickname for all of them.
Source: National Archives, Prologue Magazine, Summer 1999, Will the Real Molly Pitcher Please Stand Up? (archives.gov)