The Bill of Rights in Our Lives Guide
How can we make a guide that shows families how the Constitution and Bill of Rights protect people today, and how rights grew over time?
The mystery: The government under the Articles of Confederation could not even pay its soldiers. Why did leaders who met in Philadelphia in 1787 end up writing a whole new plan?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
explain the causes and results of Shays’ Rebellion and sort our Wonder Board questions by the sources that could answer them.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Picture a farmer who fought in the Revolution. He comes home and finds he owes heavy taxes and fees he cannot pay. He could lose his farm. What choices does he have?
What do you think some of these farmers did?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Causes and results. Historians ask what caused an event and what it caused in turn. A cause is a reason something happens. A result is what happens because of it. One event can have several causes.
Two sides of the story. To the farmers, the taxes felt unfair, especially to veterans who had served the nation. To state leaders, the taxes paid real war debts, and an armed attack threatened everyone’s safety. Both sides wanted the government to work for the common good, but they disagreed about what that meant.
Why the whole nation noticed. Under the Articles, Congress had no money and no strong army of its own to help a state keep order. Leaders in other states worried that the same thing could happen to them.
Worked example 1: a cause chain. Ana builds a chain: “War debt led to heavy taxes. Heavy taxes left farmers unable to pay. Unpaid debts and anger led to protests and the attack. The attack worried leaders across the states.” Each link explains the next.
Worked example 2: sourcing. Jamal asks who made today’s reading. It is a National Park Service page written in 2012, long after 1787. He decides it is a secondary source, useful for the main facts. To hear the farmers’ own words, he notes, we would need primary sources such as their petitions.
Today’s workshop. We will sort the Wonder Board into groups: questions for founding documents, for notes from the Convention, for maps and data, and for the voices of people left out of the debates.
Use the reading and your cause chain. Talk with your team before you answer.
Make your own cause chain.
Draw a chain of four boxes, from war debt to leaders calling for a stronger government. Write one sentence in each box.
Choose one Wonder Board question. Which kind of source could help answer it, and why?
Our questions are sorted. Next we look at how Pennsylvanians wrote their own state plan of government in 1776.
Exit ticket: how did Shays' Rebellion show a weakness of the Articles of Confederation?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, Wonder Board sorting 12, exit ticket 5.
Setup: make a four-column chart: founding documents; Convention notes; maps and data; voices left out.
Likely misconceptions: that the rebels were simply criminals or simply heroes; that Shays’ Rebellion alone caused the Constitution (it added urgency to plans already under way). The reading gives no casualty count; do not invent one.
Supports: provide a cause-chain organizer with the first box filled in. Stretch: what could a government do to collect needed taxes fairly?
Answer guide: strong responses link debt and taxes to the uprising and the uprising to calls for a stronger government. Accept answers that see both fairness and safety concerns if they use a detail.
National Park Service, Springfield Armory National Historic Site: Rebellion at the Springfield Arsenal · U.S. government work, public domain
This page comes from Springfield Armory National Historic Site, a national park in Springfield, Massachusetts. It was written in 2012 to mark the anniversary of an event from January 1787.
After the Revolutionary War, Massachusetts owed money from the war. To pay that debt, the state put heavy taxes and fees on its people. Daniel Shays was one of many people who struggled to support a family under these burdens. Many of the protesters were veterans who had just come home from the war.
For a long time they tried to fix what they saw as unfair treatment. Then Shays and others turned to force. In January 1787 they tried to storm and take over the Springfield Arsenal, a place where weapons were stored. The attempt failed. The page says the uprising ended in loss of life and came close to disaster for the state.
The page explains that leaders saw how close the new nation had come to falling into disorder. The bloodshed and anger helped lead to a stronger central government and a national constitution.
Source: National Park Service, Springfield Armory National Historic Site: Rebellion at the Springfield Arsenal (nps.gov)