compare the choices enslaved and free Black Americans made in the war and explain the limits of the freedom each side offered.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. In 1775, Virginia’s royal governor promised freedom to some enslaved people who joined the British. Write one question you would ask about that promise before you trusted it.
Did Lord Dunmore's 1775 offer free everyone who was enslaved in Virginia?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A choice about freedom. For enslaved people, the biggest question was often not “king or Congress?” It was “Which path can bring my family freedom?” Some joined the British. Some, like Peter Salem, fought for the Patriots. Many escaped when war gave them a chance.
Sourcing the proclamation. Who: Lord Dunmore, Virginia’s royal governor. When: 1775, as fighting spread. Why: to weaken the rebels. So the proclamation was not an attack on slavery itself. It was a war plan that some people used to win their own freedom.
Two points of view. To enslaved people it was a doorway. To many white Patriots in Virginia it was a threat to the slavery their wealth depended on. The Declaration of Independence later complained that the king had “excited domestic insurrections amongst us,” words historians connect to offers like Dunmore’s.
Worked example 1: comparing two paths. Zainab compares Peter Salem with the Ethiopian Regiment. She writes, “Both chose a side that offered them freedom. Salem was freed to fight for the Patriots. Dunmore’s soldiers fled rebel enslavers to fight for the British. Neither side offered freedom to everyone.”
Worked example 2: a careful claim. Leo first writes, “The British freed the slaves.” He revises: “The British offered freedom to some people enslaved by rebels, and about 3,000 Black refugees left New York with the British in 1783.” The new claim matches the evidence.
Centering people. Behind every number is a person who took a huge risk to be free. Our gallery will use names and choices, not only numbers.
Use the reading and your Peter Salem card from 1.09.
Write a CER for the Black Americans gallery.
Question: Did either side in the war offer real freedom to enslaved people? Write a claim, two pieces of evidence (one from 1.09 and one from today) and your reasoning.
Black Americans made hard choices on both sides. Next time we see how Native nations faced the same war.
Exit ticket: in one sentence, explain why Dunmore's offer was both a real chance at freedom and a limited one.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 9, practice 10, CER 8.
Accuracy: Dunmore’s proclamation is dated November 7, 1775; the NPS page gives only the year. “Book of Negroes” is the historical title of the record; explain that Negro was a word used then and that we say Black Americans today. NPS says refugees who reached the British before November 30, 1782, were promised freedom. The “domestic insurrections” phrase is quoted from the Declaration transcript used in 1.14.
Sensitivity: no role-play of escape or enslavement. Do not ask students to pretend to be enslaved; ask them to analyze choices from evidence.
Likely misconceptions: that the British were against slavery; that all Black Americans were Patriots, or all were Loyalists.
Supports: a Venn diagram for the comparison. Stretch: explain why the same document looked different to different groups.
Answer guide: a strong CER says neither side offered freedom to all: Dunmore excluded people enslaved by Loyalists, and Washington stopped recruiting enslaved people in 1775, yet many people used the war to gain freedom.
National Park Service, Fort Stanwix National Monument blog, From Bondage to Freedom, or Fighting for Their Independence in a Different Way · U.S. government work, public domain
In 1775, Lord Dunmore, the last royal governor of Virginia, offered freedom to enslaved people in Virginia who escaped from rebel owners and joined British forces. His offer, called a proclamation, inspired enslaved people in other southern colonies to run away too.
The offer had limits. It did not free people enslaved by Loyalists, and those who fled Loyalists were sent back. Dunmore’s goals were military: to hurt the rebels’ supplies, spread fear among them and keep men from joining the Patriot army.
Men who joined Dunmore formed the Ethiopian Regiment. It saw limited action in Virginia in 1775 and was broken up in New York in 1776. Other Black units, such as the Black Pioneers, built roads and forts for the British.
Near the end of the war, the British recorded the names of Black refugees in the “Book of Negroes” and gave them certificates of freedom. About 3,000 people left New York with the British in 1783. Most went to Nova Scotia, where they found freedom but little justice. In 1792, more than 1,200 settled in Sierra Leone in Africa.
Source: National Park Service, Fort Stanwix National Monument blog, From Bondage to Freedom, or Fighting for Their Independence in a Different Way (home.nps.gov)