explain the difference between a direct democracy and a republic and compare how each makes rules, using James Madison’s Federalist No. 10.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Our class can vote on a game for Friday in two minutes. Could all the people in Pennsylvania vote that way on every law? What would get hard?
What did Madison think worked better for a large nation?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two ways to make rules. In a direct democracy, citizens vote on laws themselves. In a republic, also called a representative democracy, citizens elect representatives who make the laws. The United States and Pennsylvania are republics, though some decisions, such as approving changes to the Pennsylvania Constitution, go directly to voters.
Strengths of each. Direct democracy lets everyone speak for themselves, and it works well in small groups. A republic works for millions of people, lets representatives study issues full time, and, Madison argued, cools sudden passions and protects minority rights.
Majority rule and minority rights. In both systems the majority usually decides. But a fair government also protects the rights of those who lose a vote. Madison worried about factions that might trample others’ rights.
Worked example 1: a direct decision. Hannah’s class votes by show of hands on where to plant a class garden. Every student votes. She writes, “This is direct democracy, because everyone decided in person.”
Worked example 2: a representative decision. Our borough council votes on whether to fix a playground. Residents elected the council members to make that choice. Diego writes, “This is a republic, because people chose representatives to decide for them.”
Your CER today. Answer: which way of making rules fits a group of 25? Which fits a state of millions? Use Madison’s two differences as evidence.
Sort examples, then build your CER.
Sort and explain.
Label each as direct or representative: a school-wide vote on a mascot, the Pennsylvania House passing a law, a borough council choosing library hours, a club voting on a field trip day. Explain one choice.
Madison trusted structure to protect rights. Next we read his famous line about angels.
Exit ticket: why is majority rule not enough on its own to keep a government fair?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 8, sort 8, CER 9.
Accuracy: the date, newspaper and definitions are from the LoC full text of No. 10. Pennsylvania constitutional amendments require approval by voters (standard fact). Keep Madison’s argument as his argument; Anti-Federalists argued that a large republic would be too distant from the people, which 2.13 presents.
Nonpartisan: use local, practical decisions (playgrounds, library hours). Do not use current party issues.
Likely misconceptions: that ‘republic’ and ‘democracy’ are total opposites; that the U.S. is not democratic at all.
Answer guide: strong CERs choose a system, cite a difference (delegation to elected few or larger scale) and reason about size and fairness.
Library of Congress, Research Guides: Federalist Papers: Primary Documents in American History, Full Text of The Federalist Papers, Nos. 1-10 · Public domain historical text; Library of Congress guide
After the Convention, the Constitution had to be approved by the states. To win support in New York, Alexander Hamilton, James Madison and John Jay wrote 85 essays under the pen name “Publius.” They ran in New York newspapers in 1787 and 1788 and are called the Federalist Papers.
Federalist No. 10, by Madison, appeared in the New York Packet on November 23, 1787. Madison describes a pure democracy as a society of a small number of citizens who gather and run the government in person.
He describes a republic as a government in which “the scheme of representation takes place.” That means people choose others to represent them.
Madison names two big differences. First, in a republic, the people hand the work of governing to a small number of citizens they elect. Second, a republic can stretch over many more citizens and a much larger country. Madison argued that a large republic could better control factions, groups that push their own interests against the rights of others or the good of all.
“The two great points of difference between a democracy and a republic are:” —James Madison, Federalist No. 10
Source: Library of Congress, Research Guides: Federalist Papers: Primary Documents in American History, Full Text of The Federalist Papers, Nos. 1-10 (guides.loc.gov)