explain how a tax makes the price of a good go up, using the Sugar Act and the Stamp Act as evidence.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A store sells a notebook for $2. A new rule says the store must pay 50 cents to the government for every notebook it sells. What do you think happens to the price the store charges you?
What usually happens to the price when sellers must pay a tax on each item?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A tax on goods. A tax is money people must pay to the government. When a tax is placed on each item sold, sellers usually raise their price to cover it. Buyers end up paying some or all of the tax.
Two kinds of tax. The Sugar Act taxed goods coming into the colonies from other places. The Stamp Act was new: it taxed paper goods made and used inside the colonies. Before this, only the colonies’ own assemblies had set inside taxes.
Worked example 1 (sample numbers). Lena imagines a printer who sells a newspaper for 2 pennies. A stamp tax adds 1 penny for each paper. If the printer passes the whole tax on, the new price is 2 + 1 = 3 pennies. She writes, “The tax raised the price by half.” These numbers are sample numbers to practice the idea; they are not real 1765 prices.
Worked example 2: a real tax rate that went down. Darius notices the molasses tax was cut from 6 pence to 3 pence. He asks why people were angrier, not happier. The reading explains: the old tax was rarely collected, but the new one was strictly enforced. Paying 3 pence is more than paying nothing.
Where it hit. Rum makers and merchants in New England felt the Sugar Act. Printers, lawyers and anyone buying newspapers or cards felt the Stamp Act. The colonies’ different trades meant different people felt each tax.
Not only about money. Colonists elected no members to Parliament. Many argued that only their own elected assemblies had the right to tax them. That is what “no taxation without representation” means.
Use the reading. For number questions, show your work.
Make a Tax and Price Card for our museum’s Timeline Wall.
Choose one taxed good (molasses, newspapers, playing cards or legal papers). Using sample numbers, show its price before and after a tax. Label your numbers “sample.” Then explain who would pay more.
In two sentences, explain why colonists said a tax was unfair even when it was small.
Taxes raised prices, and they raised tempers. Next time we see what colonists did about it.
Exit ticket: explain to a neighbor, in one sentence, how a tax on paper could make a newspaper cost more.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 8, practice 12, card 7.
Accuracy: all dollar and penny prices in this lesson are sample numbers and must stay labeled. Real figures from the reading: debt near 140 million pounds; 200,000 pounds a year for 10,000 soldiers; molasses 6 to 3 pence per gallon; Revere’s income 102 to 60 pounds. 12 pence made 1 shilling and 20 shillings made 1 pound.
Likely misconceptions: that a lower tax rate always means people pay less (enforcement matters); that colonists objected only to the money (they also objected to who had the right to tax).
Supports: number line or counters for price problems. Stretch: if the seller pays half the tax and the buyer pays half, what is the new price in the card example? (7 pennies.)
Answer guide: the Revere detail shows falling income while costs and taxes rose. Fairness answers mention no elected members in Parliament and consent.
National Park Service, Boston National Historical Park, Britain Begins Taxing the Colonies: The Sugar and Stamp Acts · U.S. government work, public domain
After the Seven Years’ War, Britain owed a huge debt, close to 140 million pounds. Leaders also wanted about 200,000 pounds a year to keep 10,000 soldiers in America. They decided the colonies should help pay.
The Sugar Act of 1764 cut the tax on foreign molasses from 6 pence to 3 pence a gallon, but it was strictly enforced, so more colonists actually paid. It banned foreign rum and taxed foreign wine, coffee and cloth. This hit New England, where making rum from molasses was a major business.
The Stamp Act of 1765 taxed things made and used inside the colonies: legal papers, newspapers, pamphlets, playing cards and dice. Each needed a stamp to show the tax was paid.
Times were already hard. Paul Revere’s income from his silver shop fell from 102 pounds in 1764 to 60 pounds in 1765. Colonists cried “No taxation without representation.” Lawyer James Otis argued that taxes could be laid only with the people’s consent, or agreement.
“Taxes are not to be laid on the people, but by their consent in person, or by deputation.” — James Otis, 1764, quoted by the National Park Service
Source: National Park Service, Boston National Historical Park, Britain Begins Taxing the Colonies: The Sugar and Stamp Acts (nps.gov)