compare Federalist and Anti-Federalist views on ratification and explain how the Pennsylvania minority’s proposals, including fair-trial rights, pointed toward the Bill of Rights.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. You are asked to approve a new set of school rules. They explain who is in charge, but they do not list any student rights. Would you vote yes, vote no, or ask for changes first?
Pennsylvania voted on the Constitution in December 1787. What do you think happened?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two sides. Supporters of the Constitution called themselves Federalists. They said the nation needed a stronger government and that the Constitution’s limits, like separation of powers, already protected rights. Opponents, called Anti-Federalists, feared a distant national government could overpower the states and the people without a written list of rights.
Pennsylvania moves early. The National Archives reports that Pennsylvania ratified on December 12, 1787, by a vote of 46 to 23, the second state to do so. James Wilson argued for the Constitution. Writings signed “Centinel” argued against it, mainly because it had no bill of rights.
The result. The demand for rights did not go away. James Madison led the First Congress to propose amendments, and on December 15, 1791, the states ratified ten of them: the Bill of Rights. Several matched the Pennsylvania minority’s ideas, such as free speech, a speedy trial by jury, and limits on searches.
Worked example 1: comparing viewpoints. Isabel writes: “A Federalist would say the structure protects rights. The Pennsylvania minority said rights should be written down. Both wanted liberty, but they disagreed about how to protect it.”
Worked example 2: a fair-trial right. Caleb explains one proposal for families: “If you are accused of a crime, you should know the charges, have a lawyer and face the witnesses. That makes trials fair, so innocent people are less likely to be punished.”
Your CER. Who helped American liberty more in the end: the Federalists, the Anti-Federalists, or both? There is evidence for more than one answer. Choose and defend yours.
Use the reading and the mini lesson. Remember to show both sides fairly.
Draft a ‘Right in Our Lives’ card for the guide.
Pick one proposal from the Pennsylvania minority. Explain it in plain words and give an everyday example of why it protects people.
Next we look at how Americans honor the nation and its laws, and pull our big ideas together.
Exit ticket: how did people who opposed the Constitution end up helping to improve it?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 8, practice 8, CER 9.
Accuracy: the vote, the Centinel essays and the 1791 date come from the National Archives page used in 2.04. The CSAC page gives the minority’s account of the procedure; the majority’s view differed, so present it as the minority’s claim. The minority’s address was printed December 18, 1787. Part 2 teaches the Bill of Rights in depth.
Nonpartisan: Federalists and Anti-Federalists are historical groups, not today’s parties. Grade the CER on evidence and reasoning, not on which side a student chooses.
Answer guide: strong CERs use one detail per side, such as Federalist trust in structure and the minority’s list of rights, and note that the Bill of Rights came from that debate.
Center for the Study of the American Constitution, University of Wisconsin-Madison: Dissent of the Minority of the Convention of Pennsylvania, 12 December 1787 · 1787 document in the public domain; page copyright Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin System; summarized in our own words with a link
Pennsylvania’s ratifying convention met in late 1787. Delegates who opposed the Constitution, called the minority, said the majority would not let them propose changes or record their objections. They could only vote yes or no on the whole plan.
So the minority published fourteen proposals. They asked for freedom of conscience, which means freedom of religious belief. They asked for trial by jury. For people accused of crimes, they wanted the right to know the charges, to have a lawyer, to face the witnesses and to have a speedy trial by a fair local jury. No one should be forced to testify against himself.
They also asked for no excessive bail or cruel punishments, limits on searches without good evidence, and freedom of speech and the press. Other proposals would keep powers with the states, such as running their own militias and elections, and keep the three branches separate.
The minority feared that without these protections, the people would be giving up their “dearest rights.”
Source: Center for the Study of the American Constitution, University of Wisconsin-Madison: Dissent of the Minority of the Convention of Pennsylvania, 12 December 1787 (csac.history.wisc.edu)