explain what the Three-Fifths Clause did, why delegates argued over it, and how it gave more power to slaveholding states.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. The first census, in 1790, counted about 700,000 enslaved people in the United States, most of them in the South. Enslaved people could not vote. If seats in the House depend on how many people live in a state, should a state get seats for people it does not allow to vote?
Which states do you think wanted enslaved people counted in full?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
What the clause said. The final Constitution said House seats would be based on the number of free persons, plus “three fifths of all other Persons.” The framers never wrote the word “slave,” but “all other Persons” meant enslaved people. On July 12, the delegates approved the three-fifths count, tied to direct taxes and a census every ten years.
What it did, and did not, mean. The clause was about power, not about how much of a person anyone was. Enslaved people were whole human beings with families, skills, faith and hopes. They could not vote at all. Counting them gave extra seats in Congress to the white voters and enslavers of their states, the very people who held them in slavery.
Other protections for slavery. On August 29, the NPS records, delegates made a bargain: Congress could not ban the slave trade from Africa until 1808. They also passed, without debate, a clause requiring that people who escaped slavery to another state be returned. Freedom-seekers who reached a free state could still be sent back.
Worked example 1: comparing viewpoints. Naomi lines up two speakers. Butler wanted a full count to give South Carolina more seats. Morris opposed counting enslaved people because it would reward the slave trade. She writes, “Both talked about seats, but Morris also called slavery unjust.”
Worked example 2: a careful claim. Andre starts to write that the Constitution said enslaved people were three-fifths of a person. He checks the words and fixes it: “The clause counted three-fifths of enslaved people to decide seats. It gave slaveholding states more power while enslaved people had no voice.”
Change over time. After the Civil War, the Thirteenth Amendment ended slavery in 1865, and the Fourteenth Amendment replaced the three-fifths rule with counting “the whole number of persons.”
Use the reading and the mini lesson. This is hard history, so speak carefully and respectfully.
Write an accurate entry for our guide.
Write three sentences for families: what the Three-Fifths Clause said, who gained power from it, and what later changed it.
Fix this false sentence: “The Constitution said enslaved people were three-fifths of a person.” Explain your fix.
While delegates debated, free Black Philadelphians were building their own institutions a short walk away. Next we meet them.
Exit ticket: how did the Three-Fifths Clause give more power to slaveholding states?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 12, guided practice 10, exit 3.
Approach: no role-play. Students analyze recorded arguments; they do not argue as delegates for or against slavery. Keep enslaved people’s humanity at the center and avoid images of people in distress.
Accuracy: the 1790 census counted about 700,000 enslaved people; use that as an approximate figure for 1787. July 12 vote and Aug. 29 bargain and fugitive clause are from the NPS day-by-day pages for those dates. Morris’s stated reasons mixed moral objection and regional power; say so. The clause also applied to direct taxes.
Likely misconceptions: the ‘three-fifths of a person’ wording; that Northern delegates all opposed slavery; that the Constitution used the word slave.
Supports: a two-column viewpoint chart. Stretch: why did Wilson say the problem had to be set aside? Was that a fair price for union?
Answer guide: strong answers state that counting enslaved people added seats for slaveholding states while enslaved people had no vote, and name a later change (13th or 14th Amendment).
National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park: The Constitutional Convention: A Day by Day Account · U.S. government work, public domain
On July 11, 1787, delegates argued about the census, the count of people that would decide each state’s seats. One hard question was how to count enslaved people.
Pierce Butler and Charles Cotesworth Pinckney of South Carolina wanted enslaved people counted fully. They argued that enslaved people’s labor created as much value as free people’s. Other delegates, including Elbridge Gerry of Massachusetts, George Mason of Virginia and Gouverneur Morris of Pennsylvania, preferred counting three-fifths, for different reasons. Morris warned that giving states seats for enslaved people would encourage the slave trade, which he called an injustice to human nature.
James Wilson of Pennsylvania asked a sharp question. If enslaved people were counted as citizens, why were they not treated as citizens? If they were counted as property, why was other property not counted? Still, he said the problem had to be set aside to reach a compromise.
That day, a motion to use three-fifths failed, four states to six. The question stayed open, and the delegates kept arguing.
“Are they admitted as citizens—then why is not other property admitted into the computation?” —James Wilson (PA), as quoted by the National Park Service
Source: National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park: The Constitutional Convention: A Day by Day Account (nps.gov)